It is one that stands out even amid almost 2½ years of denial and disgrace for the government over its handling of the scandal engulfing its $109 billion Big Build program.
asserted
that → stand → program
The spectacle of a visibly enraged counsel assisting the royal commission Chris Young, KC, leading the inquiry through documents covered in thick slabs of black ink redactions should trouble anyone who had hope for a revival of government transparency in this state.
asserted
who → enrage → state
Young told Commissioner Chris Kourakis, AC, that the Victorian Infrastructure Delivery Authority (VIDA) had provided many such heavily redacted documents, had delayed discovery and was arguably not complying with its legal duties.
asserted
Authority → tell → duties
This was “profoundly disappointing”, Young said, given Premier Ben Carroll’s public assertions his government considered the royal commission’s work important.
asserted
work → say → assertions
Kourakis noted that the approach to discovery of government agencies had impeded the orderly running of his inquiry.
asserted
approach → note → inquiry
Carroll had, only two days earlier, responded to a much milder rebuke from the commission on Monday to the state government on this topic by accepting there was a need to do better.
asserted
Carroll → respond → topic
On Thursday, in the face of the much more strident and serious criticism, Carroll meekly ducked, suggesting he was not going to offer a running commentary on the commission.
asserted
he → duck → commission
The Age is more than happy to take up that role.
asserted
Age → take → role
Notwithstanding the government’s apparent obstruction, the revelations the commission produced through its first week of witness examinations were devastating.
asserted
commission → produce → examinations
In focusing on the case study of the $110 million Gap Road level crossing removal, the commission exposed the irrefutable truth of so much that the government has rubbished or brushed off since The Age’s Building Bad investigation blew the lid off the industry in mid-2024.
asserted
investigation → focus → mid-2024
That investigation revealed that senior staff had tried to warn Jacinta Allan, when she was minister, that the CFMEU was out of control before Building Bad broke.
asserted
Bad → reveal → control
As premier, she denied this, even in the face of a leaked ministerial brief from mid-2023.
asserted
she → deny → mid-2023
On Tuesday, the commission revealed the government’s most senior bureaucrats had also drafted two almost-identical ministerial briefs for her, once in 2022 and again in January 2023, warning of exactly this phenomenon.
asserted
bureaucrats → reveal → phenomenon
The Age reported that the minister’s office had intervened in the Gap Road dispute, saying if the contractors could not make peace with the union, including that they appoint a CFMEU-aligned labour hire company, they would not win further work.
uncertain
they → report → work
Allan said anyone with evidence of this should report it to police.
asserted
anyone → say → police
On Wednesday, a top John Holland executive said he was told this by a government official.
asserted
he → say → official
He was so concerned that he rang that official’s boss, who confirmed there was a “view in government” that if John Holland could not win peace with the union it would not be getting in on the state’s record-breaking infrastructure binge.
uncertain
it → ring → binge
When asked whose view that was, he said he was told: “The minister’s office.”
asserted
he → ask → office
The official suggested the company needed to meet with the union to sort it out.
uncertain
company → suggest → it
The Age also reported in July that not only was the threat general but that there was specific mention of the airport rail project.
asserted
threat → report → project
Again, this was denied by Allan.
asserted
this → deny → Allan
Executives from John Holland and other companies involved in the project, plus a former CFMEU organiser, gave sworn evidence to the commission that this happened at the now-infamous meeting at the CFMEU’s headquarters.
asserted
this → involve → headquarters
The organiser, Paul Tzimas, said his boss Joe Myles had boasted to the construction executives that he had a “direct line to Jacinta Allan’s office”.
asserted
he → say → office
Carroll has tried to make his establishment of the royal commission a founding virtue of his premiership.
asserted
establishment → try → premiership
And if that premiership ends later this month, he deserves to be remembered as the person who did the right thing regardless of what it meant for his party’s political prospects.
asserted
it → end → prospects
His government and its agencies, however, have reverted to bad habits in a bid to avoid the uncomfortable glare of scrutiny.
asserted
government → revert → scrutiny
Young noted that an executive meeting of government’s infrastructure agency took place at a key point in the Gap Road fiasco, but it cannot find any notes or minutes for the meeting.
asserted
it → note → meeting
No explanation has been provided for this curious failure.
asserted
explanation → provide → failure
Nor have we yet heard why those damaging briefs prepared for the minister were not signed by her.
asserted
briefs → hear → her
The government’s redactions highlighted by the commission blatantly incorporated material that was both relevant to the commission’s work and damaging for the government, including notes showing top officials were acutely aware of the consequences of delays at Gap Road.
asserted
officials → highlight → Road
Following Thursday’s dressing down from the commissioner, it appeared government agencies had lifted their game.
asserted
agencies → follow → game
Counsel assisting the royal commission Chris Carr, SC, was “happy to report there has been substantial production of highly relevant material overnight.
asserted
Counsel → assist → material
“That material has allowed us to identify further lines of inquiry, which we must pursue over the weekend and on Monday morning.”
The Age was pleased to hear it.
The frustration of the commission’s work – through the ridiculous and cynical redactions – threatens to undermine Carroll’s legacy as the leader who brought truth to an ageing government.
asserted
who → allow → government
And the commission is just getting started.
asserted
commission → start → ?
Get a weekly wrap of views that will challenge, champion and inform your own.
asserted
that → get → own
The Aporia
