Millions of Australians were unable to use their Outlook emails during the Microsoft outage that spanned most of the day on Friday.
asserted
that → use → Friday
This halted business operations, interrupted workdays and made everyday online actions extremely difficult for many.
But if you're expecting to be compensated for the headaches the outage brought, don't expect a big cash payout.
asserted
outage → halt → payout
Could we be compensated for the Microsoft outage?
uncertain
we → compensate → outage
Yes, but it will probably just be businesses, RMIT Associate Professor Mark Gregory says.
asserted
Gregory → say → ?
Dr Gregory says a service level agreement that businesses have with providers such as Microsoft will often have requirements that certain targets are met.
asserted
targets → say → requirements
"Some of these agreements have mechanisms for compensation if the targets are not met," Dr Gregory says.
asserted
Gregory → have → compensation
"The typical scenario though is that the compensation is in terms of returning a percentage of the monthly or annual fee for using that service.
asserted
compensation → return → service
"It doesn't normally extend to lost productivity.
asserted
It → extend → productivity
"
Microsoft's agreements would only cover the loss of that service, but not the knock-on effects of that, Deakin IT lecturer Fariha Jaigirdar says.
asserted
Jaigirdar → cover → that
"The loss of productivity is not something they are bound to compensate for," Dr Jaigirdar.
asserted
they → bind → productivity
And this compensation is generally made in terms of a credit, which could equate to a small discount on the company's next bill.
uncertain
which → make → bill
"If people are expecting [that] cash will be in their account … that is not something that is going to happen," Dr Jaigirdar says.
asserted
Jaigirdar → expect → account
It's unclear how Microsoft will address calls for compensation in the coming days, with the global nature of the outage putting pressure on the technology giant to repair its reputation.
uncertain
nature → address → reputation
The ABC has contacted Microsoft for comment.
asserted
ABC → contact → comment
There isn't one dollar figure that would apply to every business, Dr Jaigirdar says
This all depends on how much a business pays for its Microsoft services.
And this also depends on whether a business can successfully file a compensation claim with Microsoft, which requires certain information to process compensation.
uncertain
which → be → compensation
While larger companies with legal departments might have in-house experts to make a claim, the process could be tricky for smaller businesses to navigate, Dr Jaigirdar says.
uncertain
Jaigirdar → have → claim
"I don't think it's a very straightforward process," she says.
asserted
she → think → ?
Credit won't cover losses
asserted
Credit → cover → losses
While a credit towards a monthly bill couldn't hurt, it could be a drop in the ocean compared with what some businesses lost on Friday.
uncertain
businesses → hurt → Friday
"The credit is tiny compared with the loss of productivity," Dr Gregory says.
"
asserted
Gregory → compare → productivity
It's a bit like when there's a telco outage, people ultimately just have to wear it and move on."
asserted
people → be → it
Dr Gregory says providers such as Microsoft might argue that it's up to businesses to sort out productivity insurance and have alternative workarounds during outages, but it's not that simple.
uncertain
it → say → outages
He says that may well be the case for preparing for things such as telecommunications outages, by having another SIM card, for example.
uncertain
that → say → example
"[But] with IT and with software, it's not so easy," Dr Gregory says.
"
asserted
Gregory → say → software
It's not something that you can easily duplicate.
asserted
you → duplicate → that
That argument, to some extent, does not hold water."
What could the ACCC do?
uncertain
ACCC → hold → What
"There is potential for the ACCC to weigh in on the matter, the problem is of course under what section of the act," Dr Gregory says.
asserted
Gregory → be → act
There were changes to the legislation that permitted the ACCC to take action against companies that provide telecommunications services.
asserted
that → be → services
"[But] that would be in terms of a legal action over the outage, not in relation to compensation," Dr Gregory says.
asserted
Gregory → say → compensation
"It's a question of really what the purpose of the class action is and whether or not they would try to go beyond the loss of service compensation to loss of productively compensation," Dr Gregory says.
asserted
Gregory → try → compensation
"There may be law firms that want to go to court to just see where the limits are.
uncertain
limits → want → court
"Sometimes this is positive because then it makes it clear about the strengths or weaknesses of current legislation."
asserted
it → make → legislation
The ABC is aware of at least one legal firm investigating the potential for a class action lawsuit over the outage.
asserted
ABC → investigate → outage
Victoria Peak Litigation Funding is currently putting the call out for businesses and individuals who may have suffered financial losses as a result of the outage.
uncertain
who → put → outage
However, the firm is careful to stress that registering to take part "does not establish entitlement to compensation or mean that proceedings have commenced".
asserted
proceedings → stress → compensation
And even if a class action does get off the ground and is successful, it can take quite a while until participants see any money.
asserted
participants → get → money
Calls for automated compensation
Dr Gregory says this saga highlights the need for tougher legislation about how people are compensated when big providers — such as Microsoft — fail.
asserted
providers → automate → Microsoft
"The Australian government does need to look at automated compensation," he says.
asserted
he → need → compensation
"But also strengthening sovereign capability so that things like outages outside Australia don't impact productivity inside Australia."
While Dr Jaigirdar doesn't expect changes to be made to legislation overnight, she's hopeful it will prompt action.
asserted
it → strengthen → action
"This is adding serious fuel to the regulatory fire in our country," she says.
asserted
she → add → country
…and 2 more, not listed.