In the hours after polls closed on election day, tech industry players began praising Sergey Brin, the co-founder of Google, on social media.
asserted
players → close → media
“Huge thanks to Sergey Brin here,” wrote Garry Tan, the CEO of Y Combinator.
asserted
Tan → write → Combinator
Venture capitalist Ilya Sukhar posted: “God bless Sergey Brin.”
asserted
God → post → Brin
And David Marcus, a crypto entrepreneur, simply wrote: “Hero.”
asserted
Marcus → write → Hero
They were all referring to Brin’s instrumental role in the defeat of California’s wealth tax ballot measure, known as Proposition 40.
asserted
They → refer → Proposition
The proposed one-time 5% tax on billionaires in the state is poised to be defeated by double-digit numbers.
asserted
tax → propose → numbers
Simultaneously, an opposition initiative that would ban any taxation on billionaire wealth, Proposition 42, put on the ballot by Brin and a cohort of the state’s ultra-rich, passed.
asserted
that → ban → state
Brin, whose net worth is about $230bn, contributed at least $132m to the fight – more than any other donor.
asserted
worth → contribute → donor
The runner-up was former Google CEO Eric Schmidt, who gave more than $48m.
asserted
who → give → 48
Millions more were donated by executives from Palantir, DoorDash, Stripe and Reddit, along with prominent venture capitalists.
asserted
Millions → donate → capitalists
All told, Silicon Valley’s elite raised nearly $425m to sink the tax, according to campaign finance filings, making it the most expensive opposition campaign in state history.
uncertain
it → tell → history
Over the last month, the campaign poured those dollars into highly produced ads and mailers that bombarded voters with warnings that the tax was dangerous and would hurt everyday people.
asserted
tax → pour → people
Taglines from the campaign said Prop 40 was an “everyone tax”, “reckless experiment” and “you’re next”.
asserted
you → say → campaign
While supporters of the tax said the money would go toward funding the state’s healthcare losses from Donald Trump’s One Big Beautiful Bill Act, opponents repeatedly sent the message to voters that it would make healthcare funding worse.
asserted
funding → say → voters
Even without Prop 40’s outsized opponents, the pro-billionaire tax campaign had a difficult task.
asserted
campaign → have → task
It had to convince Californians that this specific one-time tax, chiefly geared toward healthcare funding, was the right way to address losses from Trump’s bill.
asserted
tax → have → bill
The idea of zeroing in on billionaires ruffled feathers across the state with major political figures opposing it, including Gavin Newsom, the governor, and Xavier Becerra, the governor elect.
asserted
figures → zero → Newsom
In comparison with the billionaires’ war chest, the pro-Prop 40 camp, sponsored by the union SEIU-United Healthcare Workers West (SEIU-UHW), raised just more than $31m.
asserted
camp → sponsor → 31
They were outspent nearly 14-fold.
asserted
They → outspent → ?
“All lies have a shelf life,” said Suzanne Jimenez, the chief of staff for the SEIU-UHW.
asserted
Jimenez → have → UHW
“Billionaire-funded propaganda may mislead voters about the consequences of these cuts today, but as hospitals reduce services, emergency rooms close and families lose access to care, the truth will become increasingly difficult to hide.”
The counties that voted to pass Prop 40 are typically more Democratic and where many of the state’s wealthy reside, including Los Angeles, San Francisco and other areas around the Bay Area.
uncertain
many → fund → Area
The counties that overwhelmingly voted against the measure were mostly red, rural and poor.
asserted
that → vote → measure
While many of these counties swung blue in US House races this election, up to 80% of voters there voted no on Prop 40, according to the latest count.
uncertain
% → swing → count
Rob Lalka, a business professor at Tulane University and author of The Venture Alchemists: How Big Tech Turned Profits Into Power, compared the Prop 40 campaign with Uber and Lyft’s ballot measure crusade in 2020, where the companies spent more than $200m to defeat an initiative over labor rights for drivers.
asserted
companies → turn → drivers
The ride-hailing companies used similar tactics, Lalka said, something he describes as “misleading propaganda and paying for endorsements”.
asserted
he → hail → endorsements
“The money also seemed astonishing at the time: the amount to influence the outcome, over $200m, was a massive sum,” Lalka said.
asserted
Lalka → seem → m
“Money in politics has only increased in California throughout this decade.
asserted
Money → increase → decade
That’s the context for Prop 40 this election cycle.
asserted
That → ’ → Prop
The colossal funding of political campaigns has broken records nationwide this midterm cycle, said Francesco Trebbi, a business and public policy professor at the University of California, Berkeley.
asserted
Trebbi → break → California
He pointed to Elon Musk dumping $446m into House and Senate races across the county, but noted that it was ineffective in places such as Texas: Musk’s mark, James Talarico, won.
asserted
mark → point → Texas
“Maybe it was easier to decouple Prop 40 opposition from President Trump’s agenda, so Brin had an easier target to hit,” Trebbi said.
asserted
Trebbi → decouple → target
Still, he added: “We need a lot more data and statistical evidence in order to conclusively finalize this discussion.”
asserted
We → add → discussion
Exit polls haven’t yet been released for Prop 40, which will give more details on voters’ decisions.
asserted
which → release → decisions
In the meantime, the SEIU-UHW’s Jimenez said that despite the loss, the union and its allies are not going to give up on the long game: “If Sacramento fails to protect patients and deliver a real solution that makes billionaires pay their fair share, healthcare workers will pursue every available avenue, up to and including returning to the ballot in 2028 with a billionaire tax.”
asserted
workers → say → tax
The Aporia
