Left-wing streamer Hasan Piker stumbled through an explanation of why he cared more about Muslim persecution in Israel than in China, the latter of which he openly praises and glamorizes.
asserted
he → stumble → which
In an interview on the Axios Show, Alex Thompson questioned Piker over his love of China, known for its heavy persecution of Uyghur Muslims, despite frequently decrying Israel for its own treatment of Muslims.
asserted
Thompson → question → Muslims
In a long answer, Piker struggled to square the contradiction.
asserted
Piker → struggle → contradiction
“Yeah, because Israel is murdering not just Muslims but Christians as well with my tax dollars, and that I think is unacceptable,” Piker said in response to Thompson.
asserted
Piker → murder → Thompson
“It’s the same principle behind America’s Global War on Terror, that is, an abject failure, that I oppose as well.
asserted
I → ’ → that
That many Americans also oppose, as a matter of fact.”
asserted
Americans → oppose → fact
When Thompson suggested he wouldn’t be talking about Israel if it weren’t a U.S. ally, he first agreed, then qualified his answer.
uncertain
he → suggest → answer
“Yeah, I would not be,” Piker said.
asserted
Piker → say → ?
Of course, I would still talk about it, because it’s a genocide, and …
asserted
it → talk → it
I believe Amnesty International considers what China has done to the Uyghur Muslims to be a cultural genocide, if I’m not mistaken.”
asserted
I → believe → Muslims
When asked if he agreed with the description, Piker said he did.
asserted
he → ask → description
He also said there were “different terms applied for different actions” and implied there were different tiers of genocide, with Israel committing an “outright genocide.”
asserted
Israel → say → genocide
The left-wing commentator tried to give a comparative example when Thompson pressed him on whether China was also committing a genocide, presenting the Russian invasion of Ukraine as bad, but not as bad as the war in Gaza.
asserted
China → try → Gaza
“Having said that, it’s a different standard between, and a different weight, in the immorality of these actions as opposed to what Israel is doing in Gaza … and also the 75 years of apartheid and occupation,” he said, after noting his disapproval of the war in Ukraine.
asserted
he → say → Ukraine
When Thompson suggested there was a different level of outrage when it came to Israeli violence compared to Chinese violence, Piker disagreed, saying there was a “sufficient amount of outrage” against China, “not just coming from myself, but also from American society broadly.”
uncertain
Piker → suggest → society
As Thompson pressed him further on the apparent contradiction, noting his heavy praise of China, Piker justified his favorable stance by citing China’s cumulative output, as opposed to his negative view of Israel’s output.
asserted
Piker → press → output
“I think that Israel’s totality, like its entire output, its entire existence, is still built on the principles of ethnic cleansing and never truly addressing the inhumanity of the acts that came even at the inception of the Nakba and continued onward with full-blown American support,” Piker said.
asserted
Piker → think → support
“If Israel existed as a nation with a binational commitment to the Palestinians, but every now and then there … was like back and forth struggle, I think the calculation would be far different, not only by myself but also by many others in American society and all around the world,” he said.
asserted
he → exist → world
Piker has based much of his commentary around his belief in the evil perpetrated by Israel, while simultaneously holding up the People’s Republic of China as a model state to emulate.
asserted
Piker → base → state
The Chinese Communist Party distinguished itself throughout the 20th century as one of the world’s most severe regimes, with a death count in the tens of millions through man-made famines and heavy-handed political persecution.
asserted
Party → distinguish → famines
It founded the modern People’s Republic of China in 1949 and committed its worst atrocities in the ensuing decades, a year after the exodus of Palestinians mentioned by Piker as integrally connected to the evildoings of Israel today.
asserted
It → found → Israel
The consensus among human rights organizations and scholars is that China’s behavior toward its Uyghur minority has met all the criteria for a genocide.
asserted
behavior → meet → genocide
It’s also known for its heavy-handed persecution of other ethnic and religious minorities, including Tibetans and Christians.
asserted
It → know → Tibetans
Piker has consistently held up China as a preferable model to the United States.
asserted
Piker → hold → States
The socialist streamer’s love for China includes overt praise for its dictatorial structure, which he claimed was more favorable to the working class than the decentralized, democratic structure of the U.S. and other Western countries.
asserted
he → include → U.S.
“China gets to make decisions at the top that are, one, beneficial for its own working class and, two, China can dramatically restructure their economy almost overnight if they choose to do so,” he said in an Oct. 22 video, appropriately titled, “TRUMPS VENEZUELA GAMBIT AND WHY CHINA IS JUST BETTER.”
asserted
CHINA → get → video
He went on, saying, “This is not something that the decentralized system of capitalism, the decentralized system of governance that Western liberal capitalist nations have.
asserted
nations → go → that
His admiration of the CCP culminated in a trip he took in November, filled with praise for the Beijing government and denigration of the U.S.
“I talk about China quite a bit, as far as, like, lessons to learn and what America could adopt and emulate, and seeing it in real time, I think, is a lot different,” Piker told the state media outlet China Global Television Network in an interview during his trip.
uncertain
Piker → culminate → trip
“This has been a dream come true for me.”
asserted
This → come → me
He streamed himself watching the ceremonial raising of the Chinese flag next to Chinese dictator Mao Zedong’s portrait at the Tiananmen Gate, where he noted his lack of love for the U.S.
“This is awesome,” he said, as the Washington Free Beacon reported.
asserted
Beacon → stream → U.S.
“Like, like, I just don’t, like, I, I’m not — I don’t have any sort of patriotism in my heart … for America.”
asserted
I → do → America
Piker’s Axios interview had plenty of other viral moments, including his declaration that the U.S. was worse than Al Qaeda, speaking hot on the heels of the 25th anniversary of the worst terrorist attack in U.S. history.
asserted
U.S. → have → history
The Aporia
