Few love stories have been as closely entwined with a nation’s history as that of Sonia and Rajiv Gandhi.
asserted
stories → entwine → Gandhi
The former’s much-awaited political memoir, Belonging, offers a strikingly candid account of her journey from a small town in Italy to the highest echelons of power in India – all for love, she says.
asserted
she → await → love
In Belonging, she opens up for the first time about the extraordinary twists and turns of a life that has largely unfolded in full public view.
asserted
that → belong → view
(The Guardian’s Hannah Ellis-Petersen has a rare in-person interview with Gandhi, and you can read an excerpt from the book here.)
asserted
you → have → book
Belonging, published today, contains moving glimpses of Gandhi’s private grief.
asserted
Belonging → belong → grief
She writes about the loss of her first child, who died shortly after birth, and the chilling discovery of grenades in a room of their house after Operation Blue Star, the 1984 military operation against Sikh separatists at the Golden Temple in Amritsar.
asserted
who → write → Amritsar
She also provides a ringside view of several turbulent chapters in Indian politics, not least the violent assassinations of her mother-in-law, Indira Gandhi, in 1984 and her husband, Rajiv, in 1991.
asserted
She → provide → 1991
Her book also revisits some of the darker episodes that have dogged the Gandhi family and the Congress party, including Indira’s imposition of the Emergency in June 1975, a 21-month period during which civil liberties were suspended, political opponents were jailed and the press was gagged, which caused fear and dismay across the country.
asserted
which → revisit → country
In Gandhi’s account, italso caused a rift within the family.
asserted
italso → cause → family
Ultimately, Gandhi’s memoir is a vivid record of six decades of India’s political transformation from the Congress-dominated secular republic she moved to in 1968 until today, when Hindu nationalism has become the dominant political force under Narendra Modi.
asserted
nationalism → dominate → Modi
Here are five key takeaways from her memoir and what they reveal about the state of Indian politics today.
asserted
they → reveal → politics
Gandhi has had no real contact with Modi for the last 12 years
Gandhi’s account offers a glimpse of how deep the political polarisation runs in Indian politics today.
asserted
polarisation → offer → politics
In one revealing passage, Gandhi writes that she has had “practically no real contact” with Modi in the 12 years he has led the nation.
asserted
he → write → nation
In fact, at times when the two have been in the same rooms, such as the speaker’s small chamber, Modi “tends to look away, avoiding eye contact”, she says.
asserted
she → tend → contact
On occasion, she adds, he has asked briefly about her health after a hospital stay.
asserted
he → add → stay
For her, this breakdown is a departure from the past, when leaders on opposing sides of the aisle “would treat one another with cordiality”.
asserted
leaders → treat → cordiality
After the 2001 terror attack on parliament, Gandhi immediately called then-BJP prime minister AB Vajpayee to enquire about his safety, a gesture he appreciated.
asserted
he → call → safety
Gandhi sees an increasingly authoritarian style of politics, in which those in power seek to “belittle and torment” opponents.
asserted
those → see → opponents
For years, Gandhi’s son, Rahul, has been the subject of BJP’s ridicule, which calls him Pappu, a derisive term intended to portray him as inexperienced and naive.
asserted
which → call → him
She adds that similar things are happening elsewhere in the world, an observation that can be read in the context of US President Donald Trump’s use of personal insults and ridicule against opponents.
asserted
that → add → opponents
It’s lonely at the top for India’s female politicians
India has an illustrious history of women occupying top leadership positions, long before many other democracies.
asserted
women → ’ → democracies
But their rise has often come at a cost – that of loneliness in navigating a male-dominated political world.
asserted
rise → come → world
In the book, Gandhi describes a 2012 conversation with Hillary Clinton on the countrys’ female leaders and their backgrounds.
asserted
Gandhi → describe → leaders
In her recollections of Indira, she shares that, despite wielding authority, Indira could feel besieged and profoundly alone, and this was particularly acute, Gandhi writes, in the months leading up to the declaration of the Emergency by her mother-in-law.
uncertain
Gandhi → share → law
Gandhi also writes of her own isolation, including when she decided to take on the leadership of the Congress out of a sense of duty to her family’s political legacy.
asserted
she → write → legacy
Those in power are increasingly stonewalling the press
Among the many ways in which Gandhi charts the erosion of India’s democratic conventions in Belonging, one particularly telling shift is the changed relationship between the media and those in power.
asserted
shift → stonewall → power
She recalls a time when journalists had opportunities to question prime ministers directly.
asserted
journalists → recall → ministers
In 12 years in power, Modi has not addressed a single press conference on his own.
asserted
Modi → address → own
He has sat in on one press briefing at the conclusion of an election campaign, and appeared alongside US presidents at joint press encounters after bilateral meetings, where they took questions from the press.
asserted
they → sit → press
Modi has consistently avoided facing journalists in an open forum, and his media interactions have largely been one-on-one interviews with sympathetic, pro-government news anchors or in one much publicised exchange with a Bollywood actor who asked him how he liked to eat mangoes.
asserted
he → avoid → mangoes
And it’s not just media …
asserted
it → ’ → ?
The book’s publication has brought renewed attention to concerns about the space for free expression in contemporary India, and the extent to which apprehensions about repercussions may influence what can be said, written and published.
uncertain
what → bring → repercussions
Penguin Random House India was to publish Gandhi’s memoir but withdrew from the project in August.
asserted
India → publish → August
Gandhi told the Guardian that it was “uneasy in general with the criticism of the government” and said it had dropped the book after she declined certain suggested edits.
uncertain
she → tell → edits
Penguin has disputed her account, saying that the suggestion it decided not to publish the book because of refused editorial changes “does not accurately reflect the circumstances”.
asserted
it → dispute → circumstances
The book, released in the US by Alfred A Knopf, is being published in India by HarperCollins.
asserted
book → release → HarperCollins
In June, Penguin had also pulled out of plans to distribute graphic journalist Joe Sacco’s The Once and Future Riot, about the 2013 Muzaffarnagar communal violence.
asserted
Penguin → pull → violence
The publisher cited an inaccurate map of India and unresolved citation issues.
asserted
publisher → cite → India
Sacco, however, blamed the decision on the “current political climate in India”.
asserted
Sacco → blame → India
She’s had quiet fallouts with the ‘thoroughly dishonest’
Western political memoirs, particularly by former heads of government or senior politicians, are often forthcoming in naming political adversaries, recounting private exchanges and offering candid assessments of colleagues.
asserted
memoirs → ’ → colleagues
…and 31 more, not listed.
The Aporia
