It is almost easy to forget now, but before taking power in 2018, the Coalition Avenir Québec was a party that wanted to reform Quebec.
asserted
that → forget → Quebec
François Legault campaigned on the very real frustration of taxpayers who were paying a lot without always feeling they were getting their money’s worth.
asserted
they → campaign → worth
The CAQ talked about the cleanup that was needed in the Quebec model, the need to cut bureaucracy and the importance of giving families and taxpayers more room to breathe.
asserted
that → talk → room
The CAQ was a party that wanted to challenge the status quo.
asserted
that → want → quo
This was a characteristic it had partly inherited from its predecessor, the Action Démocratique du Québec.
asserted
it → inherit → predecessor
Although the CAQ often touted itself as a more sophisticated evolution of the ADQ, notably by bringing together former members of the Parti Québécois, the Liberals, and the ADQ around a vision that sought to move beyond the old debate between federalism and sovereignty.
asserted
that → tout → federalism
But the reformist spirit remained at the heart of its political identity.
asserted
spirit → remain → identity
Of course, governing creates dissatisfaction.
asserted
governing → govern → dissatisfaction
That’s the reality for any party that has governed for eight years, especially with a majority government.
asserted
that → ’ → government
The CAQ also quickly lost some of the voters who had supported it precisely because it represented a break from the traditional parties.
asserted
it → lose → parties
What is more striking is seeing just how much the party’s priorities have shifted since then.
asserted
priorities → see → ?
The CAQ is no longer speaking to the same electorate.
asserted
CAQ → speak → electorate
In 2018, it spoke to families and taxpayers who wondered whether they were getting enough in return for what they paid to the government.
asserted
they → speak → government
Today, it speaks more to an electorate seeking reassurance in the face of major economic and geopolitical turmoils and wanting to protect the services and benefits they already enjoy.
asserted
they → speak → services
It is reflected in the evolution of the CAQ’s political priorities.
asserted
It → reflect → priorities
In 2018, it campaigned on the idea that Quebec spent a lot but rarely got results that matched the level of spending.
asserted
that → campaign → spending
Today, the CAQ’s message revolves around economic uncertainty, creating stability and “preserving our capacity to act.”
asserted
message → revolve → capacity
Leader Christine Fréchette’s campaign has proposed deregulation measures and greater use of the private sector in health care.
asserted
campaign → propose → care
But what was once at the centre of the party’s message now feels much more peripheral.
asserted
was → feel → message
Fréchette and the CAQ’s strategy of making a clean break with the Legault legacy has generated a lot of discussion since the beginning of the campaign.
asserted
Fréchette → make → campaign
It’s understandable to want to rejuvenate a party with an unpopular track record.
asserted
It → ’ → record
But beyond the leadership change and the prominence given to Fréchette in all the party’s communications, there’s a legitimate question worth asking: in its eagerness to make people forget the past, does the CAQ still remember what drove its political agenda before it took power?
asserted
it → give → power
The first leaders’ debate, held last Tuesday on TVA, was particularly revealing in this regard.
asserted
debate → hold → regard
When asked about the need to reform the Quebec model so that taxpayers get more for their money, Fréchette avoided the question and took the opportunity to praise infrastructure investments to build new schools made by her government…
asserted
Fréchette → ask → government
On Sunday, she accused PQ Leader Paul St-Pierre Plamondon of taking a “much more conservative” turn, pointing in particular to his proposals to encourage higher birth rates and shrink the size of government.
asserted
she → accuse → government
She even went out of her way to say that the PQ’s new family policy was, in her view, “not progressive.”
asserted
policy → go → view
There is something striking about that for anyone who remembers the CAQ before it came to power.
asserted
it → be → power
Encouraging families to have more children, reducing the size of government, questioning the growth of the public service: none of these ideas are exactly foreign to the CAQ’s history.
asserted
none → encourage → history
A few years ago, many of those themes would have fit naturally into a conversation among CAQ members or MNAs in a convention.
asserted
many → fit → convention
But today, they are being used to define what the party wants to distance itself from.
asserted
party → use → itself
The CAQ will face an important challenge after the Oct. 5 vote.
asserted
CAQ → face → vote
A change in leadership may make it possible to turn the page on an unpopular track record, but it cannot, on its own, give a party a new purpose.
uncertain
it → make → purpose
For a long time, the CAQ’s purpose was fairly easy to understand.
asserted
purpose → understand → time
It wanted to give families more choices, taxpayers more money, and offer nationalists an option that didn’t involve another referendum.
asserted
that → want → referendum
Eight years later, the CAQ now defends many of the institutions and practices it once sought to shake up.
asserted
it → defend → institutions
Perhaps this is simply what happens to a party after eight years in power.
asserted
what → happen → power
But if Christine Fréchette truly wants to turn a new page, she will eventually have to answer a question more fundamental than what to do with François Legault’s record.
asserted
she → want → record
If Legault’s legacy is to be erased and centre-right ideas are no longer embraced, how does the CAQ intend to define itself going forward?
asserted
CAQ → erase → itself
The Aporia
