Sen. John Hickenlooper, D-Colo., mimed a coin flip on Monday night when asked if he’ll support Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer over his insurgent opponent, Sen. Chris Van Hollen, D-Md.
It was a joke — but one that also showed how Democrats are wrestling with the decision.
asserted
Democrats → mime → decision
We flip nine seats and the person who actually helps put it together and do all that, all of a sudden there’s a revolt,” Hickenlooper said.
asserted
Hickenlooper → flip → that
He quickly made clear he didn’t mean that as a Schumer endorsement: “I haven’t picked a position.
asserted
I → make → position
I do think it’s useful to go and look at: How could the caucus be better?”
uncertain
caucus → think → ?
If the first few days of the leadership race are any indication, it’s going to be a very long two weeks for Senate Democrats.
asserted
it → go → Democrats
Several declined to comment on Monday night after days of celebrating their big election wins, with one senator saying Schumer’s challenge is all reporters are asking about.
asserted
reporters → decline → wins
But that’s because it’s such an unusual moment for the party: The vast majority of sitting Senate Democrats have never experienced a contested leadership race for the top job.
asserted
majority → ’ → job
And Van Hollen’s rebel campaign isn’t following crushing losses — but instead a historic victory.
asserted
campaign → follow → losses
“No one who was not on the ballot worked harder for this victory than Chuck Schumer.
asserted
who → work → Schumer
Chuck Schumer also happens to know Donald Trump better than anyone else in the caucus and dealing with this wounded president is going to be a challenge
asserted
dealing → happen → president
,” said Sen. Tim Kaine, D-Va.
asserted
Kaine → say → ?
“The voters are also demanding change.”
asserted
voters → demand → change
Kaine, who will chair the Budget Committee next year, also declined to publicly come out for or against Schumer.
asserted
who → chair → Schumer
Van Hollen’s pitch for change
Van Hollen is not exactly an obvious change agent: He previously chaired the party’s campaign arms in both the House and Senate and has been in elected office since 1991.
asserted
He → chair → 1991
But he is seeking to draw bright contrasts with Schumer, pushing for a prohibition in the next spending bill on offensive weapons for the Iran war and highlighting Schumer’s opposition to the Obama era Iran nuclear deal.
asserted
he → seek → deal
And while Schumer has several times the public support of Van Hollen, most of the incoming 56 Democratic Caucus members next year have declined to publicly endorse either one.
asserted
most → have → one
Van Hollen said he knows “for a fact” some public reporting about senators’ support for Schumer is not true: “Some are voting for me and others are undecided on that list.”
asserted
others → say → list
“People are still listening.
asserted
People → listen → ?
They’re very interested in having a debate,” Van Hollen said on Monday evening.
asserted
Hollen → ’re → evening
One of his supporters, Sen. Jeff Merkley, D-Ore., said he thinks the Maryland Democrat has a real chance to defeat Schumer.
asserted
Democrat → say → Schumer
Most Democrats still see Schumer as the heavy favorite given the election results, however.
asserted
Democrats → see → results
Still, a number of other longtime Democratic senators who know Schumer well are keeping their powder dry.
asserted
who → know → powder
Asked about the race, Sen. Ron Wyden, D-Ore., said only that he’s “laser-focused” on his agenda next year leading the Finance Committee and pushing Medicare for All, a billionaire’s income tax and repealing tariffs.
asserted
he → ask → tariffs
“Everybody deserves to be heard and then our caucus will make a decision,” said Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash., who will chair the Appropriations Committee.
asserted
who → deserve → Committee
“I have not declared anything,”
asserted
I → declare → anything
The next leader will decide when Murray or Wyden’s legislation will come to the Senate floor over the next two years — giving them incentive to stay neutral.
asserted
legislation → decide → incentive
And many Democrats are still digesting how to handle a secret ballot election that comes after the party’s most commanding win since Barack Obama became president.
asserted
Obama → digest → win
“Every candidate should make their pitch.
asserted
candidate → make → pitch
And I’ll hear out any candidate for leader,” said Sen. Jon Ossoff, D-Ga., who obliterated his opponent in his reelection bid.
asserted
who → hear → bid
“I’m grateful to everyone for their efforts, including Leader Schumer.”
asserted
I → ’m → Schumer
Schumer has served as Democratic leader for a decade, during which time the party’s activist base has soured on him; he’s also the architect of multiple Democratic majorities and made the most of a 50-seat Democratic majority during the first two years of Joe Biden’s presidency.
asserted
he → serve → presidency
But no leader hangs on forever: both former Democratic Leader Harry Reid and former Republican Leader Mitch McConnell lost a handful of votes in their last leadership races, before stepping down from the job.
asserted
Reid → hang → job
Schumer’s given no indication he would do that, but he’s up for reelection in 2028 and has a big decision ahead of him.
asserted
he → give → him
And Van Hollen knows it.
asserted
Hollen → know → it
“That’s a decision for him,” he said of Schumer’s 2028 plans.
asserted
he → ’ → plans
Some Democrats said it’s healthy to have this debate after more than three decades without a real contested battle for the leadership race.
asserted
it → say → race
“We’re not afraid to have a discussion because we’re Democrats,” Kaine said.
asserted
Kaine → ’re → discussion
“We like democracy.”
asserted
We → like → democracy
“It just comes with the territory,” said Sen. Martin Heinrich, D-N.M.
Burgess’s view
Van Hollen’s leadership challenge to Schumer has made things very awkward for Senate Democrats.
asserted
things → come → Democrats
The contest will supercharge the debate about the party’s agenda in 2027 as well as how they handle the lame duck.
asserted
they → supercharge → duck
…and 1 more, not listed.