The News
The diesel export ban that President Donald Trump is mulling in a bid to bring down record-high prices would backfire in two ways — further dividing Hill Republicans while risking even pricier gasoline.
asserted
Trump → mull → gasoline
It’s not clear that the Trump administration will impose diesel export limits, which the president said this week that he’d explore as average national prices push past $6.50 per gallon.
asserted
prices → ’ → gallon
If Trump does push ahead, his main cheerleaders will be GOP candidates in tight races this fall who are eager to market more ideas to lower costs before the midterms.
asserted
who → push → midterms
But most congressional Republicans want nothing to do with the idea, no matter how close they are with the administration.
asserted
they → want → administration
“The better policy would be for states like California to lift the restrictions that they’re imposing on the exploitation and the refining of diesel,” Sen. Bill Hagerty, R-Tenn., told Semafor.
asserted
Hagerty → lift → Semafor
“Taking down domestic barriers that have been exerted by states — that, to me, is a far better approach.”
asserted
that → take → me
US oil executives have fought hard against a ban, warning it would push prices higher worldwide; the European Union recently echoed their concerns, as its own diesel costs climbed following Trump’s remarks.
asserted
costs → fight → remarks
Energy analysts are just as critical, describing it as a Band-Aid at best — even if the constraints are nonbinding, as Energy Secretary Chris Wright suggested they could be in Pennsylvania on Thursday afternoon.
uncertain
they → describe → afternoon
“The diesel export ban, even if in a strong-armed ‘voluntary’ form, is a desperate idea that promotes inefficiency and ultimately higher prices,” said Skanda Amarnath, a former Federal Reserve economist who now helms the left-leaning organization Employ America.
asserted
who → promote → organization
The frosty response from Trump’s own party is particularly notable after a year that began with Republicans stiff-arming his earliest ideas to lower the cost of living.
asserted
Republicans → begin → living
Soon after, Trump pursued an Iran war that has since dragged on past the seven-month mark, straining the global economy and leaving voters increasingly pessimistic.
asserted
that → pursue → voters
GOP lawmakers instead proposed alternatives like cutting gas taxes or tapping oil reserves:
asserted
lawmakers → propose → reserves
“We should be looking at multiple solutions,” Hagerty said.
asserted
Hagerty → look → solutions
Sen. Thom Tillis, R-N.C., lamented that “we always keep skating to where the puck is at the expense of getting to where the puck’s going to be,” calling the ban “just another example where, even in the White House, I think there’s disagreements about the pros and cons.”
“The president always makes the decision that is best for the American people,” a White House official told Semafor, adding that he “is evaluating all the options on the table.”
asserted
he → lament → table
Know More
GOP Senate candidates like Ashley Hinson in Iowa and Mike Rogers in Michigan say a ban is necessary to bolster their states’ struggling agricultural producers.
asserted
ban → know → producers
Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, who also faces a tough race, said she hasn’t “had the chance to look at” the proposal.
asserted
she → face → proposal
Like Hagerty, she proffered a different solution: releasing heating oil from a federal reserve ahead of the winter.
asserted
she → proffer → winter
Oil-state Republicans are harshest of all in their criticism: Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, derided it as “a gimmick” that “won’t work.”
asserted
that → deride → gimmick
As plummeting consumer sentiment emboldens Democrats to push farther into GOP-held territory despite a cash deficit in some key races, they see the export ban as proof of the GOP’s desperation this late in the cycle.
asserted
they → plummet → cycle
“Republicans can try one gimmick after the other, but they refuse to deal with the source of the problem,” House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries told reporters this week.
asserted
Jeffries → try → reporters
“Go tell Donald Trump to end that war in Iran that no one in America asked for in the first place.
asserted
one → tell → place
While there is already legislation that would restrict diesel exports, the Trump administration doesn’t need Congress to act, legal experts told Semafor.
asserted
experts → be → Semafor
Trump can impose a ban unilaterally thanks to sweeping authorities provided by the International Emergency Economic Powers Act — the same law that provided his initial authority for tariffs since struck down by the Supreme Court.
asserted
that → impose → Court
“This would be a very straightforward thing to do under IEEPA,” said Georgetown Law’s Peter Harrell, a former State Department official who later oversaw supply chains on former President Joe Biden’s National Security Council and National Economic Council.
asserted
who → do → Council
Trump needs to declare oil shortages a national emergency, Harrell said, and sign an executive order restricting diesel exports.
asserted
Harrell → need → exports
The order could allow the Energy Department to make some exemptions “in case there is some unforeseen adverse consequence,” he added.
uncertain
he → allow → case
Trump also has the option of wielding the Defense Production Act, as he did to crack down on exports of critical minerals and protective equipment.
asserted
he → have → minerals
“But that would be more complex,” Harrell said.
asserted
Harrell → say → ?
The small group of Republicans who have called for a ban to tamp down prices say it’s a necessary step to shield farmers and consumers from the Iran war’s economic fallout.
asserted
it → call → fallout
Sen. Chuck Grassley, R-Iowa, said on the Senate floor this week Trump should impose the embargo by executive order to “help family farmers who feed and fuel the world.”
asserted
who → say → world
Democrats see the response to Trump’s latest idea as proof that Republicans are flailing, but we see the clearest sign yet of what our colleague Burgess identified earlier this week: A GOP long in this president’s thrall is suddenly moving past him at an increasingly fast clip.
asserted
GOP → see → clip
The degree of blunt talk we heard from Trump’s party about the economic and political downsides of a ban — at least, on the record — would have been unimaginable last year.
asserted
we → hear → record
The Aporia
