It’s not clear whether Prime Minister Mark Carney’s airplane must-reads included Stephen Harper’s memoir ahead of his arrival Monday night in China for the APEC summit.
asserted
reads → ’ → summit
But Harper, who appointed Carney as a central bank governor, has sharp advice on dealing with Beijing that he may have shared with Carney in their frequent conversations, even if the prime minister hasn’t read it.
uncertain
minister → appoint → it
Harp warns in the autobiography released two weeks ago that while pragmatic engagement with China is worth pursuing, a fully bilateral free trade deal with China’s ruling Communist Party may never be possible.
uncertain
deal → warn → Party
Carney has also ruled that out.
asserted
Carney → rule → that
But Carney continues to seek closer trade ties to buffer Canada from the worst impacts of a U.S. tariff assault on major Canadian industries via more Chinese investment, particularly in the electric vehicle sector.
asserted
Carney → continue → sector
“I am a China skeptic,” Harper writes.
asserted
Harper → write → ?
“And my views have become considerably more pessimistic in recent years because of the governance of Xi Jinping.”
asserted
views → become → Jinping
Xi became China’s president after Harper was in office.
asserted
Harper → become → office
But the former Conservative prime minister says starting from his own early years in office, he believed China’s emergence as a long-term competitive threat was evident “for those with their eyes open,” as was Russia’s role as a “perpetual disrupter.”
asserted
role → say → disrupter
“The most important thing to understand is that China has not changed fundamentally under President Xi, as many ‘China experts’ today argue,” Harper writes.
asserted
Harper → understand → Xi
Their economic liberalization never had any purpose other than the strengthening of the Chinese Communist Party’s internal control and the outward projection of its power.”
asserted
liberalization → have → power
Harper, who now runs a global investment consulting firm and chairs the board of Alberta’s pension and sovereign wealth fund, says that “because China is less overtly destabilizing than Russia, Iran, North Korea or other global bad actors, many tend not to think of it in that category.
asserted
many → run → category
But Harper says China’s ruling party “can even be helpful if (and only if) its own interests are at stake, as in the global financial crisis.
asserted
interests → say → crisis
The warning comes as Carney makes his second trip in 11 months to China, this time to attend the summit of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation forum, a group of 21 countries that rim the Pacific Ocean.
asserted
that → come → Ocean
Carney will sit down on Tuesday morning with Xi, who is hosting the summit, for a one-on-one meeting expected to run about 25 minutes.
asserted
who → sit → minutes
It is not clear whether the prime minister will emerge with anything concrete to announce.
asserted
minister → emerge → anything
Many Canadian companies that operate in Asia, however, are hopeful relations will continue to thaw.
asserted
relations → operate → Asia
Vincent Joli-Coeur, chairman of the National Bank of Canada’s Asia Pacific section, said in an interview that even since Carney’s January visit to China, the business investment climate is better.
asserted
climate → say → China
“It’s a huge difference.
asserted
It → ’ → ?
It’s day and night,” he told the Star.
asserted
he → ’ → Star
“What’s the difference?
asserted
difference → ’ → ?
You know, just faster access.
asserted
You → know → ?
We used to be welcome, National Bank of Canada, in China with a red carpet.
asserted
We → use → carpet
But now a lot of Canadian companies … when we speak with them, they tell us it’s so different for the past 11 months.
asserted
it → speak → months
It started in January with that landmark trip.”
National Bank already operates in China , where it offers loans to institutional investors.
asserted
it → start → investors
Joli-Coeur said he is looking toward more business opportunities for Canadian companies across Southeast Asia as a result of Carney having concluded negotiations in Cambodia on free trade agreements with the ASEAN group and with the Philippines.
asserted
Carney → say → Philippines
Carney and has made improving relations with Beijing a foreign policy priority, while insisting that he will put “guardrails” around Chinese investment in areas that relate to Canada’s national security: artificial intelligence, defence and critical minerals.
asserted
that → make → security
But he is clearly open to greater Chinese investment and on this Asia tour, he set out his conditions for that if U.S. talks do not secure or fully utilize the current integrated North American auto production industry.
asserted
talks → set → industry
Carney told reporters in Cambodia that a lot depends on whether the U.S. is ready to protect and fully utilize the integrated auto market.
asserted
U.S. → tell → market
But if not, Carney is determined to seek other partners in Europe, Korea, and Japan, and welcomes more Chinese access to the Canadian auto market, conditional upon the use of critical minerals from Canada, labour standards for Canadian workers and the exclusion of knock-down or ready-to-assemble EV kits.
asserted
Carney → seek → kits
He said there must be a “strong value-add” in what is manufactured in Canada, not just the addition of final or finished components.
asserted
what → say → components
In January, Carney and Xi agreed to form a new “strategic partnership” and signed agreements to collaborate in energy and clean technology.
asserted
Carney → agree → energy
More specifically, they also agreed to reduce tariffs that had become major irritants.
asserted
that → agree → tariffs
Canada dropped its U.S.-matched 100 per cent tariffs on Chinese electric vehicles, and agreed to allow up to 49,000 Chinese EVs imports into Canada at a six per cent tariff rate this year.
asserted
Canada → drop → rate
In exchange, China reduced tariffs on Canadian seafood and canola and canola seed products, although pork tariffs remain.
asserted
tariffs → reduce → seafood
The deal was extended earlier this month for another two years.
asserted
deal → extend → years
Carney says China is part of his plan to double non-U.S. exports by the end of the decade, and in Beijing he talked about China and Canada being strong advocates of multilateralism.
asserted
China → say → multilateralism
Harper, however, sees things differently, noting that in the last renegotiation of the Canada-United States-Mexico Agreement on trade specified that any future agreement with a non-market economy such as China’s must first be run by the other CUSMA partners, which could then give notice on withdrawing from the free trade agreement.
uncertain
which → see → agreement
“Perhaps someday a comprehensive trade deal with China may make sense,” Harper said.
uncertain
Harper → make → sense
But for now, he said the Trump administration has made it virtually impossible for Canada to negotiate a trade deal with China without American approval.”
“While this can be decried as a restriction on Canadian sovereignty — which it is — it is also in our own interests,” Harper writes.
asserted
Harper → say → interests
…and 6 more, not listed.