- See more Daily Mail on Google - save us as a Preferred Source
She spent three years and £50,000 fighting her local council for the right to walk through her own back gate.
asserted
She → see → gate
But after winning a legal battle against Derbyshire County Council over access to her home, Helene Ball, 81, now has a fresh fight on her hands after giant concrete 'Lego' blocks were dumped outside her property.
asserted
blocks → win → property
Mrs Ball, a retired teacher, accused the council of pettiness after it put the 2ft blocks along a narrow wall near her home following her legal victory.
asserted
it → accuse → victory
Mrs Ball first took action against the council after discovering one morning in April 2023 that a metal fence had been cemented over a 98cm gap in her rear garden wall.
asserted
fence → take → wall
The gap leads into an adjoining council-owned car park, but Mrs Ball, who has lived at the house in Matlock since 1967, said she and her family had used the route unopposed for more than 40 years.
asserted
she → lead → years
Mrs Ball argued that her continued access amounted to prescriptive rights to access the route and a judge later ruled in her favour – with the access now being added to the deed for the land.
asserted
access → argue → land
The council was also ordered by the courts to pay Mrs Ball's costs of around £50,000 and to ensure her pedestrian and vehicular access is not impeded again.
asserted
access → order → 50,000
But Mrs Ball was shocked to then discover 54 huge 'Lego-style' blocks placed outside her home.
asserted
Ball → discover → home
The 2ft-high bricks line the narrow road behind her property and the grass verge alongside her garden wall.
asserted
bricks → line → wall
Helene Ball, who won a £50,000 battle with council chiefs over access to her home is facing a fresh fight after giant "Lego" blocks were dumped outside
The concrete 'Lego' bricks lining the street outside Mrs Ball's home in Matlock, Derbyshire
Derbyshire County Council admitted it had been 'unreasonable' to erect the original green fence at the centre of the dispute.
Mrs Ball, who has two grown-up children and four grandchildren, said: 'It's just so petty of the council to do this after they lost the case but they have been spiteful from the start.
'
asserted
they → win → start
The judge said I had a right of access by foot and by car to the rear of my house.
asserted
I → say → house
'However, the council have made it impossible to drive a car up the road and turn round, it's ridiculous.'
asserted
it → make → road
Mrs Ball and her late husband Brian moved into their home nearly 60 years ago and brought up their two sons there.
asserted
Ball → move → sons
The fence panel was installed two weeks after the second anniversary of the death of Mr Ball, and was viewed as a 'completely unnecessary act of aggression' by the family.
asserted
panel → instal → family
The gap led to a car park which residents were allowed to use at weekends.
asserted
residents → lead → weekends
But it closed three years ago while the council tried to sell the land for houses.
The court ruling from Judge Robert Brown said legal representation from the council was 'surprisingly combative' given its 'limited evidence' and 'unsubstantiated assertions'.
asserted
representation → close → evidence
Judge Brown found parts of the legal representation for the council 'totally irrelevant', 'most unhelpful' and even described the litigation as 'pugnacious'.
asserted
parts → find → litigation
Despite winning her case, Mrs Ball is now preparing for another legal battle in a bid to force the council to remove the blocks.
asserted
Ball → win → blocks
Her son David, 50, who has been carrying out legal work on behalf of his mother, said: 'The council have not acted in the spirit of the law.
'Our legal team are investigating whether the council are interfering with access to my mum's home.
asserted
council → carry → home
'Basically my mum won her case but the council have made it impossible for her to use the access road which she has used since she moved in in the 1960s.
asserted
she → win → 1960s
The fence which started the three-year legal dispute about access
The 2ft-high bricks line the narrow road behind her property and the grass verge alongside her garden wall.
asserted
bricks → start → wall
Derbyshire County Council admitted it had been 'unreasonable' to erect the original green fence at the centre of the dispute.
asserted
it → admit → dispute
A spokesman said: 'It would not be appropriate to comment further on matters that have been considered by the court other than that the council has a duty to safeguard its legal interests in public assets, including land that it owns and manages on behalf of residents.
asserted
it → say → residents
'Where issues arise concerning council-owned land or access rights, the council has a responsibility to consider the matter carefully and, where appropriate, defend any action.
asserted
council → arise → action
'Its actions are always guided by its statutory duties.
asserted
actions → guide → duties
The installation of the fence and legal challenge started under the previous Conservative-controlled administration, but the continuation and final tribunal court hearing took place under Reform UK control.
asserted
continuation → start → control
The Aporia
