- See more Daily Mail on Google - save us as a Preferred Source
Helene Ball had been out shopping with a friend when she returned to find her local council had erected a green metal fence outside her home, completely blocking the rear access to her garden.
asserted
council → see → garden
I was angry at first then I just laughed,' she said.
asserted
she → laugh → ?
'You have to laugh about it otherwise you'll cry.'
asserted
you → have → it
Mrs Ball is speaking this week from her immaculate semi overlooking the picturesque town of Matlock in the Derbyshire Dales after she won a three-year, £50,000 David and Goliath fight with Derbyshire County Council over the 3ft 3in gateway.
asserted
she → speak → gateway
She is making a Victoria Sponge cake but is 'worn out' she admits.
asserted
she → make → cake
For despite her good humour, the extraordinary battle has taken its toll on the 81-year-old retired teacher and her family.
asserted
battle → take → teacher
And it is still not over – for last week, in what Mrs Ball described as a final act of vindictiveness, the council dumped giant concrete blocks outside her home – ostensibly to reinstate Mrs Ball's access after her resounding legal victory.
asserted
council → describe → victory
But the 54, 2ft blocks – which resemble huge Lego pieces and cost the council £7,700 it emerged yesterday – have only added to Mrs Ball's distress.
asserted
it → resemble → distress
'It's stolen my summer, I haven't been able to enjoy my garden,' she said.
asserted
she → steal → garden
'I just hope I live long enough to get another one next year that I can enjoy.'
asserted
I → hope → that
Helene Ball, 81, now has a fresh fight on her hands after giant concrete 'Lego' blocks were dumped outside her property in Matlock, Derbyshire
Mrs Ball, 81, pictured in her garden in front of the 3ft gateway at the centre of the legal fight
An aerial vies of the huge blocks - which resemble large Lego blocks - outside her home
Derbyshire County Council said the blocks were were installed to 'enable vehicular access to Mrs Ball while preventing fly-tipping and racing and other antisocial activities elsewhere on the site'.
asserted
blocks → have → site
The fence which started the three-year legal dispute
The sorry saga dates back to April 2023 when the gate appeared – by which time Mrs Ball had been living at the property – and using the gate – for almost 60 years.
asserted
Ball → start → years
She and her late husband Brian, who she met while at teacher training college in Matlock, bought the house shortly after it was built in 1967 and raised their two children, David and Frances there.
asserted
it → meet → children
At the bottom of their garden was a concrete wall where a small gap had been left for a gate, which Mr Ball later fitted.
asserted
Ball → leave → which
The green metal fence appeared a month before the second anniversary of his death – at a time of great distress for Mrs Ball.
asserted
fence → appear → Ball
'I had been shopping in town.
asserted
I → shop → town
My neighbour said 'do you know the council have concreted a fence in front of your gate?'
asserted
council → say → gate
I came out and there it was.
asserted
it → come → ?
By then the concrete had set solid.'
The gateway leads to a council-owned car park.
asserted
gateway → set → park
Originally belonging to the local teacher's training college – where Mrs Ball studied – it was later given over to the county council and used for parking for its staff before the authority decided to put it up for sale for housing to bring in much needed capital funds.
asserted
authority → belong → funds
It seems to have been this decision to sell which prompted the council to block Mrs Ball's access as a short time later the car park was fenced off and the metal gate erected.
asserted
gate → seem → access
'They don't want anyone parking because they want to sell it with vacant possession,' Mrs Ball said.
asserted
Ball → want → possession
'I just came home and there it was.
asserted
it → come → ?
They only came to see me afterwards when they tried to fool me to into losing my rights.'
asserted
they → come → rights
She is referring to a visit from the council in which they asked her to sign a temporary licence to use the gate.
asserted
they → refer → gate
It would have meant she would have lost her right to claim prescriptive easement - the legal right to use another person's land, which can be acquired by proving continuous use over at least 20 years.
uncertain
which → mean → years
Thankfully she didn't and instead sought legal advice while David, a landscape gardener, started his own research and they applied for the access to be added to the land registry.
asserted
access → do → registry
The case finally went before a first tier tribunal judge in May.
uncertain
case → go → May
Mrs Ball was questioned during an online hearing, while her son David gave evidence for more two hours.
asserted
Ball → question → hours
They argued that her continued access amounted to prescriptive rights to access and, finally in August, the land judge ruled in her favour.
asserted
judge → argue → favour
The access will now be added to the deed for the land while the council was also ordered to pay her costs of around £50,000 as well as ensure her pedestrian and vehicular access is not impeded.
asserted
access → add → 50,000
It came after Mrs Ball was able to demonstrate she and her family used the gate to access the car park on foot and by car since 1967.
asserted
she → come → 1967
For while the couple had a driveway and a garage at the front of their house, their home is at the end of a steep, narrow S-shaped cul de sac and access to the rear was easier.
asserted
access → have → rear
They were able to prove – through pictures and oral testimony – that from approximately 1967 onwards, she, her husband, their children and visitors to their house all used the car park for pedestrian and vehicular access.
asserted
she → prove → access
Mrs Ball told how her husband, a forklift truck driver at a local quarry, would walk through the car park to the town centre, where he would be picked up by a colleague, until he retired in 1997.
asserted
he → tell → 1997
Mr Ball would also leave the house via the car park when he would walk down to the River Derwent to go fishing.
asserted
he → leave → fishing
Until she retired in 1973, Mrs Ball, who worked at Alfreton Junior School, would walk through the rear gate, down the car park and into town where she too would be picked up by a colleague.
asserted
she → retire → colleague
Pictures show her children playing in the snow on the land and learning to ride bikes there while Mr Bell had fitted a tyre swing to one of the trees for them.
asserted
Bell → show → them
David Bell would be picked up and dropped off by car at the rear gate following rugby practice and nights out.
asserted
Bell → pick → practice
For their part the council, who hired lawyers to fight the case, accused Mrs Ball and her son of demonstrating a 'degree of entitlement', because they believed the access was of 'benefit to the property', accusing them of embellishing their evidence.
asserted
access → hire → evidence
…and 20 more, not listed.
The Aporia
