Election results from a series of state ballot initiatives on tax issues suggest that the wave of Democratic victories may be more about gas prices and anti-Trump sentiment than any overwhelming voter enthusiasm for "tax the rich" policies.
uncertain
wave → suggest → policies
The center-ring tax ballot initiative of the election was a California measure that would have imposed a "one time"—yeah, right—5 percent tax on individuals and trusts with more than $1 billion in assets.
asserted
that → impose → assets
Championed by French U.C. Berkeley economists Gabriel Zucman and Emmanuel Saez and by the president of SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West, Dave Regan, it was opposed by California-based tech billionaires, who spent hundreds of millions to defeat it.
asserted
who → champion → it
Zucman conceded on Wednesday that the initiative had been defeated and said he would try to get it done nationally by an act of Congress.
asserted
it → concede → Congress
"It’s now one of the best environments to pass a billionaire tax in Washington in decades," he said in a post on X, adding that Rep. Ro Khanna of California and Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont had already introduced a national version of the tax.
"
asserted
Khanna → ’ → tax
Trump could veto it, but even so it could pave the way for a 2028 billionaire tax if the Democrats win back the White House. …
uncertain
Democrats → veto → House
The battle between democracy and oligarchy is just beginning," Zucman said.
asserted
Zucman → begin → democracy
A federal tax of that sort might face significant constitutional obstacles, however.
uncertain
tax → face → obstacles
The California initiative, Proposition 40, was opposed by 55.6 percent of voters and favored by 44.4 percent, with 60 percent of votes counted in the Golden State’s glacially paced reporting system.
asserted
initiative → oppose → system
A related measure, Proposition 42, that would amend the state constitution to ban such new taxes, was winning by a similar margin.
asserted
that → amend → margin
It suggested that whatever resentment California voters harbor toward tech billionaires, they are also wary of any measures that would send more business and talent fleeing the state for lower-tax jurisdictions.
uncertain
business → suggest → jurisdictions
The state already has an income tax with a top marginal rate of 13.3 percent.
asserted
state → have → percent
"Not only was california’s wealth tax rejected by voters, the *concept* of the wealth tax was *banned* by voters.
asserted
concept → reject → voters
eat shit, communists," commented Pirate Wires editor-in-chief Mike Solana, in a post that he subsequently walked back as possibly premature.
uncertain
he → eat → that
"Voters were skeptical of claims it would be temporary and they were rightly worried this would drive wealthy Californians out of state," the Committee to Unleash Prosperity, a pro-growth research and advocacy group, wrote in its newsletter, in an item headlined, "Even in a Blue Wave Election, Voters Still Hate Taxes."
uncertain
Voters → worry → Taxes
Democrats have tried to target the taxes at "the rich," attempting to capitalize on class resentments or envy and aiming to convince voters that the taxes will be paid by "the rich," not by the majority of people casting the votes.
asserted
taxes → try → votes
In Washington State, a measure to repeal the millionaire tax was trailing, with 58.1 percent opposed to the repeal and 41.9 percent in favor, with 60 percent of votes in, according to the New York Times.
uncertain
percent → repeal → Times
The state legislature and Democratic governor, Bob Ferguson, enacted a 9.9 percent tax on income and long-term capital gains above $1 million, which is scheduled to take effect January 1, 2028.
asserted
which → enact → effect
In Colorado, a ballot measure, Amendment 87, to amend the state constitution and replace the current 4.4 percent flat tax with a top rate of 8.4 percent on those earning $1 million or more, was leading narrowly, 50.49 percent to 49.51 percent, with 76 percent of the votes counted.
asserted
percent → amend → votes
Ballot measures in other states focused on property taxes.
asserted
measures → focus → taxes
Florida voters approved what the Tax Foundation described as "a $250,000 homestead exemption for non-school property taxes."
asserted
Foundation → approve → taxes
The Tax Foundation’s Jared Walczak summed it up in a blog post by observing, "The results on tax-related ballot measures lack the strong narrative of congressional results, but perhaps that is itself the takeaway: voters’ views on specific tax policies don’t seem to have changed much in recent years, even against a backdrop of significant partisan churn."
asserted
views → sum → churn
Recent years have seen a series of high-profile departures by wealthy individuals from higher-tax states such as New York, Illinois, California, and Massachusetts to lower-tax states such as Texas, Nevada, and Florida.
asserted
years → see → Texas
The Aporia
