When children move from one parent's home to the other's, existing child-support arrangements may need to be revised to reflect who is actually providing their care.
uncertain
who → move → care
An Indiana family dispute raised this issue after two daughters moved in with their father at different times and stopped visiting their mother, leading to disagreements over financial contributions, parenting-time credits and continuing support obligations.
asserted
daughters → raise → contributions
In a November 12, 2026,
decision in Joseph E Foster v. Brigitte M Foster, available on Justia, the Indiana Court of Appeals partly reversed a lower court's child-support calculations and directed it to enter a judgment of $15,275.16 in favour of the father.
asserted
Court → reverse → father
The appeals judges also reinstated the mother's child-support responsibility, clarifying that a daughter's refusal to maintain contact with her mother did not automatically end the mother's obligation to provide financial support.
asserted
refusal → reinstate → support
Daughters moved into father's home
Joseph Foster and Brigitte Foster divorced in 2016 and initially shared joint physical and legal custody of their daughters, Alyson and Lauren.
asserted
Foster → move → daughters
In November 2022, the mother received sole legal custody.
asserted
mother → receive → custody
The family arrangements changed on January 23, 2024, when Alyson moved into her father's home and stopped visiting her mother.
asserted
Alyson → change → mother
The parents agreed that child support should be recalculated from that date.
asserted
support → agree → date
Alyson began attending college in August 2024 and was subsequently treated as emancipated for support purposes.
asserted
Alyson → begin → purposes
On August 12, 2025, Lauren also moved into her father's home and stopped visiting her mother.
asserted
Lauren → move → mother
The father then sought modifications to custody and child support.
asserted
father → seek → custody
The parents eventually presented their competing calculations to the trial court in March 2026.
asserted
parents → present → March
Parents disagreed over expenses and overnight visits
asserted
Parents → disagree → expenses
The father maintained that he had covered Alyson's living expenses until her emancipation and was responsible for Lauren's expenses after she moved in with him.
asserted
she → maintain → him
The mother argued that she had continued contributing towards the children's needs, including Lauren's vehicle, mobile phone, medical expenses and college-credit courses.
asserted
she → argue → vehicle
She also referred to school lunches, testing fees and other expenses she had previously paid.
asserted
she → refer → lunches
Another disagreement concerned parenting-time credits.
asserted
disagreement → concern → credits
The mother sought credit for 182 overnight visits with Lauren, arguing that the daughter's decision to stop visiting was not her responsibility.
asserted
decision → seek → Lauren
The father disputed this claim, pointing out that Lauren had not spent any nights at her mother's home after moving in with him.
uncertain
Lauren → dispute → him
Both parents agreed that the father's weekly income was $9,038 and the mother's was $1,471.48.
asserted
mother → agree → ?
Lower court found father had overpaid
The Lake Circuit Court divided the support calculations into three periods.
asserted
Court → find → periods
It calculated that the father owed the mother $14,442 between January 23 and August 15, 2024, and another $29,640 between August 15, 2024, and August 12, 2025.
asserted
father → calculate → August
For the period after Lauren moved in with her father, the court calculated an additional $12,123, while allowing the mother credit for 182 overnight visits.
asserted
court → move → visits
The court determined that the father's total support obligation was $56,205 and that he had paid $60,568.
asserted
he → determine → 60,568
It therefore found that he had overpaid by $4,363.
asserted
he → find → 4,363
The court also concluded that Lauren had repudiated her relationship with her mother without just cause and ended the mother's future child-support obligation.
asserted
Lauren → conclude → obligation
Appeals court rejects parenting-time credit
asserted
court → reject → credit
The Indiana Court of Appeals agreed with the calculations for the first two periods but found that the lower court had made an error when calculating support after Lauren moved.
asserted
Lauren → agree → support
The appeals judges noted that all three family members had acknowledged that Lauren had not spent any overnight visits with her mother after moving out.
asserted
Lauren → note → mother
Under Indiana Child Support Guideline 6, parenting-time credits must reflect actual overnight stays.
asserted
credits → reflect → stays
The mother could not receive credit for 182 visits that had never occurred.
uncertain
that → receive → visits
The court recalculated her weekly support obligation for the relevant 32-week period at $71.88, resulting in an additional $2,300.16 in the father's favour.
asserted
court → recalculate → favour
Mother's support obligation reinstated
asserted
obligation → reinstate → ?
The appeals court also disagreed with the decision to end the mother's child-support responsibility because Lauren had rejected their relationship.
asserted
Lauren → disagree → relationship
It explained that a child's repudiation of a parent may, in certain circumstances, affect that parent's responsibility for college expenses.
uncertain
repudiation → explain → expenses
However, this does not automatically eliminate the separate obligation to provide child support.
asserted
this → eliminate → support
Relying on earlier Indiana decisions, including Bales v. Bales and Lovold v. Ellis, the court clarified that a child's estrangement cannot by itself serve as a defence against an existing child-support obligation.
asserted
estrangement → rely → obligation
The appeals court ultimately calculated the father's overpayment at $15,275.16, based on a payment history showing that he had paid $57,057.
asserted
he → calculate → 57,057
It affirmed part of the lower court's order, reversed the disputed portions and sent the case back for further proceedings to determine the mother's remaining support obligation.
asserted
It → affirm → obligation