A DHS email raises new questions about the Trump administration's election plans
asserted
email → raise → plans
An internal Department of Homeland Security email raises new questions about the agency's efforts to hunt for non-U.S. citizens who may be on state voter rolls or have cast ballots in the past.
uncertain
who → raise → past
In the email — which was sent last year, but is newly acquired by NPR — DHS personnel shared a 78-page document listing counties and states that offer election materials and ballots in non-English languages.
asserted
that → send → languages
The list of jurisdictions was attached alongside a Department of Justice criminal checklist outlining requirements for prosecution of voter-related charges.
asserted
list → attach → charges
The email was released as part of a tranche of materials after the Democratic National Committee filed suit over a public records request, and was then shared with NPR.
asserted
Committee → release → NPR
Democrats fear that the Trump administration's efforts to root out noncitizen voters will entangle or intimidate eligible voters and dampen turnout in this year's midterms.
asserted
efforts → fear → midterms
DHS has surged resources to investigate noncitizen voting, even as prior audits have found such fraud to be extremely rare.
asserted
fraud → surge → voting
Nothing in the document alludes to enforcement activity at the locations mentioned.
asserted
Nothing → allude → locations
The email is heavily redacted, so it's unclear why the list of non-English jurisdictions was attached.
uncertain
list → redact → jurisdictions
A court filing by DHS defending its redactions described the email as a "subordinate sharing initial thoughts and opinions with leadership."
asserted
filing → defend → leadership
When asked by NPR about the document, DHS said in a statement that anyone who votes illegally shouldn't be able to "use a purported lack of knowledge" of English to avoid prosecution.
asserted
who → ask → prosecution
Fears about the Trump administration's election plans have led civil rights coalitions to sue to stop DHS from deploying federal officers to the polls, which administration officials have at times suggested could happen.
uncertain
officials → lead → times
Federal interference at the polls is against the law, but that concern is also what motivated the DNC to seek records from the Trump administration.
asserted
what → motivate → administration
Last year, it filed Freedom of Information Act requests across the federal government to learn if there were any plans to deploy federal agents or troops to polling places, drop boxes and election offices in the upcoming elections.
asserted
it → file → elections
The document worries Dan Freeman, the DNC's litigation director and a former DOJ Voting Section attorney, especially when combined with the fact that DHS deemed the email responsive to the FOIA request about potential federal agents at the polls.
asserted
email → worry → polls
"The very simple connection that I logically drew is that they're targeting [these jurisdictions]," said Freeman.
asserted
Freeman → draw → jurisdictions
"We are hoping to learn more.
asserted
We → hop → more
But right now, the logical inference that I think anyone would make is that they are thinking about prosecution of federal election crimes in jurisdictions where elections are conducted in a language other than English."
asserted
elections → think → English
DHS said in its statement that it "is not planning operations targeting polling locations."
But administration officials have also inflamed fears about the possibility.
asserted
officials → say → possibility
Earlier this month, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents could serve warrants at polling places, and in May, President Trump said he would do "anything necessary" to make sure the U.S. has "honest" elections, when he was asked directly about the possibility of agents at the polls.
uncertain
he → say → polls
It's unclear who compiled the list of multilingual voting jurisdictions, but it was shared as part of an email dated Dec. 19 from a DHS border policy acting director, whose name is redacted, to Rob Law, the undersecretary for strategy, policy and plans.
uncertain
name → compile → strategy
Other DHS officials from that office were included on the email, as well as Heather Honey, who is leading the administration's efforts to root out noncitizen voting.
asserted
who → include → voting
In areas where more than 5% of voting-age citizens primarily speak a language other than English, the Voting Rights Act requires election officials to provide materials in that language.
asserted
Act → vote → language
That information is public, and the document encompassed those jurisdictions as well as some state and local policies as well.
asserted
document → encompass → jurisdictions
Much of the tranche of materials released to the DNC is redacted.
asserted
Much → release → DNC
The DNC is still litigating to get more records from the federal government.
asserted
DNC → litigate → government
But it's clear the rhetoric around possible administration plans is already impacting voters too.
asserted
rhetoric → impact → voters
Roughly 40% of voters now think it's likely ICE agents will be present at voting locations in their area, according to new polling released this week from the University of California San Diego.
uncertain
agents → think → California
That includes roughly a third or more of Democrats, Republicans and independents.
asserted
That → include → Democrats
The survey also found voters of color were significantly more likely than white voters to say they feared voting could put them at risk of being questioned by immigration authorities despite being U.S. citizens.
uncertain
voting → find → authorities
Voting officials worry that could impact turnout even if no enforcement efforts materialize.
uncertain
efforts → worry → turnout
"What they're trying to do is put it out there to discourage people from voting, to create an atmosphere of fear, and it creates a chilling effect on the democratic process," said Paul López, the top voting official in Denver and a plaintiff in a lawsuit looking to prevent federal agents from the polls.
asserted
López → try → polls
Denver is one of many jurisdictions also mentioned in the DHS document as a place that offers multilingual election materials.
asserted
that → mention → materials
Close to a third of the city's population is Hispanic or Latino, according to census data.
uncertain
third → accord → data
But when López was told by NPR about the document's existence and Denver's inclusion in it, he said he wasn't concerned, because federal law is on his side.
asserted
law → tell → side
"It is illegal for folks to be targeted on the basis of their language," López said.
asserted
López → target → language
"My message to voters is, 'Don't let these thugs scare you.
asserted
thugs → let → you
Don't let them intimidate you.
asserted
them → let → you
You're not going to be bullied and we're not going to be intimidated.'
asserted
we → go → ?
"Democracy will happen."
asserted
Democracy → happen → ?
The Aporia
