Breast cancer treatments are often lifesaving, but they can also come with both short-term and lingering side effects.
asserted
they → come → effects
One that’s been documented in study after study: bone loss.
asserted
that → document → study
A recent systematic review and meta-analysis published in Frontiers in Oncology found that breast cancer patients were more likely to develop osteoporosis or break a bone than those who hadn’t.
asserted
who → publish → those
The findings came as no surprise to Dawn Hershman, deputy director of the Herbert Irving Comprehensive Cancer Center at Columbia University Medical Center.
asserted
findings → come → Center
“It’s well known that treatments for breast cancer cause osteoporosis,” she said.
asserted
she → know → osteoporosis
The new review, she added, “emphasizes that these are potentially ongoing issues for cancer survivors that they need to pay attention to.”
asserted
they → add → attention
For the analysis, researchers from the Henan University of Chinese Medicine reviewed 16 cohort studies that included almost 1.5 million total participants.
asserted
that → review → participants
People with a history of breast cancer were 54 percent more likely to develop osteoporosis, a condition characterized by reduced bone density.
asserted
People → develop → density
They also had about a 50 percent higher risk of breaking a bone than those who’d never had the disease.
asserted
who → have → disease
Looking at individual treatments, the researchers found a higher risk of osteoporosis among people taking aromatase inhibitors, a widely used class of drugs that lower estrogen levels.
asserted
that → look → levels
However, the results were less clear for chemotherapy and tamoxifen, a medication that blocks estrogen’s effects on breast cancer cells.
asserted
that → block → cells
About 8 in 10 breast cancers are hormone receptor-positive, meaning the cancer cells have receptors for estrogen, progesterone or both.
asserted
cells → mean → estrogen
Estrogen can help many of these cancers grow, which is why some treatments aim to reduce it.
asserted
treatments → help → it
That drop can also weaken bones, said Robert Coleman, emeritus professor of medical oncology at the University of Sheffield in England.
asserted
Coleman → weaken → England
Before menopause, most estrogen comes from the ovaries, which doctors can temporarily suppress with medication.
asserted
doctors → come → medication
Chemotherapy can also disrupt how the ovaries work.
asserted
ovaries → disrupt → ?
If they don’t recover, menopause can start early.
asserted
menopause → recover → ?
As estrogen levels drop around menopause, bone loss speeds up, Hershman said.
asserted
Hershman → drop → menopause
For patients who are already past menopause, aromatase inhibitors can lower estrogen even further, raising the risk of fractures.
asserted
inhibitors → lower → fractures
Hershman pointed out that the researchers drew on data from 1998 to 2020, so the findings may not fully reflect how clinicians protect patients’ bones today.
uncertain
clinicians → point → bones
In 2019, for instance, the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) published guidelines on managing osteoporosis and fracture risk in people with nonmetastatic cancer.
asserted
Society → publish → cancer
“In the current era, many, many women are screened for bone density” and receive advice on how to lower their risk, Hershman said.
asserted
Hershman → screen → risk
“We don’t know how many people are following those guidelines,” she added, or whether they’ve helped bring down fracture rates.
asserted
they → know → rates
The findings also shouldn’t discourage patients from getting treated for breast cancer, stressed Karen Daily, an oncologist and clinical professor in the division of hematology and oncology at the University of Florida College of Medicine.
asserted
Daily → discourage → Medicine
While the risks of bone loss with certain breast cancer treatments are real, “they’re offset by the benefits,” she said.
asserted
she → offset → benefits
Plus, “most patients don’t experience a fracture from these treatments,” she added.
asserted
she → experience → treatments
Your risk of bone loss depends in part on the treatment you receive, so “being aware of that potential risk is the first step,” said Andrea Singer, chief in the division of women’s primary care and director of bone densitometry at MedStar Georgetown University Hospital.
asserted
Singer → depend → Hospital
Here are four steps you can take:
asserted
you → take → ?
Before you begin treatment, your doctor might suggest a scan called DXA to see “what your bones are like on day one,” Coleman said.
uncertain
Coleman → begin → day
ASCO guidelines recommend bone density testing for patients with nonmetastatic cancer who have at least one risk factor for osteoporotic fracture.
asserted
who → recommend → fracture
These scans establish a baseline, and having one has been associated with lower fracture risk over time.
asserted
having → establish → time
Still, in a study published in 2021, only 58.6 percent of women with estrogen receptor‐positive breast cancer who received aromatase inhibitor therapy between 2007 and 2013 had a DXA scan around the time they started taking the drugs.
asserted
they → publish → drugs
“We’re underscreening a group that we know is at risk,” Singer said.
asserted
Singer → underscreene → risk
“The best way to prevent fractures is to increase balance and muscle strength so you’re less likely to fall,” Hershman said.
asserted
Hershman → prevent → balance
A 2019 Cochrane review found that exercise programs reduced the rate of falls by 23 percent among older adults living at home.
asserted
programs → find → home
ASCO guidelines suggest a combination of balance exercises, stretching, aerobic activity and strength training to lower fall and fracture risk.
asserted
guidelines → suggest → risk
If your clinician thinks you’re not getting enough calcium or vitamin D from your diet, they might also suggest supplements.
uncertain
they → think → supplements
(Although a recent review found that calcium and vitamin D supplements did little to prevent fractures in the people studied, getting enough of both nutrients is still important for osteoporosis care.)
asserted
getting → find → care
Take medications for bone loss, if your doctor prescribes them.
asserted
doctor → take → them
If you have osteoporosis or are at a high risk of breaking a bone, your clinician might recommend a medication to slow bone loss.
uncertain
clinician → have → loss
…and 8 more, not listed.