What the West misses when it judges China’s dogged AI pursuit
PHILADELPHIA - China’s artificial intelligence success story, often criticised in the West for being unfairly underwritten by the Chinese government, reflects the country’s resolve not to repeat a strategic mistake made 150 years ago, said Singapore’s Foreign Minister Balakrishnan during a discussion on US-China rivalry.
asserted
Balakrishnan → miss → rivalry
China missed the industrial revolution but it won’t make the same mistake twice, said Balakrishnan during a Sept 25 conversation with former Australian prime minister Kevin Rudd, who is now the global president and chief executive of Asia Society in New York.
asserted
who → miss → York
“Because China missed it, China underwent a century plus of humiliation and unequal treaties.
asserted
China → miss → humiliation
This time, China has absolutely no intention of missing it again,” Balakrishnan said in an hour-long exchange during which he challenged how the US seizes the competition from China.
asserted
US → have → China
“You need to understand it is not just a matter of competition with America, being number one or number two, and I am projecting into China’s motivations, but China says: ‘this is my turn, my time in the sunshine.
asserted
this → need → sunshine
Why should anyone get in the way, especially when I have the human talent, the brain power?’,” he said.
asserted
he → get → talent
“So from China’s perspective, ‘I am not going to make the strategic mistake made a century and a half ago.
asserted
I → go → mistake
This is a strategic opportunity and I do not want anyone to get in my way.
asserted
anyone → want → way
And all I am asking for is a level playing field, and access to technology, and to get ahead as quickly as I can’,” he said.
asserted
he → ask → technology
Their intense competition is sharply different from the Sputnik-era contest between the US and the Soviet Union, he said, because today’s superpowers rely on a shared global technological stack and brainpower rather than isolated ecosystems.
asserted
superpowers → say → ecosystems
“What is interesting is that the mathematical and computational basis for AI, the foundations that both America, China, and the rest of us are operating on, is essentially the same stack.
asserted
America → operate → us
The mathematicians, the techniques, the machines are the same,” Balakrishnan said.
asserted
Balakrishnan → say → ?
“And because it is the common stack and it has been open and competitive, the rate of acceleration has been dramatic,” he said.
asserted
he → say → acceleration
Rudd pointed out that China was building its success on an “unlevel playing field”.
asserted
China → point → field
“What is working in China is… state-driven investment in its techno-industrial strategy, plus net exports, and this becomes unsustainable,” he said, pointing at China’s weak domestic consumption and its reliance for growth on exports that have flooded other economies.
asserted
that → work → economies
Balakrishnan said the use of subsidies did not fully explain the country’s AI prowess and what also eggs on the Chinese AI companies is the cut throat domestic competition which results in the creation of cheap and efficient Chinese AI models.
asserted
which → say → models
“Let us assume all subsidies, direct or implicit, are removed.
asserted
subsidies → let → ?
Do you think that would automatically remove the academic, scientific, technological edge of China?
asserted
that → think → China
I do not believe so.
asserted
I → believe → ?
“Do you think that the hyper competition domestically is going to disappear?
asserted
competition → think → ?
“The easy answer is (to) just blame it on subsidy, but I am saying there is something more going on than that, and we better understand what that source of competitive advantage is, and it is real,” he said.
asserted
he → blame → advantage
Rudd accepted the pushback but said both forces were at work – China’s scientific brilliance as well as its subsidies which lead to global overcapacity and set off a political backlash in the US and Europe.
asserted
which → accept → US
“They are applying through conscious industrial strategy, subsidies, which underpin their model, which is producing political blowback here, hence the tariff war from the US and the reduction in the trade surplus of America, and on the cusp of bringing about a similar reaction in Europe,” Rudd said.
asserted
Rudd → apply → Europe
A fundamental imbalance existed in the global economy prior to AI, Balakrishnan also pointed out as the two discussed how the two economies had evolved.
asserted
economies → exist → AI
China became the world’s manufacturing hub, while the US benefited from cheap consumer goods and low interest rates funded by Chinese trade surpluses that were invested in US treasury bills.
asserted
that → become → bills
In the West, higher productivity historically led to higher wages that created a massive middle class which consumed products and fueled more economic growth.
But the coming AI economy may not follow this same trajectory, since a company can reap huge productivity gains without hiring thousands of workers or raising wages.
uncertain
company → lead → wages
The bind is worse for China, where the pressure of an ageing and shrinking population creates an incentive for Beijing to deploy AI rapidly to remain competitive.
asserted
Beijing → age → AI
However, going too fast could lead to social unrest by worsening youth unemployment.
uncertain
going → go → unemployment
America has its own problems, he said, including deficits of trillions of dollars which are a result of its industrial policy and trade surpluses.
asserted
which → have → policy
But it is capable of surprises when it leans into its longstanding strength: turning new science into profitable products faster than anyone else.
asserted
it → lean → anyone
“That is why, at least from Singapore’s perspective, we do not count America out.
asserted
we → count → America
It is still capable of pulling a rabbit out of the hat,” he said.
asserted
he → pull → hat
In an interview with the Singapore media on Sept 26 as he concluded his trip to New York to attend the United Nations General Assembly, Balakrishnan said the exchange with Rudd was an effort at understanding a world being reshaped by the US-China relationship and their rivalry on AI.
asserted
exchange → conclude → AI
“He pushed, I pushed back…
asserted
I → push → ?
the objective is to sharpen our perspectives,” Balakrishnan said.
asserted
Balakrishnan → sharpen → perspectives
“The people who watch that conversation don’t have to agree with Kevin or me, but if we have succeeded in making you think, then we have succeeded,” he said.
asserted
he → watch → Kevin
The Aporia
