In November 2020, Barack Obama warned of an “epistemological crisis” facing western democracies.
asserted
Obama → warn → democracies
Polarisation and radicalisation were corroding trust in established information sources.
asserted
Polarisation → corrode → sources
“If we do not have the capacity to distinguish what’s true from what’s false, then by definition the marketplace of ideas doesn’t work,” the former US president said.
asserted
president → have → ideas
That vulnerability has grown since then.
asserted
vulnerability → grow → ?
Democracy’s enemies have become more determined to exploit it.
asserted
enemies → become → it
This is the threat that Andy Burnham highlighted in a speech at the United Nations this week.
asserted
Burnham → highlight → Nations
The prime minister accused Russia of waging an “industrial-scale assault” on the UK’s information environment using bot armies and fake websites to spread falsehoods, interfere in elections, foment discord and poison inter-community relations.
asserted
minister → accuse → relations
The prime minister announced the creation of a National Centre for Information Defence to thwart campaigns of epistemological sabotage by hostile actors.
asserted
minister → announce → actors
Mr Burnham is right to highlight the threat, but he told only part of the story.
asserted
he → highlight → story
The Kremlin would be wasting its money pumping out disinformation if large US tech platforms didn’t provide convenient channels for the toxin to spread, if there weren’t a complicit audience in Britain sharing the offending material and if the market for spreading pernicious propaganda weren’t so lucrative.
asserted
market → waste → propaganda
Information warfare is only effective when it exploits structural vulnerabilities in the target society.
asserted
it → exploit → society
Far-right material sowing hatred against migrants is most fruitful where the terrain has been fertilised by domestic politics.
asserted
terrain → sow → politics
Earlier this year, analysis by the Guardian found that more than half of accounts on X that were posting about racially aggravated riots in Belfast and civil disorder in Southampton were based outside the UK.
asserted
that → find → UK
Seven of the most-read tweets originated in the US, including one posted by X’s proprietor, Elon Musk, the world’s richest man.
asserted
Seven → read → proprietor
Mr Musk has been assiduous in promoting a warped, dystopian idea of Britain as a failed state whose culture is being corroded by mass migration.
asserted
culture → promote → migration
His platform has been invaluable to far-right activists who have mustered gangs of masked men into mobs that obstruct roads, intimidate people and threaten asylum claimants at British ports.
asserted
that → muster → ports
Last year, Mr Musk addressed a rally organised by the far-right activist Tommy Robinson, where he called for the Labour government to be removed.
asserted
government → address → activist
Earlier this year, Mr Robinson, whose real name is Stephen Yaxley-Lennon, travelled to Moscow on a trip funded by the Musk Foundation.
asserted
name → travel → Foundation
He said the purpose of the trip was to “see the beauty of a civilised society”.
asserted
purpose → say → society
Mr Burnham did not address that side of the anti‑democracy equation in his speech, perhaps because he felt that it would be impolitic to impugn US big tech under the president’s nose.
asserted
it → address → nose
Mr Trump is also an originator and disseminator of falsehoods online, but the nature of transatlantic diplomacy prevents a UK prime minister confronting him with that record.
asserted
nature → prevent → record
Under the circumstances, it made sense for Mr Burnham to concentrate his remarks on the threat from the Kremlin, but that must not signal the limit of his policy focus.
asserted
that → make → focus
British democracy is indeed under attack from Russia, but an effective campaign to build resilience has to recognise also the complicity of domestic extremists and the digital privileges they enjoy thanks to US technology companies.
asserted
they → build → companies
-
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article?
asserted
you → raise → article
If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.
asserted
you → like → section
The Aporia
