A dispute over the management of two family trusts in Wisconsin has resulted in an appeals court upholding a contempt finding against a brother who failed to provide requested financial documents to his sister.
asserted
who → result → sister
The case centred on whether his attempt to disqualify his sister's lawyer justified delaying his discovery responses.
asserted
attempt → centre → responses
In a November 10, 2026,
decision in Anne M Bartnik v. Todd A Mackoway, available in Justia, the Wisconsin Court of Appeals affirmed a Marathon County Circuit Court order finding Todd A Mackoway in remedial contempt.
asserted
Court → affirm → contempt
The court concluded that he had other legal options to address the discovery deadline but failed to use them.
asserted
he → conclude → them
Sister sought brother's removal as trustee
asserted
Sister → seek → trustee
The dispute began on February 17, 2025, when Anne M Bartnik filed a verified petition seeking to remove her brother as successor general trustee of their mother Shirley Mackoway's two trusts.
asserted
Bartnik → begin → mother
Bartnik alleged that Mackoway had breached his fiduciary duties by failing to administer the trusts effectively, prudently, impartially and in good faith.
asserted
Mackoway → allege → faith
She also argued that his alleged hostility towards her made him unsuitable to continue as trustee.
asserted
him → argue → trustee
She asked the court to require him to provide complete trust accounting records, including information about property, liabilities, receipts and disbursements.
asserted
She → ask → property
Her petition also sought inventories, supporting documents and judicial review of his conduct as their mother's healthcare and financial agent.
asserted
petition → seek → agent
Mackoway filed a motion to dismiss the claims concerning his conduct as their mother's agent in March 2025.
uncertain
Mackoway → file → March
The court initially stayed discovery but denied his motion on July 24.
asserted
court → stay → July
He filed his response to the petition the following month.
asserted
He → file → petition
Dispute over discovery and lawyer's disqualification
On September 24, 2025, Bartnik served Mackoway with written discovery requests, including interrogatories and document production requests.
asserted
Bartnik → serve → interrogatories
He was required to respond within 30 days.
asserted
He → require → days
On October 22, Mackoway's lawyer contacted Bartnik's attorney, Mary Sue Anderson, claiming that Mackoway had previously consulted her about the same matter as a prospective client.
asserted
Mackoway → contact → client
He argued that the consultation required Anderson to withdraw from representing his sister.
asserted
consultation → argue → sister
Mackoway filed a motion seeking Anderson's disqualification and informed Bartnik's legal team that he would not attend a scheduled deposition or provide written discovery responses until the issue was resolved.
asserted
issue → file → responses
Bartnik filed motions for remedial contempt and to compel discovery on October 27, arguing that her brother had neither met his obligations nor sought an extension or protective order.
asserted
brother → file → extension
The circuit court rejected the disqualification motion on January 5, 2026.
asserted
court → reject → January
Mackoway sent his discovery responses on January 23, but the production remained incomplete.
asserted
production → send → January
Bartnik's attorney, Mary Sue Anderson, said she had received no substantive documents in response to requests one through seven, some documents for request eight, and nothing for requests nine through 14.
asserted
she → say → 14
Circuit court found contempt over missed deadline
asserted
court → find → deadline
At a February 4, 2026, hearing, the circuit court distinguished between Mackoway's failure to attend his deposition and his failure to provide written discovery responses.
asserted
court → distinguish → responses
It accepted that his decision not to attend the deposition was made in good faith while the disqualification motion remained pending.
asserted
motion → accept → faith
However, it found that his written responses had been due on October 24, 2025, and that the pending motion did not automatically suspend that obligation.
asserted
motion → find → obligation
The court noted that Mackoway had not sought an extension or stay before the deadline.
asserted
Mackoway → note → deadline
It ordered him to provide complete responses by February 11, 2026, and pay Bartnik's reasonable attorney fees relating to the contempt motion.
asserted
It → order → motion
Appeals court upheld contempt finding
Mackoway appealed, arguing that his failure to respond was not intentional because he believed discovery should pause until the court decided the disqualification issue.
asserted
court → uphold → issue
The appeals court disagreed, explaining that an intentional refusal to produce requested records can constitute contempt under Wisconsin law.
asserted
refusal → disagree → law
Mackoway could have formally objected to the requests, sought a protective order or asked the court to delay the response deadline.
uncertain
Mackoway → object → deadline
Instead, he allowed the deadline to pass without obtaining court approval.
asserted
deadline → allow → approval
The appeals court also noted that he failed to provide complete responses immediately after the disqualification motion was denied.
asserted
motion → note → responses
It rejected his argument that the circuit court had treated his deposition absence and written discovery failure inconsistently.
asserted
court → reject → absence
The deposition raised separate concerns about potentially confidential information shared during the alleged consultation, while the written requests related generally to the claims in Bartnik's petition.
uncertain
requests → raise → petition
The Wisconsin Court of Appeals affirmed the contempt order on November 10, 2026.
asserted
Court → affirm → November
The ruling addresses the discovery dispute, not the underlying allegations of trustee misconduct or whether Mackoway should ultimately be removed.
asserted
Mackoway → address → misconduct