Eighteen years before Russian tanks rolled into Ukraine, the then German chancellor Gerhard Schröder was asked for his opinion on President Vladimir Putin.
asserted
chancellor → roll → Putin
“I am thoroughly convinced that the Russian president wants to transform Russia into a democracy and that he is doing so out of a deeply held conviction,” he said in 2004.
asserted
he → convince → 2004
That same year, Putin was re
asserted
Putin → re → ?
His comments underlined a spirit of cooperation and friendship that had grown between the two countries since the end of World War Two.
asserted
that → underline → War
Germany’s economy hugely benefited from imports of cheap Russian gas, culminating in the construction of the Nord Stream gas pipeline under the Baltic Sea.
asserted
economy → benefit → Sea
That relationship has now hit an all-time low.
asserted
relationship → hit → low
On Wednesday, the deputy chairman of Russia’s Security Council, Dmitry Medvedev, threatened Germany with direct military strikes in response to Berlin’s claim that Russia was behind a failed explosive drone attack at Leipzig Airport last month.
uncertain
Russia → threaten → Airport
The drone, which was laden with explosives, failed to detonate near a Ukrainian cargo plane.
asserted
which → fail → plane
The Kremlin said the accusation was "baseless," but Germany has responded by summoning Moscow's ambassador, ordering the closure of the Russian consulate in Bonn, and shutting down the Russian House cultural institute in Berlin.
asserted
Germany → say → Berlin
Germany’s leadership has also signalled plans to crack down on Russia’s maritime shadow fleet and announced support for an expanded European Union sanctions package.
asserted
leadership → signal → package
Analysts say the deteriorating relationship between Moscow and Berlin is crucial of the future of Ukraine and Europe.
asserted
relationship → say → Ukraine
Below The Independent looks at how one of Putin’s key economic partners became an enemy.
asserted
one → look → partners
Germany's relationship with Russia before the war
Successive German governments under Schröder and Angela Merkel have sought deep economic integration with Moscow.
asserted
governments → seek → Moscow
This strategy, rooted in the post-Cold War doctrine of Ostpolitik, was built on the belief that mutual commercial dependence would guarantee stability and deter Putin from threatening Europe.
asserted
dependence → root → Europe
Central to the relationship was a reliance on Russian gas, which saw an enormous amount of fuel sold to Germany at cheap prices.
asserted
amount → see → prices
The economic partnership between both states led to the construction of the Nord Stream gas pipelines in 2011, which delivered Russian fuel across the Baltic Sea to Germany.
asserted
which → lead → Germany
Ian Bond, the deputy director of The Centre for European Reform (CER), said the signing of the 2015 Minsk II Agreement was another indicator of the strength of Russian-German relations at the time.
asserted
signing → say → time
Brokered under Merkel, the deal was widely criticised as effectively signalling Western acceptance of Russia's illegal annexation of Crimea.
asserted
deal → broker → Crimea
Berlin refused to sever its economic ties to the Kremlin despite the annexation drawing international condemnation, repeatedly dismissing concerns from Washington and Eastern European allies that their relationship posed a risk to security.
By the eve of the 2022 full-scale invasion of Ukraine, Germany was relying on Russia for over 50 percent of its natural gas imports.
asserted
Germany → refuse → imports
How did Germany respond to the war?
asserted
Germany → respond → war
The energy partnership unravelled in February 2022 after Russia invaded Ukraine, as the construction for Nord Stream 2 collapsed, dismantling decades of trade policy and forcing Germany to seek alternative energy supplies.
In response to the invasion, the then chancellor Olaf Scholz announced a fundamental turning point in German foreign and security policy — a pivot termed the Zeitenwende.
asserted
chancellor → unravel → policy
The U-turn saw decades of post-WWII military restraint overhauled by an €100 billion fund to modernise German armed forces, send military aid to Kyiv, and systematically end the country’s economic reliance on Moscow.
asserted
decades → see → Moscow
For Mr Bond, the war bought a change in the German collective consciousness: “There was a realisation in Germany that Putin’s ambitions were not limited to Crimea and bits of Donbas.
asserted
ambitions → buy → Donbas
“Russia is an imperialist power... and I think the Germans took some time to wake up and realise that Europe has a serious Russia problem.
asserted
Europe → think → problem
Why has Germany now become Putin's public enemy number one?
asserted
Germany → become → ?
The motives behind Russia’s recent hybrid attacks are partly strategic, explained Mr Bond, with Moscow seeking to exploit divisions in Germany over continuing support for Kyiv.
asserted
Moscow → explain → Kyiv
State elections are coming up in Germany where the far-right, pro-Russia party, Alternative for Germany (AfD) are topping the polls.
asserted
party → come → polls
“With these attacks, it seems like Putin is trying to scare Germans into voting for a party who can show that they won’t have a problem with Russia,” he said.
asserted
he → seem → Russia
Mr Bond said that voters opting for a party sympathetic to the Kremlin was a “puzzle” unique to Germany, that was not replicated in eastern European states.
asserted
that → say → states
But Putin’s targeting of Germany is not exceptional, cautioned Mr Bond.
asserted
Bond → caution → Germany
Several states and institutions have been subject to the Kremlin’s aggression — including Poland and the Baltic states.
asserted
states → include → Poland
“Germany is bearing the brunt of recent attacks, but there is quite a lot of this going on,” he said.
“The message of this for the rest of Europe and NATO is that, while Russia may not be strong enough to launch direct attacks, it is doing everything it can to destabilise Europe, and try to scare away support for Ukraine.”
uncertain
it → bear → Ukraine
Mr Bond warned against potential German appeasement of Putin.
asserted
Bond → warn → Putin
“Each one hopes that if he feeds the crocodile enough, the crocodile will eat him last," Mr Bond quoted.
asserted
Bond → hop → him
“Here, Putin is hoping that the rest of Europe will believe that if it feeds Ukraine to Russia — it’ll be the end of it all.”
asserted
it → hop → it
The Aporia
