At a seaside festival in regional South Australia, true crime obsession meets the grief of families whose loved ones are presumed murdered.
asserted
ones → meet → families
Max Marten is speaking from a wheelchair beside a wooden stage in Victor Harbor's splendid art deco theatre.
asserted
Marten → speak → theatre
"We are dealing in a subject that affects every single person in this room," the podcast producer says.
asserted
producer → deal → room
I look around me; the theatre is two-thirds full of mostly white, middle-aged women.
asserted
theatre → look → women
"You have family and friends that may not be here anymore because of what happened," Max says.
uncertain
Max → have → family
What happened is usually murder, although many of the cases being discussed at "Crime Scene Victor Harbor" — billed as Australia's first true crime festival — have never been solved.
asserted
many → happen → festival
Now, buffered from the wind in a seaside town an hour's drive from Adelaide, the audience is being asked to help.
asserted
audience → buffer → Adelaide
"Through conversation things get solved and people get listened to," Max says, before handing the microphone to Bryan Littlely, the brains behind the festival.
asserted
Max → solve → festival
Bryan, a cowboy boot-wearing former journalist, farmer and now true crime podcast host, once saw an episode of CSI: Crime Scene Investigation about a murder at a true crime convention.
asserted
Bryan → wear → convention
In the episode, called "Merchants of Menace", a murder takes place at a convention selling "murderabilia": items that were used in crimes, once belonged to killers, or artworks they produced in prison.
asserted
they → call → prison
There have been attempts to outlaw murderabilia in the US, where opponents say it trivialises or glorifies hideous crimes and further traumatises victims' families.
asserted
it → outlaw → families
It exists at the grisly fringe of true crime obsession.
asserted
It → exist → obsession
For Bryan, the episode seeded the idea of a true crime convention that he revisited after he began presenting his true crime podcast "Sleepers" in front of live audiences.
asserted
he → seed → audiences
"Making yourself available to answer questions and have the statements and the evidence challenged by the public who are ever hungry for true crime [is popular]," he tells me.
asserted
he → make → me
"It just so happens that people want to pay to see that."
asserted
people → happen → that
Why not host a true crime festival in his hometown, he thought, and bring together writers, podcasters and citizen sleuths to discuss the crimes they've wrestled into stories?
asserted
they → host → stories
As for why we're seeing a true crime renaissance, Bryan points to social media.
asserted
Bryan → see → media
"There's experts everywhere … anyone can be an investigator," including victims' families he told an Adelaide radio station ahead of the festival.
asserted
he → be → festival
"The families are speaking and there's less oversight by police, there's individual and independent investigations going on …
asserted
families → speak → police
not everyone wants to be spoken to by a police officer, and police are resource poor, they can't be looking at these cases."
asserted
they → want → cases
He promises the radio host that at Crime Scene Victor Harbor there'll be "revelations on some major cases".
asserted
He → promise → cases
Before arriving at the festival, I checked into a desolate caravan park on the edge of town.
asserted
I → arrive → town
Leaving my phone on the bed, I took a shower in the cramped bathroom of a prefab cabin.
asserted
I → leave → cabin
When I pulled the handle of the sliding door to leave the bathroom it wouldn't budge.
asserted
it → pull → bathroom
I tried again, willing my fingers into the space between the door and the frame, but nothing happened.
asserted
nothing → try → door
I wasn't panicking — yet — but I started to wonder how long it would be before someone realised I was stuck.
asserted
I → panic → ?
I wedged open a small window.
asserted
I → wedge → window
It wasn't big enough to climb out, but through a fist-sized opening I saw a single campervan and tent in an otherwise empty campground.
asserted
I → climb → campground
Eventually, a woman wearing an over-sized t-shirt and pigtails tied with rainbow scrunchies appeared.
asserted
woman → wear → scrunchies
I shouted, "hello, hello!", and she approached the window.
asserted
she → shout → window
She asked if the cabin door was locked.
asserted
door → ask → ?
Then I could hear her inside the cabin.
uncertain
I → hear → cabin
"There's frayed carpet under the door catching it," she said before pulling the carpet out and opening the door.
asserted
she → be → door
In a rush of relief, I walked out of the bathroom, smiling.
asserted
I → walk → bathroom
Then I realised I was standing beside a bed wearing nothing but a towel face-to-face with a stranger.
asserted
I → realise → stranger
"Lucky it was me," the woman said before leaving.
asserted
woman → say → ?
I took that to mean lucky I wasn't a man.
asserted
I → take → that
One theory that tries to account for true crime's popularity is that for women, the overwhelming consumers of the podcasts, TV shows and books that have proliferated over the past decade or so, it imparts useful life lessons.
asserted
it → try → lessons
But this alone doesn't explain the rise of amateur sleuths or victims' families telling their own true crime stories.
asserted
sleuths → explain → stories
We live in an age of super sleuths like "mushroom murderer" Erin Patterson — who belonged to an online community researching the crimes of Keli Lane, convicted of murdering her newborn daughter in 2010 before her own case descended into true crime mania.
asserted
case → live → mania
…and 155 more, not listed.