Premier Danielle Smith’s government has taken the first steps to approve Alberta’s new electoral map, unanimously voting to move forward with the redrawn boundaries emerging from a process that has faced charges of gerrymandering.
asserted
that → take → gerrymandering
Ms. Smith’s governing United Conservative Party voted on Wednesday night to approve a motion that will result in the government creating a bill to put the map into law.
asserted
government → govern → law
The Alberta NDP voted against the motion.
asserted
NDP → vote → motion
The new map has added four new seats and will likely benefit Ms. Smith’s UCP – particularly owing to a slate of changes in Calgary’s northwest and in Lethbridge.
asserted
map → add → Lethbridge
It has also ignited fierce debate over a process that’s traditionally a sleepy affair.
asserted
that → ignite → process
Ms. Smith forced a redraw of the map in April, a decision she said was motivated by a desire to preserve rural voters’ electoral representation in light of massive population gains in Alberta’s two major cities, Calgary and Edmonton.
asserted
she → force → cities
But her decision has triggered questions about the process itself, with critics voicing concerns that the latest redrawing effort has not followed Alberta’s traditionally independent and transparent procedures.
asserted
effort → trigger → procedures
Analysis by The Globe and Mail shows that under the most recent election results, the latest map would not tilt the political playing field as severely as some expected in April when Ms. Smith rejected the previously proposed map and restarted the process.
asserted
Smith → show → process
Specific changes to the map, however, would provide an advantage to the UCP while significantly diluting the power of voters in urban centres, where support for the Alberta NDP is most concentrated.
asserted
support → provide → NDP
Calgary, where some of those changes are centred, is expected to be the battleground where next October’s provincial election is won.
asserted
election → centre → changes
Earlier this week, Ms. Smith said she didn’t want urban representation to come at the expense of the rest of the province: “We did not want rural Alberta to be under-represented.”
asserted
Alberta → say → province
The Alberta NDP has promised the map will end up in court.
asserted
map → promise → court
Ms. Smith has batted away accusations of gerrymandering and endorsed the changes.
asserted
Smith → bat → changes
Alberta’s elections agency has warned it doesn’t have enough time to implement the new map, even without the prospect of a legal challenge.
asserted
it → warn → challenge
Brian O’Ferrall, a retired judge and chair of the most recent five-person panel, wrote in the report of “unnecessary and counter-productive controversy” that dogged the five-person group as it attempted to redraw the map.
asserted
it → write → map
He dismissed accusations of gerrymandering at several turns.
asserted
He → dismiss → turns
Meanwhile, the two panelists selected by the NDP – University of Alberta constitutional law professor Gerard Kennedy and former Okotoks, Alta., town councillor Brent Robinson – wrote a separate report suggesting that aspects of the new map would be “constitutionally fraught.”
asserted
aspects → select → map
“This 2025-26 Alberta redistricting process has pushed the envelope of democratic norms,” they wrote, adding that adopting the new map “will likely force the courts to enter this fray.”
asserted
adopting → push → fray
It is unclear what effect the new map would have on the outcome of next October’s provincial election, as political tides continue to shift in Alberta.
uncertain
tides → have → Alberta
But applying the 2023 provincial election results to the new map, the UCP would hold on to its majority with a similar 11-seat margin over the NDP.
asserted
UCP → apply → NDP
Some of the deepest divisions on the latest panel were over changes to Lethbridge and Calgary, where three panelists proposed to blend the cities’ suburban neighbourhoods with rural communities.
asserted
panelists → propose → communities
Boundaries commissioners typically aim to achieve similar populations across all ridings.
asserted
commissioners → aim → ridings
But it can be impossible in certain cases to avoid creating ridings with small populations due to sparsely populated rural regions, resulting in electoral divisions with below-average populations.
asserted
it → avoid → populations
Population disparities between city and rural ridings increase under the new proposed map.
asserted
disparities → increase → map
If approved, the average rural riding would be nearly 11-per-cent smaller than the provincewide average of 53,722 people.
asserted
riding → approve → people
These differences were key concerns for Prof. Kennedy and Mr. Robinson, the minority authors, who wrote that new ridings in northwest Calgary “subtly dilute Calgarians’ votes in ways that are not necessary to achieve effective representation.”
asserted
that → write → representation
They added that the proposed recommendations “exacerbate the underrepresentation of the four largest cities in Alberta.”
asserted
recommendations → add → Alberta
Mr. O’Ferrall, meanwhile, defended the proposals while accusing Prof. Kennedy and Mr. Robinson of unfairly criticizing the proposed hybrid ridings.
asserted
O’Ferrall → defend → ridings
The former judge wrote that changes in Lethbridge were reasonable because of “an identifiable, shared southern Alberta community of interest driven by dependency on agriculture and food processing industries.
asserted
changes → write → agriculture
At several points, Mr. O’Ferrall wrote that residents in the new hybrid Calgary ridings shared similar interests.
asserted
residents → write → interests
“One’s vote is only diluted if a large number of people with whom one doesn’t share the same interests is added to his or her electoral division,” he wrote.
asserted
he → dilute → division
It is not boundaries commissioners’ job to assess the electoral implications of their work.
asserted
It → assess → work
But should the map slide past the legislature and a legal challenge, it will have electoral implications in key parts of the province.
asserted
it → slide → province
The Aporia
