The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) wrongly identified 185 people on Nevada’s voter rolls as non-citizens, state officials said this week, escalating concerns over the shoddy methodology the government is using to raise fear about non-citizen voting ahead of the midterm elections.
asserted
government → identify → elections
In July, Donald Trump gave a speech saying DHS had found a combined 278,000 non-citizens on the rolls in Nevada, California, Pennsylvania and New Jersey.
asserted
DHS → give → Nevada
Follow-up letters to each of those states weakened the claim, saying there only could be as many as 278,000 non-citizens on the rolls, including up to 15,903 in Nevada.
uncertain
letters → weaken → Nevada
In August, DHS officials told staffers in the Nevada secretary of state’s office that they had reviewed the numbers and confirmed only 185 were non-citizens.
asserted
185 → tell → numbers
DHS officials said they still needed to review more than 14,000 records.
asserted
they → say → records
But on Wednesday, Nevada election officials said they had reviewed the 185 records DHS sent them and confirmed they were US citizens.
asserted
they → say → them
“As for the 185 individuals, our records indicate that they were citizens.
asserted
they → indicate → individuals
You have provided nothing of substance to suggest otherwise,” Greg Ott, a deputy attorney general, wrote to DHS this week in an email obtained by the New York Times and Nevada Independent.
asserted
Ott → provide → Times
DHS did not return a request for comment.
asserted
DHS → return → comment
In his email, Ott lamented DHS had not been transparent about the methodology DHS had used to flag alleged non-citizens nor had it shared adequate information.
asserted
it → lament → information
When Nevada officials requested DHS provide the first name, last name, address, and any other data point DHS officials matched, the department said they were only going to provide the voter ID number.
asserted
they → request → number
In Nevada, a voter registration number can belong to multiple people, he wrote.
asserted
he → belong → people
Each of Nevada’s counties used to maintain their own registration system, but Nevada recently transitioned to a single statewide voter registration system and gave voters new state voter identification numbers.
asserted
Nevada → use → numbers
“As a result, the same number may appear at different points in time in connection with different voter records,” he wrote.
uncertain
he → appear → records
“The number also doesn’t tell us whether an individual was born in the United States, naturalized, derived citizenship through a parent, or holds any particular immigration status.
asserted
individual → tell → status
Election records commonly reflect the information supplied during registration,” he added.
asserted
he → reflect → registration
“For example, if someone registered to vote in 1970, the registration record may be incomplete; the name, address, and date of birth may be incomplete, changed, entered differently, or shared by more than one person.
uncertain
name → register → person
A number that matches a voter record thus establishes only that a number exists in, or once existed in, a voter registration system.”
asserted
number → match → system
The news outlet Votebeat also reported earlier this month that election officials in Pennsylvania have also pushed DHS for information on its basis for claiming there were as many as 14,576 non-citizens on its rolls.
asserted
officials → report → rolls
In an August letter obtained by Votebeat, Al Schmidt, Pennsylvania’s top election official, said DHS representatives had indicated they did not have “high confidence” in that number.
asserted
they → obtain → number
The Aporia
