The most commonly uttered words in football this week related to Lachie Neale, which is quite a feat given Hawthorn, abuse and umpires would top any Google News search.
asserted
abuse → utter → search
The first was the refrain: “You shouldn’t miss a grand final for that.”
asserted
You → miss → that
But it also commonly included a rejoinder: “Players have got a week for that all year.
asserted
Players → include → that
He has to go.”
asserted
He → have → ?
The third was pithier: “He’s lucky they took the good bloke defence out of compelling and exceptional circumstances.
asserted
they → ’ → circumstances
Few people would have been more invested in the Neale tribunal decision than Greg Swann.
asserted
people → invest → Swann
It was Swann who started last season as the Brisbane CEO and ended it as the AFL football boss who personally drove a rule change to elevate minor gut punches to a level demanding a one-week suspension, rather than a fine.
asserted
who → start → suspension
“I don’t see why that isn’t a penalty, to be honest.
asserted
that → see → ?
I think if you do penalise it, it’ll stop.
asserted
it → think → it
The fines aren’t doing it,” Swann told Fox Footy in July last year when he started in the job, adding the level of force would be less consequential in these punches.
asserted
level → do → punches
And so this year, gut punches have carried a one game suspension.
asserted
punches → carry → suspension
The AFL has never discriminated between being suspended for a grand final and missing round 13 in the rain in Canberra.
asserted
AFL → discriminate → Canberra
There is a logic behind why they don’t differentiate, but everyone else does.
asserted
everyone → be → ?
And in fact in other ways the AFL does differentiate between games.
asserted
AFL → differentiate → games
Offences committed in the grand final draw a heftier penalty than those committed any other week.
asserted
Offences → commit → those
So the league acknowledges the principle that grand finals are different.
asserted
finals → acknowledge → principle
In this instance, they did so because they were sick of their showcase game being tarnished by annual brawls.
asserted
game → do → brawls
So the AFL adds multiples to suspensions and fines for offences committed in the grand final.
asserted
AFL → add → final
What if we adopted a similarly flexible approach in the preliminary final?
asserted
we → adopt → final
What if any player who was found guilty in a preliminary final of an offence that would ordinarily draw a one-week suspension was instead allowed to play the grand final and serve a one-month suspension at the start of the next season?
asserted
that → find → season
How many would take the one week?
asserted
many → take → week
I would guess none.
asserted
I → guess → none
How many would take the first few matches of the new season?
asserted
many → take → season
This might have a quirky consequence were it in place this year, as it would allow Neale to play in the grand final then sit out the first month for Collingwood next year.
uncertain
Neale → have → Collingwood
But putting that aside, this idea would redress the disconnect between the AFL and the fans and players when it comes to recognising the significance of grand finals.
asserted
it → put → finals
I don’t expect the AFL to introduce this idea, and I’m not even sure they should, given the unfairness to Fremantle of allowing a player to play in the grand final whom the tribunal accepts will be suspended for a month next year.
asserted
tribunal → expect → month
But the exercise of asking who would choose a one-month ban over missing a grand final reinforces the point that grand finals are worth more than regular games.
asserted
finals → ask → games
The current rules mean relatively minor offences draw major punishments.
asserted
offences → mean → punishments
The AFL could consider a version of the Briginshaw test in grand final week.
uncertain
AFL → consider → week
That is, the seriousness of the penalty must be weighed against the seriousness of the offence, rather than just accepting that if the player committed this careless act, then this is the penalty.
asserted
this → weigh → act
This would mean asking, how serious was the offence?
asserted
offence → mean → ?
Because guilty the sentence this week is missing a grand final, which is tantamount to a multiple week suspension.
asserted
which → miss → suspension
Neale’s case could never hinge on whether he hit Hawthorn’s Jack Ginnivan – clearly he swung an arm and struck him in the guts.
uncertain
he → hinge → guts
It also was off the ball, and so worse than the sort of tummy tap Swann had in mind with the rule change at the start of the year.
asserted
Swann → have → year
The query was whether, once guilty, he deserved leniency in sentencing given his suspension-free 320 games and two Brownlow medals.
asserted
he → deserve → games
The question is, should the AFL also weigh, along with those considerations, the greater significance of missing a grand final?
asserted
AFL → weigh → final
The only certainty on Tuesday night as the tribunal’s decision to uphold the one-match suspension came down was that Neale may have surpassed James Sicily for a line of quickfire expletives.
uncertain
Neale → uphold → expletives
Get around our AFL finals coverage
- Finals: Alleged MCG nacho-thrower faces assault charges
- Lachie Neale: Lions to appeal star’s grand final ban
- Contentious calls:
asserted
Lions → get → ban
The Aporia
