Support for Prime Minister Mark Carney’s plan to “privatize” operations at Vancouver’s, Calgary’s, Toronto’s and Montreal’s international airports, and the lack of support for it, is dividing along interesting lines.
asserted
Support → privatize → lines
David Eby, the NDP premier of British Columbia, says he’s willing to support privatizing Vancouver airport so long as the revenues are invested in improving smaller airports in the province.
asserted
revenues → say → province
That’s more or less Quebec Premier Christine Fréchette’s position as well.
asserted
That → ’ → ?
Meanwhile, Ontario NDP Leader Marit Stiles is dead-set against privatizing Toronto Pearson Airport, and federal NDP leader Avi Lewis is dead-set against the entire idea on principle, with both guaranteeing all manner of disaster for passengers.
asserted
both → set → passengers
Ontario Premier Doug Ford is over the moon about the idea, though he seems most excited about the prospect of expanding Toronto’s Island Airport — an idea thwarted, at least for now, by the Carney Liberals.
asserted
he → seem → Liberals
Carney is “on fire,” Ford declared this week on the PM’s policy cavalcade …
asserted
Ford → declare → cavalcade
on the same day the premier endorsed legendary Island Airport-hating Toronto mayor Olivia Chow for re-election.
asserted
premier → endorse → election
(His office later insisted he hadn’t endorsed her.
asserted
he → insist → her
You can listen and decide for yourself.)
In substance, federal Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre’s position isn’t as different as you might expect from Lewis’s and Stiles’, considering he’s the fellow who gave the annual Margaret Thatcher Lecture in London earlier this year.
uncertain
who → listen → London
“Canadians are already cash-strapped and broke.
asserted
Canadians → strap → ?
We want to make sure that it doesn’t end up being sweetheart deals for corporate power brokers and Liberal insiders at the expense of hard-working Canadians,” he avers.
asserted
he → want → Canadians
“We want to see how it’s going to save money for Canadians, because if it doesn’t save money, then why do it?”
asserted
it → want → it
It’s a wise message politically, considering the country’s populist mood … but then, the Canadian public seems to be willing to follow Carney and his policy team just about anywhere these days.
asserted
public → ’ → Carney
Some of us do pine for some old-fashioned ideology, though.
asserted
Some → pine → ideology
“State control is fundamentally bad because it denies people the power to choose and the opportunity to bear responsibility for their own actions,” Thatcher wrote in a 2006 piece for the libertarian Reason Foundation.
asserted
Thatcher → deny → Foundation
“Conversely, privatization shrinks the power of the state and free enterprise enlarges the power of the people.”
asserted
enterprise → shrink → people
Could this plan wind up enriching “Liberal insiders”?
uncertain
plan → wind → insiders
But surely privatizing airport operations — as opposed to selling off the assets, which is not on the table — is less an invitation to political meddling than having governments or their arm’s-length “not-for-profit” agencies in charge.
asserted
which → privatize → charge
This debate is a classic Canadian confusion between form and function, combined with our crippling suspicion of change — pretty much any change.
asserted
debate → combine → change
We mustn’t have “privatized” health care … even though we already do, in many respects, and no one really proposes nationalizing pharmacists or blood labs.
asserted
one → privatize → pharmacists
During the worst days at long-term care homes during the pandemic, the Ontario media fixated on the fact publicly owned facilities seemed to be faring better as a group than privately owned ones.
asserted
facilities → fixate → ones
But the vast majority of long-term care homes in Quebec are publicly owned, and they produced similar horrors.
asserted
they → own → horrors
Several reasonable commentators have suggested it was a misstep for Carney to mention all this right now.
uncertain
Carney → suggest → this
It strikes me more like the perfect time.
asserted
It → strike → time
Toronto Star columnist Adam Radwanski wondered why the PM would drop such a “contentious type of investment into the mix” at an otherwise-successful investment summit.
asserted
PM → wonder → summit
But surely the whole point of the summit was to attract investment, including foreign investment from (as Radwanski put it) “all the visiting wealth … from Middle Eastern sovereign funds to American private-equity giants.
asserted
Radwanski → attract → giants
Why would we be concerned about “sovereignty” in one industry and not others?
asserted
we → concern → industry
Say what you will about Middle Eastern sovereign funds, they’ve invested in some pretty decent airports — as have Canadian pension plans, in other countries — notably London’s Heathrow.
asserted
plans → say → countries
There are terrible airports in Canada under current management (Montreal) and pretty decent ones (Vancouver, which placed 10th in Skytrax’s most recent World Airport awards, higher than any other North American entrant).
asserted
which → be → entrant
And we’re not even talking about ownership, just management.
asserted
we → talk → ownership
The most frustrating thing is imagining this all coming to naught, for whatever reason, and Canadians just going back to hating the status quo at our biggest airports — Toronto and Montreal, anyway — but never demanding better.
asserted
Canadians → imagine → better
It’s one of our natural afflictions.
asserted
It → ’ → afflictions
The Aporia
