Egypt’s independent press fights to survive as Mada Masr editor returns to court
GIZA, Egypt, Nov 10 -
asserted
editor → fight → court
An old villa, tucked away among mango and lemon trees in the back streets of Giza, once resounded with the clatter of keyboards and the chatter of people around its two long meeting tables but has now fallen silent.
asserted
villa → tuck → tables
Ordered by a court to close last month, Egypt's best-known independent news site, Mada Masr, has shuttered the villa as it awaits an appeal.
asserted
it → order → appeal
Editor-in-chief Lina Attalah faces a separate case this week that could land her in prison.
uncertain
that → face → prison
Human rights groups see the Mada Masr case, along with the recent arrest of the entire newsroom of fact-checking outlet Matsaddash, as a stark sign of a crackdown that is testing whether independent journalism can survive in Egypt, the Arab world's most populous country.
asserted
journalism → see → Egypt
Founded in 2013, Mada Masr has long stood out in a media landscape dominated by outlets owned by or aligned with the state.
asserted
Masr → found → state
It has won international awards and produced coverage closely followed by diplomats, researchers and foreign correspondents.
asserted
It → win → diplomats
While the site, blocked in Egypt since 2017, has faced investigations and fines before, this time it is "in existential danger"
asserted
it → block → danger
, Attalah told Reuters.
asserted
Attalah → tell → Reuters
Rights and civil society groups have condemned the prosecution, while the European Union said the "preservation and protection of independent media outlets are essential".
asserted
preservation → condemn → outlets
On Tuesday, the UN human rights office added its voice to calls for Egyptian authorities to allow journalists "to carry out their essential work free from intimidation and reprisals".
asserted
journalists → add → intimidation
Egyptian authorities did not respond to Reuters requests for comment on the Mada Masr case or wider issues of press freedom.
asserted
authorities → respond → freedom
They have repeatedly said the state is committed to freedom of expression but that media must operate within the law and respect national security.
asserted
media → say → security
Egypt’s Supreme Judicial Council has rejected claims that Attalah's trial last month was unfair.
uncertain
trial → reject → claims
Egypt’s foreign partners have also shown limited willingness to let rights concerns disrupt strategic ties.
asserted
concerns → show → ties
In September, the United States, a key security partner, waived human rights conditions — which include protecting press freedoms — on part of the roughly $1.3 billion in annual military aid it provides to Egypt.
asserted
it → waive → Egypt
Attalah said she only learned of the order to shut her newsroom when signing papers for her release from detention after the payment of a fine of 3 million Egyptian pounds ($56,200).
asserted
she → say → pounds
At the heart of Mada Masr’s case is its lack of a licence, which it says it has been seeking since a 2018 media law introduced the requirement.
asserted
law → say → requirement
Under the licensing rules, Egypt’s Supreme Council for Media Regulation must rule on applications within 90 days.
asserted
Council → rule → days
Mada Masr says its applications, most recently completed in 2023, have received no formal decision.
asserted
applications → say → decision
Such a lack of response can leave independent outlets in limbo and at risk of prosecution for operating illegally, said Lobna Darwish, head of advocacy at the Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights.
asserted
Darwish → leave → Rights
The media council has not specifically commented on Mada Masr’s case, but said last week it had issued numerous licences, that unlicensed sites made up a small share, and that it stood ready to help outlets complete their files.
asserted
outlets → comment → files
Journalists say licensing issues can feed into broader pressures.
asserted
issues → say → pressures
Shaher Ayyad, an editorial board member at independent site al-Manassa, said independent outlets are often portrayed as lawbreakers or enemies of the state.
"We are neither a site hostile to the state nor one that supports it," he said.
asserted
he → say → it
Al-Manassa has been blocked more than a dozen times since 2017, leaving readers facing dead links, sources hesitant to talk and advertisers wary, Ayyad said.
asserted
Ayyad → block → links
Though Egypt’s 2014 constitution broadly forbids imposing jail terms for publication offences, the Committee to Protect Journalists says 25 journalists are currently behind bars.
asserted
journalists → forbid → bars
The most prominent recent example was the arrest in September of all six staff of fact-checking outlet Matsaddash on suspicion of spreading misinformation on behalf of the banned Muslim Brotherhood.
asserted
example → spread → Brotherhood
The outlet denies the accusation.
asserted
outlet → deny → accusation
The six — including the outlet's only employee who belongs to Egypt's trade union for journalists — remain in jail pending trial, authorities have said.
asserted
authorities → include → trial
The Egyptian government’s 2021 National Human Rights Strategy acknowledges some shortcomings in the media field, Darwish said, adding it lists among the challenges inadequate access to official information, insufficient diversity of opinion and a weak culture of freedom of expression.
asserted
it → acknowledge → expression
Mada Masr editor Attalah returns to court on Wednesday for a retrial in a separate case in which she was previously sentenced in absentia to a year in prison for publishing false news and running an unlicensed website.
asserted
she → return → website
Attalah said she wishes to remain in Egypt despite opportunities to leave and hopes that the crisis ends by opening a "new page" for independent media sites that allows them to obtain licences.
asserted
them → say → licences
"I feel there has to be a way to do journalism in Egypt," she said.
asserted
she → feel → Egypt
The Aporia
