Princess Diana's brother, Earl Charles Spencer, fired back at Buckingham Palace after the royal household questioned his recollection of a conversation with King Charles III, saying he was being "gaslit" by the monarch.
asserted
he → fire → monarch
Earlier this week, The Daily Mail published an excerpt of Spencer's upcoming memoir, "Swan Song: Diana, My Sister," in which the king's former brother-in-law described having a heated conversation with Charles after Diana's death.
asserted
Mail → publish → death
In the excerpt, Spencer alleged that Charles said, "We’ll forget her soon enough!" regarding his ex-wife during their exchange.
asserted
We → allege → exchange
Buckingham Palace later responded to Spencer's claims, disputing the earl's account of the conversation and suggesting that grief may have affected his memory of events surrounding his sister's death.
uncertain
grief → respond → death
During an interview with The Mail on Sunday, Spencer took issue with the palace's response.
asserted
Spencer → take → response
"It is not every day you wake up to find you've been gaslit by the king," he said.
asserted
he → wake → king
"It was astonishingly provocative and below the belt because it was essentially trying to say I'd lied without the King being able to deny what I'd said."
asserted
I → try → what
"I also thought it was a rather poor imitation of the ‘recollections may vary’ quote, which was a much more elegant way of putting things, but in these circumstances entirely out of place," he added.
uncertain
he → think → place
The remark referenced the palace's famous "recollections may vary" statement issued after Prince Harry and Meghan Markle's explosive 2021 interview with Oprah Winfrey.
uncertain
recollections → reference → Winfrey
In the excerpt, published Wednesday, Spencer described a phone call he said he had with Charles six days after Diana died in August 1997.
asserted
Diana → publish → August
"Prince Charles continued his stream of anger, without me interrupting.
asserted
me → continue → anger
Then he stopped.
asserted
he → stop → ?
I assumed the pause signaled an effort to bring himself under control, but then he unleashed down the phone what I have always taken to be his pent-up contempt for Diana, and his horror that the world was so bowled over by her death,"
asserted
world → assume → death
Spencer alleged.
asserted
Spencer → allege → ?
"‘Rest assured,’ he hissed, ‘we’ll forget her soon enough!’
asserted
we → rest → her
According to the excerpt, the king and the 9th Earl of Spencer disagreed over the decision to have Prince William and Harry, then 15 and 12, walk behind their mother's casket during the funeral procession.
uncertain
William → accord → procession
A Buckingham Palace spokesperson issued a rare statement responding to Spencer's claims.
uncertain
spokesperson → issue → claims
"While we do not comment on books as a matter of principle, His Majesty is mindful that the pain of fraternal grief can cloud reason, affect judgment and color memory in ways others do not recognize, even many years after such a loss," the statement said, according to People.
uncertain
statement → comment → People
Spencer stood by his account of the alleged conversation during an appearance on BBC One's "Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg."
When Kuenssberg pointed out that Buckingham Palace had denied his version of events, Spencer pushed back, saying, "But they haven't actually, Laura.
asserted
Spencer → stand → events
They've sort of smudged that one, haven't they?"
asserted
they → smudge → one
Kuenssberg then read the palace's statement to Spencer, telling him that "the king is plainly furious."
"Well, is he furious?
asserted
he → read → him
Is he furious or is he embarrassed?" Spencer asked.
asserted
Spencer → ask → ?
"Because I can tell you here and now, those are exactly the words he said."
asserted
he → tell → you
Spencer said he remembered the conversation clearly because he had spoken so infrequently with Charles, who was then Prince of Wales.
asserted
who → say → Wales
"I've only ever had two calls on the line with Prince Charles at any stage of my life," Spencer said.
asserted
Spencer → have → life
"I was hyper alert to what he was saying and those are precisely the words that he said."
asserted
he → say → that
Spencer said he repeated the alleged comment to close friends and family members immediately afterward "because it was so monstrous."
"Which, Charles, are the public meant to believe?" Kuenssberg asked.
asserted
Kuenssberg → say → Which
"Are they to believe you or are they to believe the king, the head of state of this country who's giving the impression very forcefully that this didn't happen?
asserted
this → believe → impression
Who are we to believe?"
asserted
we → believe → ?
"Well, I'm telling the truth," Spencer replied.
asserted
Spencer → tell → truth
"So, the king is giving an impression to the country that's not true.
asserted
that → give → country
Misleading people, even lying?" Kuenssberg asked.
asserted
Kuenssberg → mislead → people
"I can hardly be responsible for what Buckingham Palace says," Spencer replied.
asserted
Spencer → say → what
"All I can tell you is what was said and what I heard and what shocked me.
asserted
what → tell → me
What else would have made me hang up on the king that day?
asserted
me → make → king
It was something as outrageous as that slur against Diana."
When asked whether William and Harry would be upset by his account of the alleged phone call with their father, Spencer suggested his nephews were already familiar with his version of events.
uncertain
nephews → ask → events
"Well, I don't like to talk about what I've been speaking about to William and Harry, but this will not be a surprise to them," he said.
asserted
he → like → them
"I will tell you that these words will not be a surprise to them."
asserted
words → tell → them
A Buckingham Palace spokesperson told Fox News Digital, "We won’t be offering any comment."
asserted
We → tell → comment
Diana died at age 36 after suffering injuries sustained in a car accident in the Pont de l'Alma tunnel in Paris, France.
asserted
Diana → die → Paris
…and 12 more, not listed.
The Aporia
