Parents and teachers across the US are criticizing Google’s announcement that schools choosing to block AI tools could also lose access to Google Search.
uncertain
schools → criticize → Search
Google announced last week a range of new AI tools for schools and classrooms, alongside options allowing teachers and administrators to restrict their use.
asserted
teachers → announce → use
The company said schools should have control over whether students use AI in the classroom, but that schools that choose to block Google’s AI tools will also lose access to its search engine.
asserted
that → say → engine
“We believe schools should have control over AI in their classrooms and in providing administrators with controls to help them manage their approach,” said Chris Phillips, vice-president for education at Google.
asserted
Phillips → believe → Google
“After listening to schools, teachers, leading researchers, and policymakers, we are now updating our approach to controls for Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom, and Google Search.
asserted
we → listen → Classroom
Access to these products will be entirely off for K-12 student accounts until school administrators explicitly turn them on.
asserted
administrators → turn → them
Parents and teachers across the country raised concerns to the Guardian about AI’s potential to weaken students’ critical-thinking skills and the growing influence of big tech in education.
asserted
Parents → raise → education
Some called on schools to consider alternative search engines, while others argued that students should be taught how to use AI responsibly rather than prevented from accessing it altogether.
asserted
students → call → it
Jen Atay, a 51-year-old teacher in Hawaii, lambasted Google’s approach, saying: “When the software is free, you are the product, and it is inappropriate for Google to test or develop AI with minors.
asserted
Google → lambast → minors
This should not be allowed at all.”
asserted
This → allow → ?
A 44-year-old father of two boys in Amissville, Virginia, said he worries that “AI will weaken people’s ability to think critically.
asserted
AI → say → ability
I use AI in my work, but it would not be effective if I did not have well over a decade of experience under my belt.
asserted
I → use → belt
“These tools are not something that should be introduced to children at such a young age.
asserted
that → introduce → age
I’m hopeful that a Democratic Congress will force the adoption of legislation that will protect our schools from corporate malfeasance such as this.
asserted
that → ’m → this
This threat from Google is nothing but extortion and it should be treated as such,” he added.
asserted
he → treat → extortion
Similarly, Eyla Whitemoon, a mother and educator based in Kernville, California, said: “By infiltrating or ‘partnering’ with our institutions, Google and Meta et al, created a false dependency and our starved public education system happily merged with their ilk.
asserted
system → base → ilk
And just like any good mob boss, drug dealer or capitalist minion, these companies got society hooked on their products and now are raising the cost of their supply …
asserted
society → get → supply
My heart aches for what our children won’t experience in a future where AI is in charge and the mega technoautocrats sit in their bunkers and hide.”
asserted
technoautocrats → ache → bunkers
Meanwhile, a 64-year-old educator based in Ann Arbor, Michigan, said: “Thankfully, after having to revamp all teaching in response to AI, Gen Z has begun appreciating what they stand to lose on account of surrendering their cognitive skills to AI.
asserted
they → base → AI
There are alternative search engines to Google and those will now be what we turn to.
asserted
we → be → what
Teachers and students alike detest the tech industry’s demand that we kiss their feet and give ourselves up to be their peons.”
asserted
we → detest → ourselves
Others questioned why schools should depend on Google at all.
asserted
schools → question → Google
An 84-year-old retiree and mother in Maryland, said: “Google decided to follow the evil path to riches.
asserted
Google → say → riches
When they started, they were great.
asserted
they → start → ?
Schools should tell Google to go pound sand and simply have kids use DuckDuckGo or one of the other search engines …
asserted
kids → tell → engines
There is nothing Google offers that is not available from some other source.”
asserted
that → be → source
Rachel Dominguez, a 42-year-old parent in Minneapolis, Minnesota, also suggested that schools turn to academic databases instead of relying on Google Search.
uncertain
schools → suggest → Search
“Seeing as how Google Search has turned into an AI slop-first service, maybe it’s better that the kids learn how to use databases such as Academic Search Premier, JSTOR, and arXiv.
asserted
kids → see → Premier
Most school districts have subscriptions to these services, and students learning to use them would be better prepared for college.
asserted
students → have → college
That is, if the librarian still has a job in the first place,” she said.
asserted
she → have → place
Not everyone believes blocking AI is the answer.
asserted
blocking → believe → AI
Some argued that schools should focus on teaching students how to use the technology responsibly.
asserted
schools → argue → technology
A 67-year-old emerging technology teacher in Texas said: “I do not blame Google.
asserted
I → emerge → Google
AI is not going away.
asserted
AI → go → ?
I’ve been very frustrated this year trying to teach AI literacy with AI blocked.
asserted
AI → try → literacy
Schools need to teach how to properly use AI, not block it.”
asserted
Schools → need → it
A California resident echoed that view, arguing that schools could use Google’s AI tools to teach students to question the information they receive.
“Google Search has existed since the 90s and it’s crazy of them to completely remove it instead of just removing Gemini.
uncertain
it → echo → Gemini
That being said, I would like to see schools actually permit the use of Gemini and use it as an opportunity to show students how its sources aren’t always valid and you can’t trust everything an AI tells you,” they said.
asserted
they → say → you
The Aporia
