Andrew Lattarulo is an immigration lawyer and part owner of the law firm Georges Cote LLP, which represents "thousands of clients in active immigration proceedings."
asserted
which → represent → proceedings
Lattarulo also runs a popular Instagram account featuring videos of himself discussing "know-your-rights information about U.S. immigration matters," which regularly "amasses hundreds of thousands of views."
asserted
which → run → views
Georges Cote is currently being investigated by Homeland Security Investigations ("HSI"), the investigative arm of the Department of Homeland Security ("DHS"), for employing individuals without a legal right to work in the United States.
asserted
Cote → investigate → States
Audai Cote, "the registered agent and individual in charge of I-9 compliance" at the firm, was served with a Notice of Inspection on September 8, 2025.
asserted
Cote → register → September
Unlike Lattarulo, "Cote is not an immigration attorney—he focuses on personal injury."
asserted
he → focus → injury
The firm responded on September 12, 2025, and the government sent Cote a Notice of Suspect Documents on September 25, 2025.
asserted
government → respond → September
The firm was given ten days to attempt to verify the identity and work authorization of the employees named in the Notice of Suspect Documents.
asserted
firm → give → Documents
In late September 2025, while the HSI investigation proceeded, both Lattarulo and Cote travelled from Boston to Aruba for a weekend trip.
asserted
Lattarulo → proceed → trip
On September 27, 2025, Cote arrived back at Logan Airport from Aruba without issue.
asserted
Cote → arrive → issue
Lattarulo made the same journey the following day, September 28, 2025.
asserted
Lattarulo → make → journey
Lattarulo passed through customs preclearance in Aruba before boarding a flight to Boston.
asserted
Lattarulo → pass → Boston
When his flight arrived at Logan Airport, three U.S. Customs and Border Protection ("CBP") agents and one HSI officer stopped Lattarulo as he got off the plane.
asserted
he → arrive → plane
The agents seized his cell phone without a warrant and then downloaded a complete copy of the data stored on the phone.
asserted
agents → seize → phone
Eight days later, they returned the cell phone via overnight delivery.
asserted
they → return → delivery
The seized cell phone data is currently in a format that is not readable or reviewable, but the government intends to convert the data to an accessible format and search it if the Court permits.
asserted
Court → seize → it
The data includes confidential information, including privileged attorney-client communications related to Lattarulo's clients.
asserted
data → include → clients
{The Government was clear that any search of the contents of the phone would utilize a taint team to protect privileged information.}
asserted
search → utilize → information
…
The court held that Lattarulo was likely correct on his claim that the search was unconstitutional retaliation for his speech, and therefore granted "a preliminary injunction enjoining Defendants from accessing the data obtained from the phone before this action is resolved":
"[T]he law is settled that as a general matter the First Amendment prohibits government officials from subjecting an individual to retaliatory actions, including criminal prosecutions, for speaking out." …
uncertain
Amendment → hold → prosecutions
The retaliation issue [here] turns on causation—that is, whether the seizure and search of Lattarulo's cell phone would have occurred but for his protected speech.
asserted
seizure → turn → speech
Respondents have provided no evidence that searches of cell phones are frequently conducted during the kind of employment investigation at issue here, and Lattarulo has directed the Court to sources which suggest otherwise.
asserted
which → provide → sources
Indeed, Lattarulo's evidence suggests that any pursuit of criminal charges against employers for employing unauthorized immigrants is exceedingly rare.
uncertain
pursuit → suggest → immigrants
The fact that the government, after Lattarulo spoke out publicly against it, elected to adopt a highly unusual investigative method that appears designed to inflict a maximal burden on Lattarulo lends substantial support to an inference that its actions were pretextual.
asserted
actions → speak → inference
The stage of the investigation at which the search occurred further bolsters the inference of pretext.
asserted
search → occur → pretext
Under HSI's own policies, the agency "presumes that employers who, within 10 business days of receiving a Notice of Suspect Documents, verify the identity and/or employment authorization of the listed employees, or take appropriate actions to address the apparent employment of unauthorized workers, have demonstrated reasonable care under the INA."
asserted
who → presume → INA
The government's search occurred only three days after Georges Cote first received a Notice of Suspect Documents, meaning that the agency was still early in its period of "presum[ing]" compliance when it occurred.
asserted
it → occur → compliance
Thus, the government's actions here required it to short-circuit its orderly investigative procedures and cast aside its ten-day presumption of compliance in favor of immediately seizing Lattarulo's phone.
asserted
actions → require → phone
That aggressive deviation from protocol strongly suggests that the seizure did not arise from an ordinary investigative motive.
uncertain
seizure → suggest → motive
Further, Lattarulo has identified an "otherwise similarly situated individual not engaged in the same sort of protected speech," who was not subjected to the same enforcement action: his law firm partner Audai Cote, who had the same or greater access to the firm's employment records but did not speak publicly about immigrant rights.
asserted
who → identify → rights
Indeed, if the government was truly intent on seizing evidence at the first possible opportunity, Mr. Cote, who returned to America a full day before Lattarulo, would have been a more logical target.
asserted
who → seize → Lattarulo
Nonetheless, the government opted to wait until Lattarulo touched down in Boston the next day and subject only him to an intrusive cell phone search.
asserted
Lattarulo → opt → search
The balance of the evidence currently before the Court thus suggests that Lattarulo is likely to establish that he would not have been searched except for his protected speech.
uncertain
he → suggest → speech
It is true that the presence of probable cause generally precludes a finding of causation in a retaliatory arrest case, but the Supreme Court has recognized a limited exception for situations in which officers who "have probable cause to make arrests [for a particular crime] … typically exercise their discretion not to do so," such as "an individual who has been vocally complaining about police conduct … [before being] arrested for jaywalking,"
asserted
who → preclude → jaywalking
By analogy, the limited record before the Court suggests that searches of cell phones are not regularly conducted during the kind of employment investigation at issue here and that Lattarulo's own law firm partner was not subjected to the same seizure and search of property.}
It is true that Defendants can "prevail … by showing that the [search] would have been initiated without respect to retaliation," and here Defendants state that they have additional evidence which would show as much, but they have not provided it because they assert that doing so would prejudice an ongoing investigation….
uncertain
doing → suggest → investigation
[T]he Court concludes that the limited record that is before the Court suggests that Lattarulo is likely to succeed on the merits of his First Amendment retaliation claim and that the record before it is therefore adequate to grant the limited preliminary relief contemplated by this order.
uncertain
record → conclude → order
The court didn't resolve Lattarulo's Fourth Amendment claim, because it granted the preliminary injunction based on the First Amendment claim.
uncertain
it → resolve → claim
But it did note the following:
asserted
it → note → following
Plaintiffs' Fourth Amendment claim turns largely on the scope of the border search exception to the Fourth Amendment's warrant requirement.
uncertain
claim → turn → requirement
That exception "is grounded in the government's 'inherent authority to protect, and a paramount interest in protecting, its territorial integrity.'"
asserted
exception → ground → authority
It allows the government to perform "routine" border searches of electronic devices without suspicion of any crime, and to perform "non-routine" border searches of electronic devices without a warrant, so long as the government has reasonable suspicion.
asserted
government → allow → suspicion
The question this case raises is: reasonable suspicion of what?
asserted
case → raise → what
…and 11 more, not listed.