The United States could lose its measles elimination status this week, an event likely to cement health secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr’s legacy of meddling in vaccine policies amid the worst outbreak of the virus in the US in 35 years.
uncertain
States → lose → years
If the US loses its measles-free status, it would join Canada and several European and Asian nations that had eliminated the disease only for it to return.
asserted
it → lose → disease
“That is a tremendous step backwards,” said Dr Paul Offit, director of the Vaccine Education Center, an attending physician in the division of infectious diseases at Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, and a prominent critic of Kennedy.
asserted
Offit → say → Kennedy
A panel of eight independent experts will consider the epidemiological evidence in Washington DC, part of a group called the Pan American Health Organization (PAHO), a regional branch of the World Health Organization (WHO).
asserted
panel → consider → Organization
The PAHO director will make the final call.
asserted
director → make → call
“Independent of what PAHO says, measles is now endemic in the US.
asserted
measles → say → US
Measles has a foothold in the US,” said Offit.
asserted
Offit → have → US
“We’re going to see it this year, we’re going to see it next year,” because the US “critically decreased the percentage” of people vaccinated.
asserted
US → go → people
The US is in the midst of its worst measles outbreak since 1991 with more than 5,400 cases nationally, according to the Johns Hopkins University International Vaccine Access Center tracker.
uncertain
US → accord → tracker
Just this year, six people have died in Pennsylvania, a child died in New York on election day and an infant died in Wisconsin days later.
asserted
infant → die → Wisconsin
Nearly every US state has an active outbreak.
asserted
state → have → outbreak
Measles is considered one of the most infectious diseases known to medicine.
asserted
Measles → consider → medicine
The overwhelming majority of Americans vaccinate themselves and their children, but the sheer contagiousness of measles means even small dips in immunity allow it to spread.
asserted
it → vaccinate → immunity
It kills one to three people per 1,000 people and hospitalizes about one-in-five unvaccinated people who are infected.
asserted
who → kill → people
Although elimination status is a formal public health designation, its loss has real effects on everyday Americans.
asserted
loss → have → Americans
In just one example, Dr David Margolius, the Cleveland, Ohio,director of public health, is warning people to find proof of their measles vaccination in the event they’re exposed to a measles-positive patient.
asserted
they → warn → patient
“Now is the time to go and find that evidence, because now this is a real day-to-day life thing that could happen to you,” said Margolius, who is also a director-at-large of the Big Cities Health Coalition.
uncertain
who → go → Coalition
Without proof, patients face either an immunology blood draw or a 21-day quarantine.
asserted
patients → face → draw
Cleveland health authorities have already done a tremendous amount of detective work this year to track down people exposed to measles patients in hospital waiting rooms and elevators.
asserted
authorities → do → rooms
“We reach out to people and for most people, including myself, we have no personal experience with measles,” he said.
asserted
he → reach → measles
“They’ve got everything else going on in their life, and now they’re getting this call.”
asserted
they → get → call
The types of people who contract measles has also changed.
asserted
who → contract → measles
In 1963, when the vaccine was first licensed, measles was considered a childhood disease.
asserted
measles → license → 1963
Most children contracted the disease by the age of five.
asserted
children → contract → five
“Now you’re seeing the epidemiology shift,” said Offit.
asserted
Offit → see → shift
Two-thirds of people infected with measles in Pennsylvania are adults, a group on which researchers have little information.
asserted
researchers → infect → information
Mothers have even given birth to babies with measles.
asserted
Mothers → give → measles
“Now, you’re seeing something we just didn’t see at all – congenital measles.”
asserted
we → see → something
The potential loss of elimination status comes at a tenuous moment for the Trump administration.
asserted
loss → come → administration
Republicans just endured a historic drubbing in the midterm elections.
asserted
Republicans → endure → elections
Several new Democratic doctors and scientists are slated to come into Congress on promises to hold Kennedy accountable.
asserted
Kennedy → slat → promises
At the same time, Trump has doubled down on his commitment to vaccine antagonism with the appointment of Stephen Miller as chief of staff.
asserted
Trump → double → staff
“Next to me, Stephen Miller is the strongest Maha supporter in the administration,” Kennedy said in a statement about Miller’s appointment.
asserted
Kennedy → say → appointment
“It’s time to unleash the Kraken.”
asserted
It → ’ → Kraken
Meanwhile, the capacity of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) to respond has been significantly hampered by the Trump administration.
asserted
capacity → respond → administration
The agency has lost up to one-third of its staff, Kennedy has interfered in the agency’s reporting of measles deaths and has spread misinformation about the measles vaccines.
asserted
Kennedy → lose → vaccines
Even so, Margolius doesn’t lay all the blame at Kennedy’s feet.
asserted
Margolius → lay → feet
Vaccine hesitancy was increasing before Trump took office, and pandemic-era disruptions were real.
asserted
disruptions → increase → office
“Some of the narrative has been to pin this on our health secretary, which certainly I think he could do much more to help the situation rather than hurting the situation, but I do think the case count is climbing everywhere,” he said.
uncertain
he → pin → situation
“This could happen even under a more pro-public health administration.”
uncertain
This → happen → administration
…and 7 more, not listed.
The Aporia
