The Houthis‘ advance doesn’t mean Iran is winning.
asserted
Iran → mean → ?
It means President Donald Trump is.
asserted
Trump → mean → ?
This might sound crazy compared to the popular Western narrative.
uncertain
This → sound → narrative
In fact, the escalation exposes a decaying regime.
asserted
escalation → expose → regime
It is the act of a panicked, paralyzed regime on the brink of falling.
asserted
It → fall → falling
Recent Trump-era blockades and sanctions have drained Iran of hundreds of millions of dollars daily, pushing the regime to increase its support for the Houthis despite its previously skeptical and limited backing.
asserted
blockades → drain → backing
This sudden cash injection has enabled the Houthis to block Red Sea ports and shipping lanes, effectively preventing Saudi Arabia from diverting oil to Yanbu Port after the Strait of Hormuz was closed.
asserted
Strait → enable → Hormuz
This is no typical Iranian tentacle wrapping itself further around the Middle East.
asserted
This → wrap → East
It is a panicked plot by a cornered regime calling on a faction that should be its last resort.
asserted
that → call → faction
In an interview with France 24, Thomas Juneau, a University of Ottawa professor and leading researcher on the Houthi-Iran relationship, explained, “I’ve written a lot over the years to reject the view that the Houthis are a puppet of Iranian foreign policy, that the Houthis are an arm of Iranian foreign policy that merely obeys or executes Iran’s orders.
asserted
that → lead → orders
I think the relationship is much more complicated than that.”
asserted
relationship → think → that
Asked about recent events, Juneau said, “What we’ve been seeing in the last few days in Yemen has absolutely been done in close coordination with Iran and has to be seen in the context of developments in the Persian Gulf.”
asserted
seeing → ask → Gulf
Although the Houthis may now look like a proxy, coordination does not mean control.
uncertain
coordination → look → control
In Iran’s eyes, the Houthis offer a poor return on investment compared with other regional militant groups, particularly because Tehran does not want to risk a direct, costly escalation with Saudi Arabia.
asserted
Tehran → offer → Arabia
The gap in scale tells the true story.
asserted
gap → tell → story
Saudi Arabia poured at least $4 billion into Yemen from 2012 to 2022 alone.
asserted
Arabia → pour → 2022
By contrast, a 2015 U.N. Security Council report traced Iranian arms shipments to the Houthis back to 2009, including a 2011 seizure of 900 Iranian rockets.
asserted
report → trace → rockets
It found that American officials estimated Iran’s historical assistance consisted merely of small arms and “several million dollars in cash.”
asserted
assistance → find → cash
The backing was so minimal that in 2014, both the United Nations and the United States explicitly stated that the Houthis were not an Iranian proxy but a group receiving limited support.
asserted
Houthis → state → support
Michael Mulroy, a former deputy assistant secretary of defense for the Middle East and co-founder of the Lobo Institute, offers the sharpest counter.
asserted
Mulroy → offer → counter
“The Houthis are the most effective proxy for Iran,” Mulroy said.
asserted
Mulroy → say → Iran
“They have essentially pledged allegiance to the new supreme leader and have actively joined this conflict, compounding the economic pressure Iran is putting on the world energy market.
asserted
Iran → pledge → market
The U.S. will have to deal with them decisively if this conflict is to come to an end favorably to the U.S. and the region.
asserted
conflict → have → U.S.
Although the Houthis’ expansion has negative ramifications for the world energy market, it also raises a question about how they should be treated: If the Houthis are truly Iran’s proxy arm, the only viable outcome for the U.S. is direct intervention to clamp down on Iran.
asserted
outcome → have → Iran
That doesn’t fully add up, however, given that U.S. officials met directly with the Houthis in Oman on Sunday.
asserted
officials → add → Sunday
Trump said of the secret meeting, “The Houthis called us, and they don’t want to fight with us.
asserted
they → say → us
They don’t want me to go after them.”
asserted
me → want → them
When asked for further comment on the recent escalation, a State Department spokesperson said, “Iran’s support for the Houthis is nothing new — it has armed, funded, and trained the terrorist group for over a decade, enabling the Houthis to sow chaos in Yemen and beyond and interfere with freedom of navigation in the Red Sea.”
asserted
it → ask → Sea
Asked how the Trump administration plans to tackle the Houthis, the spokesperson added, “The Trump administration has clearly demonstrated its resolve and commitment to confront Iran and its proxies throughout the region, and we will not hesitate to use all available tools to counter the full range of Iran’s destabilizing actions.”
asserted
we → ask → actions
This puts the U.S. in a position of ultimate strength.
asserted
This → put → strength
Washington is twisting Iran’s hand toward imminent economic collapse, and Tehran’s financial ability to feed its regional network will naturally evaporate.
asserted
ability → twist → network
That will weaken its hold on the Houthis, particularly against Trump’s peace-through-strength pragmatism.
asserted
That → weaken → pragmatism
As Iran’s economy deteriorates, its ability to sustain the Houthis weakens, allowing Yemen’s internationally recognized government, which actively combats the group, to deal with the aftermath rather than the U.S.
Tehran thought deploying the Houthis would be a smart last-ditch effort, a counterpunch to inflict harm on the U.S. and its allies.
asserted
deploying → deteriorate → U.S.
What it forgot is who it is facing, and the message this sends: Iran is losing, and not just slightly.
asserted
Iran → forget → who
William Nye is a Brisbane-based Australian student and op-ed columnist covering global and domestic politics, culture, economics, and international affairs, with a strong focus on U.S. politics.
asserted
Nye → base → politics
His work has appeared in the Spectator Australia and the Washington Examiner.
asserted
work → appear → Spectator
The Aporia
