This happened when the board was deciding whether to allow a long-term lease of space on weekends to a church, pursuant to a policy that allowed such leases for community groups generally.
asserted
that → happen → groups
And, a federal court held Friday, this violated the First Amendment.
asserted
this → hold → Amendment
Plaintiff Matt Gioia moved his family from Colorado to Maine in the summer of 2020 to start a new church.
asserted
Gioia → move → church
Gioia was born in Waterville, Maine, and lived in Guilford, Maine until he graduated high school and joined the military at seventeen years old.
asserted
he → bear → military
Initially, Gioia's church—The Pines Church—gathered at his home.
asserted
church → gather → home
In March of 2021, The Pines Church began holding Sunday morning services at a movie theater in Orono, Maine, pursuant to a month-to-month lease arrangement.
asserted
Church → begin → arrangement
As the Church grew, Gioia began to look for a new space that could accommodate a larger group.
uncertain
that → grow → group
Gioia sought space from the Hermon School Department, which generally opens up its facilities to various groups:
asserted
which → seek → groups
This policy provides that "[s]chool facilities should be made available for appropriate community use when such facilities are not required for their primary purposes: the instruction of students and related school activities."
asserted
facilities → provide → students
The policy distinguishes between "occasional or short-term use of school facilities," which "shall be authorized by the school principal," and "long-term rental or lease," which "shall be authorized by the Hermon School Committee upon the recommendation of the Superintendent of Schools."
asserted
which → distinguish → Schools
But the Hermon School Committee (which consisted of "Committee Chair Jesse Keith, Vice Chair Karen Shorey, Stephanie Oiler, Haily Keezer, and Christopher McLaughlin") denied the Church's request for a year-long or six-month lease, allowing only a month-to-month lease (which appeared to be inadequate for the church, given its need for a stable meeting location).
asserted
which → consist → location
Here's part of the summary of the facts, based on the bench trial that the court held:
asserted
court → base → that
The next day [after a hearing], a former committee member emailed Keith and Shorey to share her belief "that it is not in our communities [sic] best interest to lease one of our school facilities to any religious organization," warning that "[t]here is a quiet movement in our country by some conservative religious groups who are actively working to soften the boundaries between church/state, starting with our schools" and that granting the Church a lease would lead to "a slippery slope."
asserted
granting → email → slope
She wondered how the Hermon School Department would have to respond to a similar request from "an Imam who wants to open a mosque," in light of the "precedent" set by a lease to The Pines Church.
asserted
who → wonder → Church
Her email concluded with unintended irony: "There's a reason why the founding fathers wrote the constitution the way they did."
asserted
they → conclude → constitution
Keith and Shorey denied at trial that this email influenced their decision-making with respect to the Church's lease request, which I find implausible in light of the trial record….
asserted
I → deny → record
McLaughlin reached out to [HSD Superintendent Micah] Grant and explained that he "had a few additional questions" for Gioia:
asserted
he → reach → Gioia
McLaughlin "wanted to get a better sense of how [T]he Pines Church approaches issues of diversity, equity, and inclusion around their messaging around some key issues relevant to marginalized communities."
asserted
Church → want → communities
Those questions requested information about the Church's views on same-sex marriage, "[a]ccess to safe and affordable abortion," "[a]ccess to gender affirming medical care," "[c]onversion therapy for LGBTQIA+ individuals (youth and adults)," and "[i]nclusive sexual education and access to birth control for youth."
asserted
questions → request → youth
[At a later meeting, High School Principal Brian] Walsh took the podium and explained that he had several reservations about the Church's request.
asserted
he → take → request
He first explained that it would be difficult to find the staff to clean the building on Sunday afternoons.
asserted
it → explain → afternoons
But apart from this, he continued:
[W]e've never had a long-term lease, at least over my twenty-one years here, and I think there's a number of reasons we don't do that.
asserted
we → continue → that
There's a lot of variables we just don't know.
asserted
we → be → variables
No question our students should come first, our program should come first.
asserted
program → come → ?
We also don't know or have the sense of how this will be promoted, to [the student representative's] question.
asserted
this → know → question
If you put Hermon High School's name with a church or another organization with different beliefs than the school has, I see that as problematic.
asserted
I → put → that
But again, that's where I sit and that's where I stand.
asserted
I → sit → ?
Doesn't mean this organization won't do a great job, doesn't mean they won't support, hopefully, our mission as well.
asserted
they → mean → mission
I just don't know, there are too many variables with that and again we have not—we have never done that.
What I would not want is for students to feel like a group organization that we are renting to, their vision or their mission is now ours.
asserted
vision → know → that
And there's a blurred line when it comes to that.
asserted
it → be → that
I have nothing against this church, this reverend, or anything, we've just never said yes to something like this, so probably why it's in your hands, because you guys get to make that decision.
asserted
guys → have → decision
I'm looking at the facility and some other variables, so that's kind of—that's where I come from….
asserted
I → look → where
[At a later meeting,] Oiler then made a motion for a month-to-month lease, citing concerns about the number of people and cleaning the space afterwards, which she was careful to emphasize had nothing to do with the organization.
asserted
she → make → organization
Keezer asked if they could ask Gioia about how the Church kept its current space clean.
uncertain
Church → ask → space
Oiler curiously protested that this was not about the Church (when in fact it was ostensibly about the Church and its janitorial readiness) but any organization, then adding the less than persuasive point that if fifteen people got the stomach bug at the same time, someone would have to clean it up.
asserted
someone → protest → it
{At trial, Oiler testified that she had in mind a specific incident that occurred at Hermon Middle School when one of her children was a student there.}
asserted
one → testify → children
Given the shortage of custodial staffing, she explained, she was concerned about the number of people who would be coming in and out of the building.
asserted
who → give → building
She suggested that the Committee investigate its current rental arrangements, to make sure those organizations were paying what they should considering the costs associated with hosting them.
uncertain
they → suggest → them
What this had to do with the Church's application remains a mystery….
asserted
had → do → application
The Free Speech Clause prohibits restrictions on access to limited or designated public fora that "discriminate against speech on the basis of viewpoint," including on the basis that the viewpoint in question is a religious one.
asserted
viewpoint → prohibit → question
…and 31 more, not listed.