THE Federal Constitutional Court marked its first anniversary on Friday with a commemorative stamp.
asserted
Court → mark → stamp
Speaking on the occasion, its chief justice remarked on how fleeting the year had been.
asserted
year → speak → occasion
Litigants, lawyers and the judges of the Supreme Court might have described it differently.
uncertain
Litigants → describe → it
A year after the 27th Amendment rewrote the structure of the country’s judiciary, one of the most basic questions raised by the new order remains unanswered: which court, the FCC or the SC, has the final word?
asserted
court → rewrite → word
This was, perhaps, bound to happen.
asserted
This → bind → ?
Critics had foreseen problems in the short and hurried route the government took from the 26th to the 27th Amendment.
asserted
government → foresee → Amendment
In October 2024, the 26th Amendment carved constitutional benches out of the SC, with their members chosen by a reconstituted Judicial Commission in which judges no longer held a majority.
asserted
judges → carve → majority
Critics warned then that the independence of the judiciary was at stake.
asserted
independence → warn → stake
Barely a year later, and in evident haste, the 27th Amendment turned those benches into an entirely separate court.
asserted
Amendment → turn → court
Two of the SC’s senior-most judges resigned in protest the day it became law.
asserted
it → resign → protest
Thousands of cases were soon transferred to the FCC, and the SC was stripped of its constitutional jurisdiction.
asserted
SC → transfer → jurisdiction
What has followed has seemed less a division of labour than a contest for primacy.
asserted
followed → follow → primacy
Last December, the FCC held that its rulings bind all courts, including the SC, but that the latter’s do not bind the FCC.
asserted
latter → hold → FCC
In May, Chief Justice Yahya Afridi pushed back, ruling that the two are coordinate courts, neither an appellate forum over the other.
uncertain
neither → push → other
Last month, the FCC rebuked an SC bench for revisiting a matter the FCC considered settled, raising concerns over judicial discipline.
asserted
FCC → rebuke → discipline
The sparring shows no sign of stopping.
asserted
sparring → show → stopping
The text of the amendment arguably favours the FCC, while the SC relies on the overall constitutional scheme to assert its position.
asserted
SC → favour → position
That both positions can be argued is precisely the problem.
asserted
positions → argue → ?
Two hasty amendments have created an ambiguity that leaves the two courts defining their relationship through pointed observations in their judgments.
asserted
that → create → judgments
The costs are borne by litigants, whose cases risk being shuttled between forums.
asserted
cases → bear → forums
The FCC, meanwhile, has worked with seven judges against a sanctioned strength of 13.
asserted
FCC → work → 13
And its order barring the Peshawar High Court from hearing petitions on emergency and governor’s rule in KP has pushed citizens away from a court closer to home.
asserted
order → bar → home
Since parliament created this ambiguity, it must now resolve it.
asserted
it → create → it
The jurisdiction of the two courts and a mechanism for settling disputes between them should be spelt out in law, not left to judges to fight over.
asserted
jurisdiction → settle → judges
As long as its independence remains in doubt, it will struggle to win public confidence.
asserted
it → remain → confidence