Every year, as November approaches, Pakistan’s sugar sector gets embroiled in a familiar cycle of controversy, uncertainty and competing interests.
asserted
sector → approach → controversy
Growers want millers to start crushing on time, offer fair prices and ensure timely payments.
asserted
millers → want → payments
Millers, on their part, cite unsold inventories, uncertainty over export and financial constraints as reasons for delaying operations.
asserted
Millers → cite → operations
Caught between the two, the government struggles to protect consumers by keeping sugar prices affordable without undermining the financial viability of the industry.
asserted
government → catch → industry
More often than not, it fails to satisfy either side, leaving the sector mired in uncertainty at the start of another crushing season.
asserted
it → fail → season
This recurring confrontation is more than a seasonal disagreement between farmers and industrialists.
asserted
confrontation → recur → farmers
It rather reflects the failure of successive governments to evolve a coherent, long-term framework for managing sugarcane production, procurement, processing and marketing.
asserted
It → reflect → production
Consequently, what should be a routine agricultural and industrial activity has instead become an annual flashpoint, holding everyone – rural livelihoods, the sugar supply chain and consumers – hostage for the next entire year.
asserted
be → become → year
In recent years, alongside this annual controversy, an equally contentious pattern has emerged: a recurring cycle of sugar exports, subsequent price hikes and eventual imports.
asserted
pattern → emerge → exports
Under pressure from millers, the government invariably allows export, sometimes even subsidising it – ostensibly to earn foreign exchange, offload surplus inventories and help start crushing season.
asserted
government → allow → season
However, as domestic supplies tighten and prices begin to soar, the government scrambles to import sugar to stabilise the market.
asserted
government → tighten → market
Farmers are protesting delay in crushing; millers want export of sugar, holding crushing season hostage; the government appears reluctant and the situation is approaching a boiling point.
asserted
situation → protest → point
A policy can only be sustainable if it balances the interests of all three parties.
asserted
it → balance → parties
Farmers are protesting the delay in crushing operations.
asserted
Farmers → protest → operations
Millers, not satisfied with export permission of 200,000 tonnes, want to send out another 1.1 million tonnes.
asserted
Millers → want → tonnes
The government, bitten by the last experience of export, is reluctant.
asserted
government → bite → export
According to the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, Pakistan exported approximately 765,734 tonnes of sugar (against permitted 700,000 tonnes) during the first 11 months of FY2024-25, generating around $411 million.
uncertain
Pakistan → accord → million
These exports were authorised in phases after the government and industry apparently sat together many times and identified a substantial domestic surplus.
asserted
government → authorise → surplus
However, the domestic price situation belied surplus claims.
uncertain
situation → belie → claims
By June 2025, retail prices jumped to Rs200 per kgi n most parts of the country, and the government approved an import plan for 500,000 tonnes to boost domestic supplies.
asserted
government → jump → supplies
The SBP in a 2024-25 report linked export with squeezed domestic availability and sugar price trends.
asserted
SBP → link → availability
It also noted that sugar contributed significantly to urban food inflation during the same period.
asserted
sugar → note → period
This reversal raised a fundamental question: how did a country, with surplus stocks for exports, find itself in short supply within months and was forced to import the same commodity?
asserted
country → raise → commodity
Though the government never answered this question, the critics, however, did.
asserted
critics → answer → question
To them, most of the millers belong to, what they pejoratively call, sugar mafia, and the ruling elite and it is the most convenient way to make a windfall of hundreds of billions of rupees within a few months.
asserted
it → belong → months
The State Bank of Pakistan, in its 2024-25 report, linked export with squeezed domestic availability and sugar price trends in the second half of the financial year.
asserted
Bank → link → year
It also noted that sugar contributed significantly to urban food inflation during the same period.
asserted
sugar → note → period
The foreign exchange argument proved equally false.
asserted
argument → prove → ?
Price differential is a routine when transactions take place at different times, but the comparison does raise questions about the assumptions and consequences of exporting sugar and then importing at a higher price.
asserted
comparison → take → price
A briefing to the National Assembly in October 2026 further deflated the export case when it was told that 306,737 tonnes of sugar was imported at a total cost of Rs54.16bn.
asserted
tonnes → deflate → Rs54.16bn
Approximately 198,668 tonnes had been sold at an average price of Rs168 per kg, while 108,069 tonnes is still with the Trading Corporation of Pakistan, and the government is considering the export option.
asserted
government → sell → option
Now consider the final reality: Pakistan first exported sugar, subsequently imported to restore domestic supplies, and then faced the cost of unsold imported stocks.
asserted
Pakistan → consider → stocks
The ECC this September noted inaccurate demand-and-supply projections and the cost of holding imported sugar stocks.
asserted
ECC → note → stocks
It is not to say that sugar exports or imports are undesirable: both can be justified under appropriate circumstances.
asserted
both → say → circumstances
The problem is when such decisions are made without reliable assessments of production, consumption, carryover and strategic reserves – or, as critics allege, at the behest of vested interests, the consequences are then borne by all, by consumers through price volatility, by farmers through market uncertainty, and by taxpayers through the costs of inventory management.
asserted
consequences → make → management
Millers are once again pressing for export of sugar, with the crushing season being held hostage.
asserted
season → press → sugar
The government appears reluctant and the situation is approaching a boiling point.
asserted
situation → appear → point
What Pakistan needs, therefore, is not another round of ad hoc and unsubstantiated decisions on exports, imports or prices, but a predictable, long-term, transparent and rules-based policy framework that brings certainty to the sector.
asserted
that → need → sector
To achieve this, it must establish a credible system for assessing sugarcane production, expected sugar recovery, domestic consumption, carryover stocks and exportable surpluses before authorising any exports.
asserted
it → achieve → exports
It must be linked to independently verified estimates and the maintenance of strategic reserves, rather than granted permission for export under pressure from the industry, later lick price wounds and scramble to contain price increases through import.
asserted
It → link → import
…and 8 more, not listed.