Melanie and David Moor spent more than $500,000 on what they expected to be their retirement home in Camperdown, south-west Victoria, only to discover that the house had been placed entirely on a neighbouring block.
asserted
house → spend → block
The couple had bought land in a new subdivision in 2021 and, after obtaining permits, installed a driveway and relocated a four-bedroom house onto the 2-hectare property they believed they owned.
asserted
they → buy → property
Instead, the house had been moved onto the adjacent block, which belonged to someone else.
asserted
which → move → someone
The mistake was discovered in August 2024, while the Moors were completing work on the house, after a council officer told David Moor to stop construction and seek legal advice.
asserted
officer → discover → advice
The couple then spent almost two years trying to resolve the dispute, including an unsuccessful proposal to swap the two properties.
asserted
couple → spend → properties
In April 2026, the house was finally moved about 100 metres onto the block the Moors actually owned.
asserted
Moors → move → block
The confusion began when the land was still an undivided paddock
The Moors first viewed the subdivision in August 2021, when the land was still part of a larger 8-hectare paddock that had not yet been divided into individual lots.
asserted
that → begin → lots
They paid a $5,000 deposit and signed the contract of sale in April 2022.
asserted
They → pay → April
Melanie Moor told ABC that the couple believed they had identified the correct block after a real estate agent showed them the property, while numbers on nearby fence posts also contributed to their understanding of which lot they had purchased.
asserted
they → tell → lot
The real estate agency later said an internal investigation found that its agent had not made false or misleading claims.
uncertain
agent → say → claims
A spokesperson said the agent had shown the couple the property well before the contract was signed and while it was still part of the larger paddock, adding that it was ultimately the buyers' responsibility to confirm which block they owned.
asserted
they → say → block
The confusion continued after the purchase.
asserted
confusion → continue → purchase
In 2023, before settlement, the Moors had a driveway constructed on the block they believed was theirs, with permission from the former owner of the neighbouring property.
asserted
they → have → property
When the house was later relocated, the builder and other tradespeople used that driveway as a reference point for identifying the lot.
asserted
builder → relocate → lot
ABC reported that the relocation company's job document listed the road name but not a specific lot number.
asserted
document → report → name
Council inspections did not catch the mistake
The Moors obtained a building permit from Corangamite Shire Council in April 2024.
asserted
Moors → catch → April
However, documents supporting the permit included an aerial photograph showing that soil samples had been taken from the wrong block.
asserted
samples → support → block
Council records also showed that staff visited the site three times in one month to inspect stump holes dug for the house relocation.
asserted
staff → show → relocation
The mistake was finally identified in August 2024, while the Moors were putting the finishing touches on the house.
asserted
Moors → identify → house
A council officer contacted David Moor, instructed him to stop work and advised him to seek legal advice.
asserted
officer → contact → advice
Melanie said the couple initially thought the call was a scam before realising that their new home was sitting entirely on land they did not own.
asserted
they → say → land
The actual owner of that block lived interstate and had purchased the property from their late uncle.
asserted
owner → live → uncle
According to the owner's lawyers, the owner had been unaware that the Moors had moved a house onto the land until after the work had taken place.
uncertain
work → accord → place
A proposed land swap failed over differences between the blocks
asserted
swap → propose → blocks
Once the mistake was discovered, the Moors proposed swapping the block where their house had been placed with the neighbouring block they actually owned.
asserted
they → discover → block
The proposal was rejected by the other landowner's lawyers, who said the properties were not equivalent.
asserted
properties → reject → lawyers
They pointed to differences in the views from each block, a registered easement on the Moors' property and possible tax consequences from a land swap.
asserted
They → point → swap
The dispute eventually became a legal matter.
asserted
dispute → become → ?
In July 2025, the landowner's lawyers gave the Moors 14 days to remove the house and restore the property to its original condition, warning that the house could otherwise be sold.
uncertain
house → give → condition
At the time, the Moors said they could not afford to move it.
uncertain
they → say → it
The contractor who had originally relocated the house also advised that it might not survive another move.
uncertain
it → relocate → move
The situation was particularly difficult because Victoria's property laws do not give courts the same range of options available in some other Australian jurisdictions for cases in which someone mistakenly builds on another person's land.
asserted
someone → give → land
An ABC report examining the issue noted that such cases are sometimes referred to as the "mistaken improver" problem.
asserted
cases → examine → problem
The house was moved 100 metres onto the correct block
asserted
house → move → block
After months of negotiations, the parties reached an agreement in February 2026 for the Moors to clear the disputed property by May 2.
uncertain
Moors → reach → May
The couple eventually found another house mover who was willing to take on the job after their original contractor had warned against a second relocation.
asserted
contractor → find → relocation
Just before Easter, the four-bedroom house was lifted and transported about 100 metres sideways onto the Moors' actual property.
asserted
house → lift → property
The couple described seeing the house transferred onto their own land as a major relief after the prolonged dispute.
asserted
house → describe → dispute
The move has not yet made the house habitable.
asserted
house → make → ?
The building is temporarily sitting on empty oil drums while it waits to be restumped.
asserted
it → sit → drums
…and 7 more, not listed.
The Aporia
