Trump administration takes California ballot fight to Supreme Court
Nov 2 -
asserted
administration → take → Court
President Donald Trump's administration asked the US Supreme Court on Monday to temporarily block California from counting mail-in ballots from more than 20,000 registered voters who federal officials allege are likely non-US citizens.
asserted
officials → ask → voters
Escalating a legal fight that could affect thousands of voters in the November 3 midterm elections, the Justice Department filed the emergency request as it seeks to prevent counting the disputed ballots until each voter's citizenship status can be verified.
uncertain
status → escalate → ballots
A federal appeals court refused the request on Friday.
asserted
court → refuse → Friday
Trump's fellow Republicans are fighting to retain control of Congress in the midterms.
asserted
Republicans → fight → midterms
The administration has intensified its focus on alleged noncitizen voting in the run-up to the midterms.
asserted
administration → intensify → midterms
Trump has made false claims about widespread US voting fraud including in the 2020 election lost to Democrat Joe Biden.
uncertain
Trump → make → Biden
Multiple studies and state audits show that ineligible voting, including by noncitizens, is rare.
asserted
voting → show → noncitizens
The US Constitution assigns the responsibility of administering elections to states, though the federal government has some oversight.
asserted
government → assign → oversight
The lawsuit marked a rare federal intervention in the voting process and signaled a willingness by the administration to contest the election results in court.
asserted
lawsuit → mark → court
The administration already sought to restrict voting by mail — a mode of casting ballots used more often by Democratic-leaning voters — but the Supreme Court in September rebuffed that effort.
asserted
Court → seek → effort
The list of 20,000 registered voters was amassed by the US Department of Homeland Security and sent to California officials and to Los Angeles County officials.
asserted
list → register → officials
The Justice Department sued in federal court on October 15, claiming California is unlawfully preventing its enforcement of a 1996 US law that makes it a criminal offense for noncitizens to vote in federal elections.
asserted
noncitizens → sue → elections
The department said California's action violated the US Constitution's Supremacy Clause, which holds that federal law generally preempts state law.
asserted
law → say → law
The administration asked the Supreme Court to order California to separate any ballots cast by people on the list from other ballots, and not to count them until those voters are verified as citizens.
asserted
voters → ask → citizens
"Once illegally cast ballots are counted and commingled with lawful votes, the resulting harm is impossible to remedy," the Justice Department wrote in a filing in the case.
asserted
Department → cast → case
California has said that the state's safeguards against noncitizen voting are robust and that the lawsuit threatens to deprive 20,000 people of their right to vote based on vague accusations.
asserted
lawsuit → say → accusations
The administration's process for scrutinizing voter lists to identify noncitizens is flawed and likely rife with errors, it said in court papers.
asserted
it → scrutinize → papers
'BEND TO THE WILL'
US District Judge David Carter in Los Angeles denied the administration's request on October 28.
asserted
Carter → bend → October
"Never before in American history has the federal government, on the eve of an election, sought to coerce a state and local government to abandon their own constitutional elections procedures and bend to the will of the executive branch," Carter wrote.
asserted
Carter → seek → branch
Carter raised concerns over the reliability of the administration's data, noting that people recently flagged by the federal government as noncitizens on voter rolls in other states have repeatedly turned out to be naturalized US citizens.
"If the executive can discount votes and threaten an ongoing election due to unproven allegations, then our democracy is in danger," Carter wrote.
asserted
Carter → raise → danger
The San Francisco-based 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals also refused on Friday to block the ballots, emphasizing the state's power over election procedures and California's "comprehensive statutory scheme to ensure the integrity of its elections," including a system for canceling registrations if a voter is shown to be ineligible.
asserted
voter → base → registrations
Siding with the administration could result in disenfranchisement "and could jeopardize the county's entire election," the 9th Circuit said.
uncertain
Circuit → side → election
The Supreme Court's review of the administration's emergency request could take into account the short time frame before Election Day.
uncertain
review → take → Day
In September, the justices barred Missouri from using a redrawn map of the state's House districts designed to favor Republicans in the midterms.
asserted
justices → bar → midterms
Reinstating that map "in the midst of an ongoing election would usher in electoral chaos," the court said in that ruling.
asserted
court → reinstate → ruling
ADMINISTRATION DEMANDS
The administration has taken an increasingly aggressive approach toward how states run elections.
asserted
states → take → elections
The Justice Department has told election officials in all 50 states that they could face criminal prosecution if they knowingly allow noncitizens to remain on their rolls or cast ballots.
uncertain
noncitizens → tell → ballots
It has lost a series of lawsuits seeking to obtain voter rolls, including sensitive personal information, from dozens of states.
asserted
It → lose → states
A Reuters investigation published in July found just 129 cases in which noncitizens had been charged with voting illegally since the passage of a 1996 federal law criminalizing such conduct.
asserted
noncitizens → publish → conduct
Many appeared to stem from voter confusion or administrative errors, rather than intentional fraud.
asserted
Many → appear → fraud
Trump has made California a focal point of his sweeping immigration crackdown.
asserted
California → make → crackdown
California has 52 seats in the House of Representatives, more than any other state.
asserted
California → have → state
Democrats need a net gain of four House seats to win a majority in the chamber.
asserted
Democrats → need → chamber
The Aporia
