For months, Canadian Jews have been warning that if nothing changes, an attack like the one that happened on Bondi Beach in Australia in December — when gunmen opened fire at a Hanukkah celebration, killing 15 innocents and wounding 40 — could happen here.
uncertain
gunmen → warn → 40
On Sunday, that worst-case-scenario would have come to pass, if not for the actions of a real-life Canadian hero: Const. Jeff Smith.
asserted
scenario → come → hero
If our political leaders had just a thimbleful of Smith’s courage, the antisemitism that has been rotting this country’s core would have been stamped out years ago.
asserted
that → have → core
Instead, when faced with unprecedented hate directed at Canadian Jews, Prime Minister Mark Carney recognized a non-existent state of “Palestine,” effectively rewarding Hamas for its terrorism against Jews and starting a war with Israel.
asserted
Carney → face → Israel
Meanwhile, the Liberals shamelessly mine for votes from anti-Israel communities.
asserted
Liberals → mine → communities
When a man like Smith risks everything to protect his fellow Canadians, the least the governing party could do is risk a few seats.
uncertain
party → risk → seats
The officer was stationed outside the Sons of Jacob Synagogue in Belleville, Ont., on Sunday evening, as congregants were filing in for Yom Kippur services, when a gunman, alleged to be 29-year-old former Canadian Armed Forces member Sean Ward, screamed, “You are going to die for the Jews,” and opened fire.
asserted
You → station → fire
Smith was hit almost immediately, before he even had a chance to exit his vehicle.
asserted
he → hit → vehicle
But that did not stop him.
asserted
that → stop → him
Rather than taking cover and tending to his wounds, Smith got out of his car and traded fire with the gunman for nearly three minutes when a second officer, Const. Mike McCurdy, arrived and immediately engaged the shooter.
asserted
officer → take → shooter
Thanks to Const. Smith’s bravery, the threat was ultimately neutralized.
asserted
threat → neutralize → bravery
According to Belleville Police Chief Murray Rodd, Smith and McCurdy put a stop to “what would have become an unimaginable tragedy,” in what he described as a “deliberate attack directed at members of the Jewish community.”
uncertain
he → accord → community
Thanks to Smith’s selfless bravery, the only person who died in the attack was Ward, though Smith is still in critical but stable condition, having suffered gunshot wounds to his head and body.
asserted
Smith → die → head
The response from Canadians has been heartening: a GoFundMe campaign for the officer had more than $700,000 as of Friday afternoon.
asserted
campaign → hearten → afternoon
But whether this is representative of a Canada that is finally confronting the growing threat to Canadian Jews remains to be seen.
asserted
that → confront → Jews
After giving a full-throated speech in Toronto in June, in which he admitted that “Canada’s civic compact is failing Jewish-Canadians,” Carney could only muster a boilerplate response to a terrorist attack that almost resulted in a bloodbath, writing on X that, “Jewish people must be able to worship safely.
uncertain
people → give → X
That should go without saying.
asserted
That → go → ?
The question now is: what is the government going to do to stem the growing tide of hate in this country?
asserted
government → go → country
Will it suddenly grow a spine?
asserted
it → grow → spine
We are not encouraged.
asserted
We → encourage → ?
The Belleville attack represents a serious escalation, as previous synagogue shootings have taken place when they were largely empty.
asserted
they → represent → place
This incident, on the other hand, was clearly intended to be a massacre of Jews, a modern-day pogrom taking place right here in Canada, in a quintessentially peaceful Ontario town.
asserted
incident → intend → town
In his June speech, Carney touted his government’s Canada Community Security Program, which provides millions in funding for synagogues and other community institutions to bolster their security.
asserted
synagogues → tout → security
While there is a need for such private security measures, this has been a tacit admission that the government has broken its social contract with Canadians: the state will protect you, because you do not necessarily have the right to protect yourself.
asserted
you → be → yourself
Unlike in the United States, where the Second Amendment protects the right to “keep and bear arms,” Canada has some of the strictest gun laws in the world.
asserted
Canada → protect → world
Yet it should escape no one’s notice that in this case, the only thing standing in the way of a bad guy with a gun was a good guy with a gun.
asserted
thing → escape → gun
Const. Smith was keeping watch over the synagogue thanks to the foresight of its leaders, who requested a police presence due to concerns over the threat of antisemitic violence.
asserted
who → keep → violence
While seeing police outside synagogues, typically off-duty officers hired by the shuls themselves, has been common for decades, governments and law-enforcement agencies need to understand that this must be the norm going forward, as no amount of security cameras will stop an armed terrorist who’s intent to kill.
asserted
who → see → terrorist
Statements like, “Jewish people must be able to worship safely,” as Carney wrote, are simply not enough, because the right to live in peace and security in this country only exists because it is backed up by the state’s monopoly on violence.
Canada will not see genuine change, and Jews will not be genuinely safe, until political leaders stop trying to win support from those who hate Israel, and by extension Jews themselves.
asserted
who → worship → extension
The Liberals must purge the antisemitic elements from within their ranks.
asserted
Liberals → purge → ranks
And, yes, anti-Zionism is antisemitic, a fact the Liberals should come to terms with.
asserted
Liberals → come → terms
When antisemitic provocations on the streets are shrugged off, hatred will fester and attacks like the one that took place in Belleville will be the inevitable result.
asserted
that → shrug → Belleville
Next time, we may not be lucky enough to have a heroic man like Const. Smith standing in the way of our own Bondi Beach massacre.
uncertain
man → have → massacre
The Aporia
