Charles Lammam argued on Nov. 11 that Ottawa should drop its boast of the lowest net debt in the G7, because the measure counts pension assets the government cannot use and leaves out obligations it must pay.
asserted
it → argue → obligations
Twelve readers left 16 comments.
asserted
readers → leave → comments
Read on for how The Hub community is thinking about this issue.
asserted
community → read → issue
What readers granted
No reader defended the budget’s preferred number.
asserted
reader → grant → number
Randy Stellings set the tone: “Canadians are seriously misgoverned when it’s abundantly evident that governments, federal and provincial, well know they are misconstruing the fiscal situation of the country.”
asserted
they → set → country
Gordon Edwards allowed that most people, not only politicians, cherry-pick data that suits their case.
asserted
that → allow → case
“But this is an egregious misrepresentation of the country’s accounts,” he wrote.
asserted
he → write → accounts
“The great banker knows better.”
asserted
banker → know → ?
Ben Heller fastened on the pension point.
asserted
Heller → fasten → point
He recalled his father telling him the Liberals think it is all their money, and wrote that “this is literally the Liberals thinking our pensions are available for their needs.”
asserted
pensions → recall → needs
J. A. Boessenkool offered an explanation for why the low number persuades.
asserted
number → offer → explanation
A bank assessing a loan counts a customer’s RRSP and TFSA as assets, he wrote, so the budget’s accounting looks familiar.
asserted
accounting → assess → assets
“I suspect that the average person will not understand the argument because of what they experience at a financial institution!”
asserted
they → suspect → institution
The difference, he argued, is what a lender does next: “Financial institutions do not normally lend you money knowing the way you live that your debts will only increase.”
asserted
debts → argue → way
Where they broke
The break was not with Lammam’s conclusion but with his frame.
asserted
break → break → frame
Bryan Moir argued that settling on the right debt figure is only the start.
asserted
settling → argue → figure
“There is only one taxpayer,” he wrote, and adding federal, provincial and municipal debt to the obligations of Crown corporations and agencies makes the picture “considerably more troubling than Ottawa’s preferred talking point suggests.”
uncertain
point → be → corporations
Even that, for Moir, misses the point.
asserted
that → miss → point
“The relevant question isn’t whether Canada can borrow more than other G7 countries.
asserted
Canada → borrow → countries
It’s whether Canadians are receiving sufficient economic value from the debt they are already being asked to service.”
asserted
they → ’ → debt
“The Joneses’ larger mortgage doesn’t make ours any more affordable.
asserted
ours → make → ?
And the bank’s willingness to lend us more doesn’t make borrowing a wise economic decision.”
asserted
borrowing → lend → more
Michael Giguere blamed the press: “Why would media major outlets publish proper debt numbers when they themselves are recipients of tax payer largesse.”
asserted
they → blame → largesse
Yvan Savard and Kim Morton looked instead at the public.
asserted
Savard → look → public
Savard imagined where the country could be with an accountable government and “a population that cared enough to actually get informed.”
uncertain
that → imagine → government
Morton cited “a lack of knowledge and concern by the majority of the population.”
asserted
Morton → cite → population
What they proposed
Moir had the most concrete ask.
asserted
Moir → propose → ask
He wants “a consolidated accounting of the annual debt-servicing costs borne by Canadians across all levels of government,” including Crown corporations and public agencies, without double-counting.
asserted
He → want → counting
His complaint was about where the debate spends its energy: “We spend considerable time debating how much more governments can afford to borrow and remarkably little examining what Canadians have received for the debt already incurred.”
asserted
Canadians → spend → debt
Stellings went further and suggested that misstatements about the country’s ability to borrow “should be grounds for a legal challenge.”
uncertain
misstatements → go → challenge
The exchange worth reading
The shortest comment drew the thread’s best back-and-forth.
asserted
comment → draw → back
“Do Canadians even want to know?” asked Mark Whiffen.
asserted
Whiffen → want → ?
Kim Morton replied: “Probably not.
asserted
Morton → reply → ?
Until the bill becomes due.”
asserted
bill → become → ?
Morton then wrote that the grandchildren’s generation “should rightfully throw us all out in a snowbank” and get on with cleaning up the mess.
asserted
generation → write → mess
Patick Beck had a condition: “Just make sure that you start with the politicians!”
asserted
you → have → politicians
“If it was up to me politicians would get minimum wage and no taxpayer funded pension plan.”
asserted
politicians → get → wage
SCOTT MACKINNON took the budget’s rosy number at its word and asked for the obvious dividend: “Since our economic situation is so great, why not cut my income taxes in half?”
asserted
situation → take → half
Our weekly Wisdom of Crowds article picks the essay that generated the most reader comments in the preceding week and uses those comments to summarise how The Hub community is thinking about an important issue in the news.
asserted
community → pick → news
Get your comment featured in a future edition by joining the debate that starts at the bottom of every article we publish.
asserted
we → get → article