A Connecticut public school teacher who was suspended after refusing to remove a crucifix from her classroom is taking her First Amendment battle to a federal appeals court.
asserted
who → suspend → court
Marisol Arroyo-Castro, who had displayed the religious symbol near her desk for nearly a decade, is challenging a school district’s decision to remove it.
asserted
who → display → it
The case is scheduled for oral arguments on December 7, 2026.
asserted
case → schedule → December
Arroyo-Castro taught middle-school social studies at DiLoreto Elementary & Middle School in New Britain, Connecticut.
asserted
Castro → teach → Britain
She said the crucifix was a personal expression of her faith and a source of comfort during her working day.
asserted
crucifix → say → day
However, school administrators instructed her to take it down, warning that refusing to comply could lead to disciplinary action.
uncertain
refusing → instruct → action
The disagreement escalated in December 2024, when the teacher was reprimanded for insubordination.
asserted
teacher → escalate → insubordination
The school district subsequently removed the crucifix and suspended her for two days without pay.
asserted
district → remove → pay
She was later placed on paid administrative leave and reassigned to a non-teaching position in March 2025.
asserted
She → place → March
Teacher says crucifix was a personal expression of faith
asserted
crucifix → say → faith
Arroyo-Castro said the crucifix had been displayed near her desk for approximately 10 years.
asserted
crucifix → say → years
She described it as something that helped her remain calm while grading papers and completing other classroom work.
asserted
her → describe → work
“I pretty much kept it to myself,” she said, explaining that the symbol was a personal source of comfort.
asserted
symbol → keep → comfort
She recalled becoming emotional when administrators told her to remove it.
asserted
administrators → recall → it
According to her account, she was informed that she could return to her classroom only if she left the crucifix behind.
uncertain
she → accord → crucifix
“I said, ‘I can't,’” she recalled.
asserted
she → say → ?
Appeals court examines whether a teacher's display of a crucifix violated rules governing religious expression in public schools.
asserted
display → examine → schools
On December 11, 2024, Arroyo-Castro received a formal reprimand for insubordination.
asserted
Castro → receive → insubordination
The following day, the school removed the crucifix and suspended her for two days without pay.
asserted
school → follow → pay
On December 16, she was placed on paid administrative leave.
asserted
she → place → leave
In March 2025, she was reassigned to a role that did not involve teaching students.
asserted
that → reassign → students
“They suspended me,” she told Fox News Digital.
asserted
she → suspend → Digital
“Then they told me that they were going to pay me after that, but that I couldn't go back into the school near the children, that they didn't want me around the students, that I'm not supposed to talk to the students or interact with them or any of the staff in the school.”
asserted
I → tell → school
Federal appeals court to hear teacher's First Amendment case
Arroyo-Castro filed a federal lawsuit in January 2025, alleging that the school district had violated her First Amendment rights by restricting her religious expression.
asserted
district → hear → expression
In November 2025, a federal judge denied her request for a preliminary injunction, ruling that she was unlikely to succeed because the crucifix display constituted government speech.
asserted
display → deny → speech
The teacher subsequently appealed the decision to the US Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.
asserted
teacher → appeal → Circuit
Her legal team is arguing that the crucifix represented private religious expression rather than an endorsement of religion by the school.
asserted
crucifix → argue → school
Becky Rees Dummermuth, senior counsel at First Liberty Institute, which is representing Arroyo-Castro, said the appeal would focus on the protection afforded to teachers' private religious expression under the First Amendment.
asserted
appeal → represent → Amendment
“So we've appealed to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals, and in the next couple of weeks, on Dec. 7, we'll have an oral argument there in the Second Circuit Court of Appeals in New York City, and we'll argue before the court that Marisol's speech was private speech,” she told Fox News Digital.
asserted
she → appeal → Digital
Dummermuth also referred to the US Supreme Court's 2022 decision in the case involving former high school football coach Joe Kennedy, whose post-game prayers became the subject of a legal dispute.
asserted
prayers → refer → dispute
The attorney said the case supported the argument that public school employees do not automatically lose their right to private religious expression at work.
asserted
employees → say → work
First Liberty is relying on the First Amendment's Free Exercise and Free Speech Clauses in its challenge.
asserted
Liberty → rely → challenge
School district says dispute involved more than the crucifix
The Consolidated School District of New Britain has defended its actions, maintaining that the dispute involved concerns beyond the presence of a religious symbol in the classroom.
asserted
dispute → say → classroom
In a statement to Fox News Digital, the district said its concerns related to a broader pattern of statements and actions involving students from different religious backgrounds.
asserted
concerns → say → backgrounds
“The Consolidated School District of New Britain has consistently maintained that this matter extends beyond the presence of a religious symbol in a classroom.
asserted
matter → maintain → classroom
As outlined in the attached independent, third-party investigative report, the district's concerns involved a broader pattern of statements and actions that raised serious concerns about the treatment of students of differing religious backgrounds.”
asserted
that → outline → backgrounds
The district said it had offered Arroyo-Castro several ways to practise her faith without affecting the religious freedoms of her students, but that she and her attorneys had declined those options.
asserted
she → say → options
It also said it had a responsibility to ensure that classrooms remained inclusive and welcoming to students and families from different faiths.
asserted
classrooms → say → faiths
The district referred to an independent investigative report that included interviews with four teachers, the principal, the assistant principal and Arroyo-Castro.
asserted
that → refer → teachers
The report documented claims by some students that the teacher had referred to God, Jesus and religion in ways the investigator considered inappropriate.
uncertain
investigator → document → ways
…and 8 more, not listed.