President Donald Trump has repeatedly noted the economic boon from foreign citizens who attend American universities.
asserted
who → note → universities
Yet according to survey results published on Monday, foreign-student enrollment in the U.S. fell substantially this year, largely due to the uncertainty created by Trump's policies.
uncertain
enrollment → accord → policies
Based on a survey of more than 800 colleges and universities, the Institute of International Education reported that the number of new foreign students is down 15 percent from last year.
asserted
number → base → students
Total international enrollment, which fell by 3 percent last year, decreased by 9 percent this year, including drops of 3 percent for undergraduates, 15 percent for graduate students, and 6 percent for participants in optional practical training (OPT).
asserted
which → fall → training
That two-year decline is "likely historic," Ted Mitchell, president of the American Council on Education, told The New York Times.
asserted
Mitchell → tell → Times
And according to the survey, the most common explanations offered by institutions that saw reductions were the visa application process, U.S. travel restrictions, "feeling unwelcome in the United States," and limits on the duration of student status.
uncertain
that → accord → status
Foreign students see "too much uncertainty in the United States," NAFSA executive director Fanta Aw, whose organization represents international educators, told the Associated Press.
asserted
organization → see → Press
It is not hard to see why.
asserted
It → see → ?
Last year, Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) suddenly terminated thousands of records in the database of foreign students with visas authorizing them to attend American universities.
asserted
Immigration → terminate → universities
That move, which sowed panic among students across the country, was the result of the Trump administration's "Student Criminal Alien Initiative."
asserted
which → sow → Initiative
Contrary to the implication of that label, the initiative affected many people who had no criminal convictions that would justify revoking their visas.
asserted
that → affect → visas
Nor did ICE cite any other specific justification listed in the relevant regulations.
asserted
ICE → cite → regulations
Instead, the students were told their records had been terminated for "otherwise failing to maintain status."
asserted
records → tell → status
Although ICE subsequently restored the records, they still included notations of the prior terminations.
asserted
they → restore → terminations
Those black marks, along with the possibility that ICE might reverse course again at any time, left students uncertain about whether they would be allowed to remain in the United States and complete their degrees—a situation that prompted intervention by a federal judge.
uncertain
that → reverse → judge
Last July, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) finalized a rule imposing a new four-year limit on visas for students, who previously had been allowed to remain in the country until they completed their educational programs, including "authorized practical training following completion of studies."
asserted
they → finalize → studies
Under the new policy, students who hit the four-year limit, which is inadequate for many courses of study, would have to seek extensions from the DHS, which would have complete, unreviewable discretion to reject such requests.
asserted
which → hit → requests
In September, a federal judge deemed the rule change "arbitrary and capricious" under the Administrative Procedure Act because the DHS did not offer a plausible justification, consider alternatives, estimate predictable costs, or meaningfully respond to the points raised by commenters.
asserted
DHS → deem → commenters
U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV, a George W. Bush appointee, finalized that judgment on Monday, vacating the rule.
asserted
IV → finalize → rule
Since the Trump administration can ask a federal appeals court to review Saylor's decision, the ultimate fate of the time limit is unclear.
uncertain
fate → ask → limit
The same goes for the $70,000 OPT application fee that the DHS proposed last month.
asserted
DHS → go → that
All of this is hard to reconcile with what Trump has said about the benefits of hosting international students.
asserted
Trump → reconcile → students
"I want to have foreign students," he insisted last year.
asserted
he → want → students
The full tuition they pay is financially essential to "our school system," he explained.
asserted
he → pay → system
During his 2024 campaign, Trump agreed that "we need to recruit the best and brightest from the world."
asserted
we → agree → world
In fact, he said, you should "automatically" get a green card when "you graduate from a college."
asserted
you → say → college
He lamented that people who earned U.S. degrees and "desperately wanted to stay here" ended up returning to their home countries, where they started companies that employ "thousands and thousands of people."
asserted
that → lament → people
Trump says he welcomes foreign students.
asserted
he → say → students
His policies tell a different story.
asserted
policies → tell → story