[A.] From Ellis v. Wallace, decided today by Chief Magistrate Judge Scott Varholak (D. Colo.):
On January 29, 2025, a Black Hawk Helicopter and American Airlines Flight 5342 collided mid-air near Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport.
asserted
Helicopter → decide → Airport
Hours after the crash, several posts and articles appeared claiming Plaintiff was the helicopter pilot in the midair collision ("the rumor"), including:
- On the morning of January 30, 2025, a "well-known podcaster and influencer Luke Ford posted a full video identifying [Plaintiff] as the pilot and discussing the crash as intentional."
asserted
podcaster → appear → crash
- On January 30, 2025, at 4:35 p.m., X user @RealNytoMwang posted "Plaintiff's photograph with text falsely identifying her as the transgender Black Hawk pilot who crashed the helicopter."
asserted
who → post → helicopter
- On January 30, 2025, at 9:22 p.m., X user @FakeGayPolitics published a post "identifying Plaintiff as the pilot, including her photographs and video clips."
asserted
@FakeGayPolitics → publish → photographs
- On January 30, 2025, at 11:34 p.m., the Santa Monica Observer published an online article titled, "A Transgender Pilot Named Jo Ellis Flew Blackhawk Helicopter Into the American Airlines Jet at Reagan National.
asserted
Pilot → publish → National
Defendant made his first X post addressing the rumor on January 31, 2025, at 1:00 a.m. Eastern Time.
asserted
Defendant → make → a.m.
And Plaintiff filed the Complaint in this matter on April 9, 2025, alleging that Defendant's posts were defamatory.
asserted
posts → file → April
Plaintiff then proceeded to appear as a guest on several podcasts.
asserted
Plaintiff → proceed → podcasts
On July 18, 2025, she was interviewed on the Kill Tony podcast.
asserted
she → interview → podcast
During the interview, the hosts asked Plaintiff about the collision rumor and her pending litigation.
asserted
hosts → ask → rumor
Plaintiff explained that Defendant was the "[f]irst one to tie my likeness to the rumor.
asserted
Defendant → explain → rumor
We don't know if he started the rumor, but he had millions of followers.
asserted
he → know → followers
He did the most what we can determine as damage."
Ten days later, Defendant filed the Special Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint, attaching copies of X posts and articles linking Plaintiff to the crash hours before Defendant commented on the rumor.
asserted
Defendant → do → rumor
Plaintiff then appeared on a second podcast, the RVA Magazine podcast, on September 30, 2025.
asserted
Plaintiff → appear → September
Plaintiff was again asked about the rumor and her pending litigation.
asserted
Plaintiff → ask → rumor
In response, she stated:
[W]ithin 24 hours of the crash, I was finding out that I was being named as as the pilot as, like, the unnamed female pilot that was the supposed DEI hire that Trump, President Trump had alluded to at a press conference that "we know it's DEI because we just know."
asserted
we → state → conference
And so that kind of sent the online world into a frenzy of like, let's figure out who this pilot is.
asserted
pilot → send → frenzy
And, from what we can tell, [Defendant] picked up on that and used a picture of me and the [Michael] Smerconish article and, um, kind of put it all together.
asserted
Defendant → tell → it
And with his following, he had, I think, two and half million followers or something like that, we believe he did the most damage.
asserted
he → have → damage
Like it would not have had the legs it had if he hadn't posted about it.
asserted
he → have → it
Finally, on January 12, 2026, Kim Congdon interviewed Plaintiff on The Kim Congdon Takeover podcast.
asserted
Congdon → interview → podcast
Congdon asked Plaintiff if she was suing the individual that started the rumor.
asserted
that → ask → rumor
Plaintiff responded:
I don't, yeah, I don't know if he started it, but he definitely, like, he pushed it.
asserted
he → respond → it
He's the first one to tie my likeness to it.
asserted
He → tie → it
His name's Matt Wallace and, uh, he, uh, millions of followers on Twitter, and he pushed it pretty hard and we believe he did the most damage and so I'm suing him in federal court."
asserted
I → push → court
On April 6, 2026, Defendant filed the Counterclaim alleging that these podcast statements were defamatory.
asserted
statements → file → Counterclaim
Defendant alleges that Plaintiff made repeated defamatory statements that: (1) Defendant "was the first one to post [Plaintiff's] likeness in connection with the helicopter crash," and (2) that Plaintiff believes Defendant's "statements caused the most damage."
asserted
statements → allege → damage
{Plaintiff alleges that there is a material difference between claiming that Defendant was the first to name Plaintiff in relation to the tragedy, and that Defendant was the first one to post Plaintiff's likeness in connection with the collision.
asserted
Defendant → allege → collision
Accordingly, the Court assesses Plaintiff's "likeness" statements as conveying Defendant was the first to connect Plaintiff to the collision.}
[B.] The court rejected Plaintiff's arguments that Plaintiff's statements were protected by the "litigation privilege."
asserted
statements → assess → privilege
That privilege bars defamation lawsuits based on statements in court filings and in-court statements, but doesn't apply to statements about the lawsuit made outside the litigation.
asserted
privilege → bar → litigation
(Recall that, though in a typical case it would be a defendant who's arguing the statements were privileged, opinion, true, etc., and plaintiff would be responding, here the roles are flipped because the defendant is counterclaiming against plaintiff based on plaintiff's statements.)
[C.] The court also rejected Plaintiff's arguments that the statements were nonactionable opinion: It concluded that both statements were "susceptible of being proved true or false," and were framed as factual assertions rather than using "loose or hyperbolic language that provided the impression that her statements should not be taken seriously."
asserted
statements → recall → impression
[D.] The court concluded that Defendant had introduced sufficient evidence that the statements were false:
asserted
statements → introduce → evidence
First, with respect to Plaintiff's "likeness" statements, Plaintiff repeatedly claimed that Defendant was "the first one to tie [her] likeness to the rumor."
asserted
Defendant → claim → rumor
However, Defendant provided several pieces of evidence showing that other X users linked Plaintiff to the rumor before Defendant….
asserted
users → provide → Defendant
Second, Defendant has shown a reasonable likelihood of proving by clear and convincing evidence that Plaintiff's "most damage" statements were false.
asserted
statements → show → evidence
Defendant declares that "the rumor was spread primarily by much larger voices than [Defendant's,] such as Ann Coulter's, Alex Jones's, and others."
asserted
rumor → declare → Coulter
He claims that these "prominent individuals and entities" had a "far greater reach than anything [he] posted" about Plaintiff.
uncertain
he → claim → Plaintiff
If true, this declaration could provide clear and convincing evidence that Defendant's "most damage" statements were false.
uncertain
statements → provide → evidence
At the very least, it creates a question for the jury since Plaintiff has offered competing evidence.
asserted
Plaintiff → create → evidence
…
[E.] The court also concluded that Defendant had introduced sufficient evidence that Plaintiff knew the "likeness"/"first one to tie" statements were probably false (which is required by Colorado law in such cases):
asserted
which → conclude → cases
…and 24 more, not listed.