Explainer-How would impeaching Pentagon chief Hegseth work?
asserted
impeaching → impeach → Hegseth
US Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth could be impeached by the House of Representatives this week on charges of abusing his power, including by going to war with Iran without an imminent threat or congressional approval.
uncertain
Hegseth → impeach → threat
Hegseth has denied wrongdoing and President Donald Trump has pledged to stand by him.
asserted
Trump → deny → him
IMPEACHMENT IN THE HOUSE
US Representative Thomas Massie, a Kentucky Republican, introduced eight articles of impeachment against Hegseth on Monday.
asserted
Massie → introduce → Monday
The term "high crimes and misdemeanors" is not explicitly defined in the Constitution, but historically has encompassed abuses of power and violations of public trust.
asserted
term → define → trust
A simple majority in the 435-seat chamber is needed for impeachment.
asserted
majority → need → impeachment
House Republican leaders are expected first to try to derail the vote by procedural means that would effectively kill it without debate or by sending it to a committee for further investigation.
asserted
that → expect → investigation
Either requires a simple majority.
asserted
Either → require → majority
Republicans control the House 218-214.
asserted
Republicans → control → House
If those efforts fail, an impeachment vote could proceed.
uncertain
vote → fail → ?
TRIAL IN THE SENATE
Impeachment by the House would not remove Hegseth from office — it amounts to the House formally bringing charges, like an indictment in a criminal case.
asserted
House → remove → case
At that point the Senate would have to take up the matter, either by dismissing the charges or holding a trial to determine if Hegseth is guilty and should be removed from office.
asserted
Hegseth → have → office
Republicans currently hold a 53-47 majority in the Senate.
asserted
Republicans → hold → Senate
In such a trial, House members act as the prosecutors.
asserted
members → act → prosecutors
Senators serve as jurors and hear witness testimony.
asserted
Senators → serve → testimony
A guilty verdict requires a two-thirds vote of the senators present.
asserted
verdict → require → senators
If convicted, the official is immediately removed from office.
asserted
official → convict → office
A trial could be avoided or ended before a conviction vote if a majority votes to dismiss the charges.
IS HEGSETH LIKELY TO BE IMPEACHED?
uncertain
HEGSETH → avoid → charges
Massie's impeachment resolution could pass given unified Democratic support.
uncertain
resolution → pass → support
Conviction in the Senate, a much higher hurdle, is seen as unlikely.
asserted
Conviction → see → Senate
Republicans will control both chambers of Congress until noon ET (1700 GMT) on January 3, 2027, when Democrats take control of both chambers.
asserted
Democrats → control → chambers
Massie's resolution will expire on January 3 if it does not receive a vote on its merits by then.
asserted
it → expire → merits
Massie lost his primary election and will not return to Congress next year, so a different House member would need to reintroduce articles of impeachment at that point.
asserted
member → lose → point
But if the House does vote to impeach Hegseth during the current Congress, Massie's resolution would not expire on January 3, meaning the Senate could hold a trial next year when the Democrats control both the House and Senate.
uncertain
Democrats → vote → House
WHO HAS BEEN IMPEACHED BEFORE?
asserted
WHO → impeach → ?
The US Constitution states that the president, vice president and "all civil Officers" can face impeachment.
asserted
president → state → impeachment
That term has long been understood to include high-ranking officials and federal judges.
asserted
term → understand → officials
If Massie's move is successful, Hegseth would be the third cabinet secretary in US history to be impeached.
asserted
Hegseth → impeach → history
In 2024, Homeland Security Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas was impeached over Democratic President Joe Biden's handling of the US-Mexico border.
asserted
Mayorkas → impeach → border
The Senate voted to dismiss the charges, heading off a trial.
asserted
Senate → vote → trial
William Belknap, who served as secretary of war under President Ulysses S. Grant, was impeached in 1876 on corruption allegations shortly after resigning.
asserted
who → serve → allegations
He was eventually acquitted in the Senate.
asserted
He → acquit → Senate
Trump was impeached twice — first in December 2019, on charges stemming from his efforts to pressure Ukraine to investigate Biden.
asserted
Trump → impeach → Biden
The Senate acquitted him in February 2020.
asserted
Senate → acquit → February
He was impeached again in 2021 on charges of inciting an insurrection after the January 6, 2021, attack on the Capitol by his supporters.
asserted
He → impeach → supporters
The Senate again acquitted him, by a vote of 57-43.
asserted
Senate → acquit → 57
Seven Republicans were among those who voted to convict.
asserted
who → vote → those
The Aporia
