A Canadian permanent resident originally from Punjab has been sentenced to 15 months in prison after a judge rejected his request for a shorter sentence that could have helped him preserve his right to appeal a possible deportation order.
uncertain
him → sentence → order
Harpreet Singh, 30, was convicted in Ontario of sexual interference, making sexually explicit material available to a child for the purpose of facilitating sexual interference, and exposing a person under 16 to sexual activity for a sexual purpose.
asserted
material → convict → purpose
Singh, who was born and raised in Punjab, India, had asked the court to sentence him to 182 days in jail followed by two years of probation.
asserted
who → bear → probation
His immigration lawyer argued that a sentence of six months or more on any individual count could have serious immigration consequences for him.
uncertain
sentence → argue → him
The lawyer told the court that Singh could lose his right to appeal a removal order to Canada's Immigration Appeal Division if sentenced to six months or more, potentially preventing him from seeking discretionary relief on humanitarian and compassionate grounds.
uncertain
Singh → tell → grounds
But Ontario Court of Justice Justice Joe Patrick Paul Fiorucci rejected the request, saying immigration consequences could not justify imposing a sentence that would otherwise be inappropriate.
uncertain
that → reject → sentence
“Such a sentence would be neither fit nor proportionate,” the judge said in his September 15 decision, according to the National Post.
uncertain
judge → say → Post
Instead, Singh was sentenced to 15 months in prison followed by three years of probation.
asserted
Singh → sentence → probation
What happened to the teenage girl?
asserted
What → happen → girl
The court heard that Singh encountered the 15-year-old girl on a city bus on May 1, 2023.
uncertain
Singh → hear → May
Singh sat across from the girl during the journey and watched sexually explicit material on his phone, according to the court decision.
The two strangers got off the bus at the same location at about 11:23pm.
uncertain
strangers → sit → 11:23pm
According to the judgment, Singh followed the girl onto a dark trail, grabbed her from behind by the collar and hair and then exposed himself while holding his phone and displaying sexually explicit material to her.
uncertain
Singh → accord → her
The teenager fought back by elbowing and pushing Singh before fleeing.
asserted
teenager → fight → Singh
The girl's identity is protected by a publication ban.
asserted
identity → protect → ban
The court said she described the incident as “humiliating, terrifying, and deeply violating” and said it had changed her sense of safety in her community.
asserted
it → say → community
She experienced anxiety, panic and fear in places where she had previously felt comfortable, according to the judgment.
uncertain
she → experience → judgment
Judge rejects immigration-based sentencing request
asserted
Judge → reject → request
Singh's lawyer argued that a sentence of less than six months could have significant consequences for his immigration status.
uncertain
sentence → argue → status
The judge said he had considered those consequences but rejected the argument that they should determine the sentence.
asserted
they → say → sentence
"While immigration consequences are entitled to serious consideration, they cannot be permitted to dominate the sentencing exercise or create a separate sentencing regime for offenders facing possible removal from Canada,” Fiorucci said.
asserted
Fiorucci → entitle → Canada
The judge described Singh's conduct as deliberate and predatory and said the offences were directed at a vulnerable child.
asserted
offences → describe → child
He said the circumstances were “highly aggravating” and that Singh's degree of moral blameworthiness was high.
The Crown had sought between 12 and 15 months in prison, along with three years of probation.
Singh's background and rehabilitation
Singh was single and had no children at the time of sentencing.
asserted
Singh → say → sentencing
His family had been arranging a marriage for him, but those plans were put on hold while his criminal case was being resolved.
asserted
case → arrange → hold
He was unemployed when he was sentenced but was looking for work, particularly in the electrical field.
asserted
he → sentence → field
He had also volunteered in his religious community for several years.
asserted
He → volunteer → years
Family members and a friend submitted letters describing him as honest, hardworking, respectful, dependable and supportive.
asserted
members → submit → him
The judge noted that Singh had undergone counselling with a social worker.
asserted
Singh → note → worker
According to the court, the treatment helped him understand the seriousness and consequences of his conduct, accept responsibility, identify relevant risk factors and understand the importance of boundaries and continued self-monitoring.
uncertain
him → accord → monitoring
A social worker assessed Singh as currently presenting a low risk of sexual reoffending, taking into account factors including his status as a first-time offender and his participation in treatment.
asserted
worker → assess → treatment
However, the judge said the seriousness of the offences and the harm suffered by the victim required a substantial custodial sentence.
asserted
seriousness → say → sentence
Singh will serve 15 months in prison followed by three years of probation.
asserted
Singh → serve → probation
The Aporia
