- Published
"It is tough," John Healey admitted to me earlier this month when I asked him if there had been too much doom-mongering?
"Conflicts, uncertainty, driving up inflation, driving up interest rates.
asserted
I → admit → rates
But we've got great strengths.
asserted
we → get → strengths
We've got good reasons to be confident about the future of Britain," he insisted.
asserted
he → get → Britain
The new scheme to try and help young people get on the property ladder, announced on Saturday, was aimed at boosting confidence in the economy.
asserted
people → try → economy
But the chancellor is now facing two big decisions before his inaugural Budget on 28 October.
asserted
chancellor → face → October
In his first weeks as chancellor the oil price fell as low as $75 a barrel while the yield - the effective interest rate - on 10-year government bonds was 4.9%.
asserted
yield → fall → bonds
Just over two months later oil has largely traded above $100 and the 10-year yield is at around 5.4%.
asserted
yield → trade → %
It is the ultimate double whammy for a chancellor facing his first Budget.
asserted
It → face → Budget
How long could Iran pressures last?
uncertain
pressures → last → ?
It could quickly reverse, as illustrated earlier in the summer when assumptions about a deescalation in the US Iran conflict led to sharp falls in energy prices and yields.
uncertain
assumptions → reverse → prices
In New York this week both President Trump and his Iranian counterpart President Pezeshkian suggested November's US midterm elections were connected to when the war might end.
uncertain
war → suggest → York
The Iranians would wait until after the elections to seek peace because the war's impact on the cost of living - particularly soaring diesel costs - could damage him electorally, the US president told the UN General Assembly.
uncertain
president → wait → Assembly
The Iranian president said his nation "didn't want it to get to the midterms".
asserted
it → say → midterms
Both sides in this war are feeling the economic squeeze of conflict.
asserted
sides → feel → conflict
No one could rely on there being a settlement by then, but it is plausible.
uncertain
it → rely → ?
So the Budget tax, spend and borrowing forecasts could be based on a prolonged conflict, which is actually on the cusp of ending, or even already ended.
uncertain
which → base → ending
The chancellor has to therefore decide whether to plan for the worst, and make some painful permanent tax and spend decisions, or buy some time.
asserted
chancellor → decide → time
One option is to let borrowing take some of the strain, by tolerating a reduction in the £24bn of headroom - room for manoeuvre against its self-imposed borrowing rules - left by his predecessor, Rachel Reeves.
asserted
borrowing → let → predecessor
This year's headroom will be judged in three years rather than four, so there is some rationale as to why a smaller number over a closer target might be appropriate.
uncertain
number → judge → target
And while higher inflation means higher interest costs, it also means higher cash tax receipts, at a time when thresholds continue to be frozen.
2.
asserted
thresholds → mean → time
Will he keep the vibes going?
asserted
vibes → keep → ?
The hopeful optimism "vibes" strategy of the Burnham administration appears to have had some impact.
asserted
strategy → appear → impact
The longest running UK consumer confidence survey has hit a two-year high.
asserted
survey → run → high
Some data companies call it a "Burnham bounce", although the weather and World Cup were also factors.
asserted
weather → call → it
There is evidence, more mixed, that business optimism has also perked up in recent months, possibly because of earlier falls in energy prices, though this has been clouded by anticipation of possible tax rises.
uncertain
this → be → rises
Business group, the Institute of Directors said this was despite, rather than because of, the new government.
asserted
this → say → government
While no one should get too carried away with these turnarounds, they do stand in contrast to the admitted mistake of the Starmer government in talking up consumer pain, two years ago.
asserted
they → get → pain
The question for the chancellor is whether better consumer and business spirits can be reconciled with the need for a "challenging" Budget?
asserted
spirits → reconcile → Budget
Indeed, it's important to determine how much of the summer global bond market shock is solely down to the impact of the Iran war and how much is more structural.
asserted
much → determine → war
Governments are facing new and intense competition in bond markets from the world's biggest AI businesses.
asserted
Governments → face → businesses
In addition, the UK has had recent, prominent political and economic uncertainty.
asserted
UK → have → uncertainty
Right now the bond markets are like a pack of wolves stalking red deer, probing for weaknesses.
"At times like this you don't want to be at the back of the herd," said one very senior former Treasury adviser.
asserted
adviser → stalk → herd
In response, the Treasury has pointed to the UK having the highest growth and the fastest falling borrowing of the major G7 countries so far this year and our overall energy prices starting to decouple from high and volatile gas prices.
asserted
prices → point → prices
However, the IMF chief Kristalina Georgieva this week dismissed the idea that advanced nations could pause their fiscal homework, while the Gulf situation calmed.
uncertain
situation → dismiss → homework
it is impossible to stress strongly enough how critical it is to get the courage to take the steps that are necessary," Georgieva told me, acknowledging the UK's "fairly consistent, credible" plans.
asserted
Georgieva → stress → plans
Last year, the government's official forecaster the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR) downgraded the UK's productivity peformance, leading to a notable hit to the public finances.
asserted
forecaster → downgrade → finances
Now the UK's productivity record has been upgraded materially by the Office for National Statistics, although this is because of fewer hours worked.
asserted
this → upgrade → hours
Separately, the new chair of the OBR Jonathan Haskel is known for his argument that official statistics understate investment in intangibles like software and data.
asserted
statistics → know → software
His latest research suggests AI-related investment is already visible in US productivity figures, and he has long been optimistic about tech's impact on the future.
uncertain
he → suggest → future
While it seems unlikely that such factors will make it into the OBR's calculations next month, there is a real debate here.
asserted
factors → seem → calculations
…and 6 more, not listed.
The Aporia
