Losing parental rights can permanently change a family's future, particularly when young children have spent years living with other caregivers.
asserted
children → lose → caregivers
In Alabama, a mother who lost her parental rights to her two children challenged a court decision that allowed them to remain with their respective caregivers.
asserted
them → lose → caregivers
The Alabama Court of Civil Appeals has now reversed part of that decision, restoring the mother's parental rights to her older child while allowing the termination involving her younger daughter to stand.
asserted
termination → reverse → daughter
In a November 13, 2026
opinion available on Justia, the appeals court also upheld the termination of the father's parental rights to both children.
asserted
court → uphold → children
The case, N.H. v. M.D., arose from separate proceedings involving the children's maternal great-aunt and a foster caregiver.
asserted
case → arise → aunt
Children placed with different caregivers
According to the court's opinion, the mother and father were never married but had two children together.
uncertain
mother → place → children
Their older child, K.P., was born on December 15, 2020, and allegedly tested positive for illegal drugs at birth.
uncertain
child → bear → birth
The Barbour County Department of Human Resources (DHR) subsequently initiated dependency proceedings, and the juvenile court placed the child with the maternal great-aunt.
asserted
court → initiate → aunt
Their younger child, No.H., was born on April 5, 2022, and also allegedly tested positive for illegal drugs.
uncertain
child → bear → drugs
Following separate dependency proceedings, she was placed with a licensed foster parent.
asserted
she → follow → parent
Although the great-aunt briefly obtained custody of both children, she later returned the younger child to the foster caregiver.
asserted
she → obtain → caregiver
In October 2024, the great-aunt and the younger child's custodian separately petitioned to terminate the parents' parental rights.
asserted
aunt → petition → rights
After a trial on February 24, 2026, the Barbour Juvenile Court entered judgments in favour of the petitions on March 5, 2026, finding that neither parent was willing or able to provide appropriate care and that there were no viable alternatives to termination.
asserted
parent → enter → termination
The court awarded permanent custody of the older child to the great-aunt and the younger child to the foster caregiver.
asserted
court → award → caregiver
Court examines mother's efforts to maintain contact
asserted
Court → examine → contact
During the proceedings, the great-aunt testified that she had allowed both parents to visit the children at her home in Dothan.
asserted
parents → testify → Dothan
She said she had even offered them money for petrol to make the journey from Eufaula, but estimated that the mother had visited only four or five times since 2022.
asserted
mother → say → 2022
The father had visited two or three times.
asserted
father → visit → ?
The mother attributed her limited contact to transportation difficulties and communication problems.
asserted
mother → attribute → difficulties
She also said she had attempted to arrange visits and had offered financial assistance for the children's needs.
asserted
she → say → needs
The younger child's foster caregiver similarly testified that the mother had contacted her only occasionally.
asserted
mother → testify → her
She said she had taken the child to meet her mother twice in Eufaula, including on the child's third birthday in April 2025.
asserted
she → say → April
The mother acknowledged that she had not provided financial support for the younger child and had seen her only three times.
asserted
she → acknowledge → her
However, she said her circumstances had improved.
asserted
circumstances → say → ?
By the time of the trial, she was sober, had maintained the same residence for six years, was employed as a restaurant manager and was raising another young son.
asserted
she → maintain → son
The guardian ad litem also acknowledged that the mother had made progress and was able to care for her youngest son after separating from the children's father.
asserted
mother → acknowledge → father
Appeals court distinguishes between the two children
asserted
court → distinguish → children
The Alabama Court of Civil Appeals agreed that the evidence supported terminating the mother's parental rights to the younger child.
asserted
evidence → agree → child
The foster caregiver and her husband had provided the child's primary care since infancy and intended to adopt her.
asserted
caregiver → provide → her
The court concluded that ending the mother's parental rights would provide the younger child with greater stability and permanency.
asserted
ending → conclude → stability
However, the judges reached a different conclusion concerning the older child.
asserted
judges → reach → child
The older child had remained with the maternal great-aunt since the beginning of the dependency proceedings.
asserted
child → remain → proceedings
The great-aunt testified that she intended to continue caring for the child permanently but did not plan to adopt her.
asserted
she → testify → her
The appeals court found that the lower court had not adequately established how terminating the mother's parental rights would benefit the older child.
asserted
terminating → find → child
Since the child already had a safe and stable home with the great-aunt, maintaining that arrangement without terminating the mother's rights remained a viable alternative.
asserted
maintaining → have → rights
The judges also emphasised that parental rights should not be terminated when doing so would provide no additional benefit to the child.
asserted
doing → emphasise → child
Father's parental rights remain terminated
asserted
rights → terminate → ?
The appeals court separately rejected the father's challenges to the termination of his parental rights.
asserted
court → reject → rights
It noted evidence of his longstanding substance-abuse problems, inconsistent visits and lack of financial support.
asserted
It → note → support
The court also considered evidence that the youngest son had tested positive for illegal drugs while in association with the father.
asserted
son → consider → father
…and 4 more, not listed.