A custody dispute can become more complicated when harassment between former spouses begins affecting their parenting arrangements and children's welfare.
asserted
harassment → become → arrangements
In Alabama, a father who was found to have sent threatening emails to his former wife using a fictitious identity challenged a court order that gave her sole custody of their three children.
asserted
that → find → children
The Alabama Court of Civil Appeals has now upheld the custody decision and a protection order against him, but sent the case back to reconsider how much time he can spend with the children.
asserted
he → uphold → children
In a November 13, 2026
opinion, the appeals court affirmed the protection-from-abuse order and most of the lower court's custody judgment in G.W.G. v. V.M.G., available on Justia.
asserted
court → affirm → Justia
However, it ruled that limiting the father's supervised visits to six hours every other week went further than necessary and required the trial court to establish a different visitation schedule.
asserted
limiting → rule → schedule
Dispute escalated after divorce
asserted
Dispute → escalate → divorce
According to the court's opinion, the former couple divorced in January 2023 and initially shared joint legal and physical custody of their three children.
uncertain
couple → accord → children
Their agreement also prohibited them from harassing each other or making derogatory comments about one another in front of the children.
asserted
agreement → prohibit → children
The mother later alleged that the father had repeatedly harassed her, prompting her to seek a custody modification and a protection-from-abuse order in November and December 2023.
asserted
father → allege → November
She requested sole legal and physical custody, saying their attempts to communicate through a parenting application and attend co-parenting counselling had failed.
asserted
attempts → request → counselling
The dispute also involved emails sent under the name "John Tyler".
asserted
dispute → involve → name
The mother testified that the messages attempted to pressure her into recording an explicit video involving the father and threatened to contact her employer and report her to the Department of Human Resources if she did not comply.
asserted
she → testify → Resources
She said the emails contained personal information about her vehicle, including its identification number and registration details.
asserted
emails → say → number
The father initially denied sending them, but text messages admitted into evidence included his acknowledgement that he was the person behind the "John Tyler" emails.
asserted
he → deny → emails
He later disputed that the message amounted to an admission of guilt.
asserted
message → dispute → guilt
Court finds father responsible for emails
asserted
father → find → emails
The trial court considered the emails alongside testimony from the mother, a family therapist and a police officer.
asserted
court → consider → mother
The therapist described a co-parenting session in which the father allegedly shouted and moved towards the mother, making the therapist concerned for their safety.
uncertain
therapist → describe → safety
A police officer also testified about reports concerning the father's conduct and recorded telephone conversation in which he discussed sending emails to the mother.
asserted
he → testify → mother
In its January 2026 judgment, the trial court found that the father had used a fictitious identity to send the harassing messages.
asserted
father → find → messages
It also expressed concern about his fixation on the mother's relationships and whereabouts, and found that he had used visitation with the children to advance his efforts to control her.
asserted
he → express → her
The court awarded the mother sole legal and physical custody.
asserted
court → award → custody
It ordered the father to have supervised visits every other Saturday and Sunday, for three hours each day, with supervision provided by the Bridge Center.
asserted
It → order → Center
He was also required to pay the associated costs.
asserted
He → require → costs
The father was further prohibited from going within 300 feet of the mother's residence and from arranging surveillance of her or the children through another person.
asserted
father → prohibit → person
Appeals court upholds protection order
asserted
court → uphold → order
The father challenged the admission of the emails, arguing that they had not been properly authenticated and should not have been considered as evidence.
asserted
they → challenge → evidence
The appeals court rejected this argument, pointing to his text message acknowledging that he had sent them.
asserted
he → reject → them
The judges also upheld the protection-from-abuse order, which prohibited him from contacting, harassing or stalking the mother and required him to stay away from her residence, workplace and the children's school.
asserted
which → uphold → residence
The order was set to remain effective until March 6, 2027.
asserted
order → set → March
The appeals court also left the mother's sole custody arrangement intact, along with the requirement that the father pay for supervised visitation.
asserted
father → leave → visitation
Why judges ordered a new visitation schedule
However, the appeals court found that the lower court had imposed an overly restrictive visitation schedule.
asserted
court → order → schedule
It noted that there was no evidence that the father had abused the children or that his conduct towards the mother had harmed their relationship with him.
asserted
conduct → note → him
A visitation supervisor had also testified that the children appeared comfortable during a supervised visit and interacted positively with their father.
asserted
children → testify → father
The judges agreed that supervised visits were justified, particularly because the father had threatened to take the children to Louisiana.
asserted
father → agree → Louisiana
However, they concluded that limiting him to six hours of supervised contact every other week was not sufficiently tailored to the concerns identified by the trial court.
asserted
limiting → conclude → court
On November 13, 2026, the Alabama Court of Civil Appeals reversed that specific visitation restriction and sent the matter back to the lower court to determine an appropriate schedule.
asserted
Court → reverse → schedule
The decision leaves the mother's sole custody and the protection order in place, while requiring the court to reconsider the father's visitation hours.
asserted
decision → leave → hours