Two-year-old Joe Massa died of a “strikingly unusual” complication, but signs that the toddler was critically ill were instantly recognised by a nurse who bypassed doctors to raise the alarm, a coronial inquest has heard.
Joe’s death in September 2024 galvanised the Minns government’s plans to end the Northern Beaches Hospital’s public-private partnership model after his mother, Elouise Massa, reported that she had repeatedly tried to alert staff to her son’s worsening condition.
asserted
she → die → condition
Senior nurse Felicity Melville started her shift as team leader at 10am on September 14 in the Northern Beaches Hospital’s emergency department, almost three hours after Elouise Massa brought Joe in.
asserted
Massa → start → Joe
On Thursday, through tears, Melville told the inquest that as soon as she saw Joe she knew that he was “very, very unwell.
asserted
he → tell → Joe
It was instantly obvious to me”, describing Joe’s dark and sunken eyes and mottled skin.
asserted
It → describe → eyes
Melville said she tried to perform a full set of observations on the toddler, and had to leave Joe’s bedside twice to find missing monitor cables and replacements for broken stickers used to monitor heart rate and saturation readings.
asserted
she → say → rate
Melville said the equipment often went missing or broke.
asserted
equipment → say → ?
She could not record Joe’s heart rate, but recorded an abnormally fast respiratory rate of 57.
uncertain
She → record → 57
When asked on Thursday whether she had the impression that Joe’s treating doctors were not recognising Joe’s condition as she was, Melville recalled a registrar telling Elouise Massa that they would wait for an ultrasound.
asserted
they → ask → ultrasound
“To me that was reassurance, and I wanted action.
asserted
I → want → action
I wanted immediate action,” she said.
asserted
she → want → action
Melville said that as another doctor began assessing Joe, she escalated the matter to her nurse unit manager, then wheeled Joe in his bed out of paediatric ED towards the resuscitation area.
asserted
she → say → area
“There was no direct conversation between either of the doctors and myself about going to resus [sic], or asking me to sort of intervene anyway,” she said.
asserted
she → be → me
Melville said Joe’s large bed would have slowed them down through a crowded triage area, so she scooped him up and put him on a smaller trolley.
asserted
she → say → trolley
“I’ve picked Joe [up], and Mrs Massa said to me: ‘My son is very sick’, and I said, ‘yes he is, and I’m getting us help’,” Melville recalled.
asserted
Melville → pick → help
Melville said she told another doctor, “I’m really worried about this child”.
asserted
I → say → child
The doctor responded and came to Joe’s bedside in the resuscitation bay.
asserted
doctor → respond → bay
She said she called the paediatric ED, but the registrar and senior doctor were not there, so she used the hospital’s speaker system to alert them.
asserted
she → say → them
She then found a resuscitation nurse nearby.
asserted
She → find → nurse
Moments later, Joe began seizing and went into cardiac arrest.
asserted
Joe → begin → arrest
Melville recalled through tears that Joe’s father, Danny Massa, had arrived and put his hand to Joe’s face just as he arrested.
asserted
he → recall → face
Joe was rushed to the Sydney Children’s Hospital, where he suffered cardiac arrest for 30 minutes, depriving his brain of oxygen.
asserted
he → rush → oxygen
He died on September 16, 2024.
asserted
He → die → September
On Friday, the doctor who oversaw Joe’s care at the Children’s Hospital said Joe’s cardiac arrest was caused by necrotic ischaemic bowel, “a nasty condition”.
asserted
arrest → oversee → bowel
Dr Andrew Numa said Joe’s presentation was an “extraordinarily uncommon illness”.
asserted
presentation → say → ?
“It’s strikingly unusual,” Numa said, and despite extensive efforts by multiple specialities, they identified no underlying cause.
asserted
they → ’ → cause
A stool sample tested positive for adenovirus, a common flu-like infection, which has been associated in rare circumstances with intestinal necrosis, “but it could be completely incidental”, Numa said.
uncertain
Numa → test → necrosis
On Monday, Elouise Massa held a tiny pair of her son’s shoes as she spoke on the first day of the inquest.
asserted
she → hold → inquest
She said clinicians at the hospital were rude and did not listen to her concerns as Joe’s condition rapidly deteriorated.
asserted
condition → say → concerns
Melville addressed Joe’s family directly on Thursday, saying: “I am so deeply sorry for your loss.
asserted
I → address → loss
Joseph mattered, and he matters now, and he will not be forgotten.
asserted
he → matter → ?
Under Joe’s Law, the Minns government banned future public-private partnerships in NSW’s healthcare system.
asserted
government → ban → system
The Aporia
