Attempts to reform the way workplace safety complaints were handled met strong resistance from the CFMEU, which instead insisted on funnelling all calls to a senior public servant who had removed a union-favoured bureaucrat, an inquiry has heard.
asserted
inquiry → reform → bureaucrat
Michael De’Ath, the former director-general of Queensland’s Industrial Relations Department, told the Commission of Inquiry into the CFMEU and Misconduct in the Construction Industry on Tuesday it was the “most extreme obfuscation” he had experienced in his career.
asserted
he → tell → career
“I’ve worked multiple jurisdictions with multiple stakeholders over multiple portfolios,” he said.
asserted
he → work → portfolios
“If you had it on a scale of one to nine, the worst I would have encountered might be three.
uncertain
I → have → nine
The inquiry heard former deputy director-general Kym Bancroft had proposed a system requiring unions to lodge complaints through a central 1300-number hotline, rather than contacting senior public servants directly.
asserted
Bancroft → hear → servants
But the CFMEU instead advised Bancroft calls regarding health and safety issues would instead be made directly to her.
asserted
calls → advise → her
“[It was] completely inappropriate and actually quite reckless … [and] incredibly unsafe,” De’Ath said.
asserted
De’Ath → say → ?
Counsel assisting the inquiry Dimitri Ternovski suggested to De’Ath it was an attempt to apply pressure on Bancroft.
uncertain
it → assist → Bancroft
“Without a doubt,” De’Ath replied.
asserted
De’Ath → reply → doubt
The inquiry heard an alternative arrangement was later introduced, involving regional directors sharing responsibility for after-hours calls, but De’Ath said the revised model still had significant shortcomings and the CFMEU continued to contact Bancroft directly.
asserted
CFMEU → hear → Bancroft
The commission also examined the reassignment of senior Workplace Health and Safety Queensland official Helen Burgess, whose close ties to the CFMEU have previously been aired in commission hearings.
asserted
ties → examine → hearings
Shortly after starting her new role as deputy director-general, Bancroft had moved Burgess out of the role.
asserted
Bancroft → start → role
Ternovski put it to De’Ath that then-CFMEU Queensland branch secretary Michael Ravbar had called him, upset she had been removed from her position.
asserted
she → put → position
“I don’t recall a call from Mr Ravbar.
asserted
I → recall → Ravbar
There very may well have been one, I do not recall it,” De’Ath said.
uncertain
De’Ath → recall → it
Ternovski: “So you don’t recall Mr Ravbar being very upset with you about this issue?”
asserted
Ravbar → recall → issue
Phone records presented to the inquiry showed multiple calls and text messages between Ravbar and De’Ath on the morning of August 5, 2022, followed by a call from De’Ath to Bancroft.
asserted
records → present → Bancroft
Commissioner Stuart Wood said it was hard to believe such a phone call would be forgotten.
asserted
call → say → ?
“You don’t recall Mr Ravbar ringing you about someone you’ve just employed for a week and a decision they’ve made?” he said.
asserted
he → recall → week
De’Ath: “Sorry, Commissioner, but I do not recall.”
asserted
I → recall → ?
Wood: “It seems very unlikely to be true, Mr De’Ath.”
asserted
It → seem → ?
De’Ath: “Commissioner, with respect, it’s absolutely true.
asserted
it → ’ → respect
In her affidavit to the commission in June, Bancroft said she received a call from De’Ath, saying Ravbar was upset she had removed Burgess from her role.
asserted
she → say → role
“When I received this call, I was very confused for a couple of reasons,” she said.
asserted
she → receive → reasons
“First, I did not know why Mr Ravbar, as an external stakeholder, was calling my leader about internal decisions being made at the [Office of Industrial Relations].
asserted
Ravbar → know → Relations
“Second, I did not understand why the removal of Ms Burgess from her role as Director of CCFS [construction compliance and field services] would be so concerning to Mr Ravbar to prompt him to call [director-general] De’Ath, who was three levels above Ms Burgess.”
asserted
who → understand → Burgess
De’Ath said Ravbar had never told him why he may have wanted Burgess to remain in that role.
uncertain
Burgess → say → role
“It would be clear that there was a suggestion that it was a convenient position and person for Mr Ravbar and CFMEU,” he said.
asserted
he → be → Ravbar
Ternovski asked whether there was a perception within the department that Burgess was “the CFMEU’s person within the OIR”.
asserted
Burgess → ask → OIR
“That was certainly our concern, and trying to get to a place of establishing that was extremely difficult,” De’Ath said.
asserted
De’Ath → try → that
The Aporia
