An independent report into the possible separation of Alberta presents multiple outcomes, but ultimately determines the cost to leave Canada could cost up to $170 billion.
uncertain
cost → present → billion
The report by the University of Calgary’s School of Public Policy was commissioned by the Alberta government and released Wednesday.
asserted
report → commission → government
It found Albertans would face high costs in the short term with uncertain benefits in the long run, and whether talks with Canada are “smooth” or “difficult” would impact that future.
asserted
are → find → future
Two hypothetical scenarios are given to provide Albertans a look into the costs that come with separation.
asserted
that → give → separation
A “smooth” scenario would see a quick, comprehensive and favourable deal with Canada that gives an orderly transition of the province to become a separate country.
asserted
that → see → province
The “difficult” path would see Canada and other countries be hostile and could result in a deal taking a much longer time if one is reached at all.
uncertain
one → see → time
In either situation, the report said establishing a new country could range from $50 billion up to $170 billion in the first five years of separation, in addition to the impacts on economic growth and the province’s own fiscal position.
uncertain
establishing → say → growth
If Alberta experiences the “difficult” scenario though, the report paints a stark picture.
asserted
report → experience → picture
The GDP would see a loss within five years of 10.1 per cent, employment could drop by 10 per cent, a typical worker could earn almost $5,500 less than if the province had not separated, and the tax each person pays could increase up to $5,500 annually.
uncertain
person → see → 5,500
Get daily National news
After 20 years, the report suggests while unemployment would decline, many people would depart the workforce, leaving the unemployment rate at 4.7 per cent.
uncertain
people → get → cent
Annual wages for a typical worker could be almost $12,000 below what they could have been without separation and taxes per person would rise by $6,600.
uncertain
taxes → rise → 6,600
The province’s GDP would also fall by 16.2 per cent.
asserted
GDP → fall → cent
Under the “smooth” path, the report could see the province maintain access to major trade markets, expand its resource development, and provide government services more efficiently.
uncertain
province → see → services
But it also finds Alberta’s gross domestic product (GDP) could be lower by about 2.2 per cent within five years, with employment 0.7 per cent lower than it currently is, take-home pay could see a dip of more than $1,200 annually and each taxpayer would pay about $800 more.
uncertain
taxpayer → find → more
- First batch of B.C. law students takes course over bar exam as Ontario mulls switch
- Ontario fines SeatGeek $25K for allegedly violating new ticket resale law
- Teen in critical condition after e-scooter collides with SUV in Winnipeg
- Élections Québec ordered to mail bilingual voter information by Quebec judge
uncertain
Québec → take → judge
After about 20 years, the report estimated the GDP would increase by 3.4 per cent, employment would go up by 0.7 per cent and the taxes Albertans pay would decrease by $1,100.
asserted
Albertans → estimate → 1,100
Take-home pay for workers could also rise by more than $1,800 annually compared to what they would have been.
uncertain
they → take → 1,800
An expert advisory panel was appointed to review the report and prepare an independent assessment.
asserted
panel → appoint → assessment
“The panel concurs that separation results in short run economic costs for Alberta for uncertain net benefits in the longer run.
asserted
separation → concur → run
However, we also stress that Canadians should be aware that Alberta’s separation will undoubtedly harm Canada as well,” said Jack Mintz, chair of the advisory panel.
asserted
Mintz → stress → panel
Treasury Board President and Finance Minister Jason Nixon said in a statement following the release of the report that it gives “important considerations” for Albertans as they prepare to vote in the upcoming Oct. 19 referendum.
asserted
they → say → referendum
He also said the advisory panel’s own insights will help Albertans interpret the report.
asserted
insights → say → report
“The panel’s assessment emphasizes that both the scenarios outlined in the report highlight how costly it would be for Alberta to separate from Canada in the short term and also highlight the substantial amount of uncertainty Alberta would face in the long term,” Nixon said.
asserted
Nixon → emphasize → term
Albertans are expected to vote on a referendum that asks voters whether Alberta should stay in Canada or hold a second binding referendum to quit Confederation.
asserted
Alberta → expect → Confederation
The Aporia
