Egypt’s intelligence chief Abbas Kamel travelled to Israel days before the October 7, 2023 Hamas attack and warned Israeli officials that Gaza was heading towards a dangerous escalation, according to a report by The Atlantic.
uncertain
Gaza → travel → Atlantic
Kamel arrived at Ben Gurion Airport on September 26, 2023, in a chartered plane linked to Egypt’s intelligence service, according to the report.
uncertain
Kamel → arrive → report
His visit came as Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and other leaders were marking the 50th anniversary of the Yom Kippur War, the surprise attack by Egypt and Syria that Israel has long treated as a lesson in intelligence failures.
asserted
Israel → come → failures
According to Israeli, Egyptian, Arab, US and European officials who were briefed on the visit after October 7, Kamel told Israeli officials that Hamas appeared to be preparing for a major attack.
uncertain
Hamas → accord → attack
He urged Israel to make economic concessions to Hamas to prevent the situation from spiralling.
asserted
He → urge → situation
One former Israeli official later briefed on the meeting told The Atlantic that Kamel’s message was essentially that Gaza was on the verge of exploding if Israel did not change course.
asserted
Israel → brief → course
However, Kamel did not provide a specific date or details of the multipronged attack that Hamas would launch less than two weeks later.
asserted
Hamas → provide → that
The Egyptian plane remained at Ben Gurion Airport for about 67 minutes before returning to Cairo, according to an Israeli airport-authority flight log.
uncertain
plane → remain → log
It remains unclear exactly which Israeli officials Kamel met during the visit.
uncertain
Kamel → remain → visit
What Israel did with the warning remains unclear
The report said officials from seven countries believed the visit should have raised alarms within Israel’s senior leadership.
uncertain
visit → remain → leadership
Netanyahu’s office, however, denied after the October 7 attack that the prime minister had received warnings from Egypt.
asserted
minister → deny → Egypt
Tzachi Hanegbi, who was then head of Israel’s national-security council, also denied to
The Atlantic that Kamel had visited Israel or delivered an Egyptian warning.
asserted
Kamel → deny → warning
The September 2023 visit was not the only warning Israel received.
asserted
Israel → receive → ?
According to
The Atlantic, Egypt continued raising concerns about Hamas in the days before October 7, while the UAE's president Mohamed bin Zayed also warned Netanyahu about the possibility of a major attack after receiving intelligence from Egyptian and Palestinian sources.
uncertain
Zayed → accord → sources
A UN envoy had publicly warned on September 27 that the situation around Gaza could have “grave consequences”, while international negotiators were trying to prevent an escalation.
uncertain
negotiators → warn → escalation
Gaza tensions were already rising
In the weeks before the attack, tensions around Gaza had been increasing.
asserted
tensions → rise → Gaza
Qatar had frozen fuel deliveries to Gaza, while Hamas called for demonstrations at the Erez border crossing.
asserted
Hamas → freeze → crossing
Israel closed the crossing in September after protests.
asserted
Israel → close → protests
Around 18,000 Gazans had permits to work in Israel, and their inability to cross added to tensions.
asserted
inability → have → tensions
Egyptian, Qatari and UN negotiators subsequently worked to restore calm, with discussions involving work permits, fuel supplies and other measures.
asserted
negotiators → work → permits
Those efforts temporarily eased tensions.
asserted
efforts → ease → tensions
Hamas agreed to pull people back from the border fence, while Israel agreed to reopen the Erez crossing and restore a medical-supply line into Gaza.
asserted
Israel → agree → Gaza
But, according to negotiators cited by The Atlantic, Hamas was using the talks to buy time while continuing preparations for its attack.
uncertain
Hamas → accord → attack
The report also said Egypt continued to raise alarms up to two days before October 7.
asserted
Egypt → say → October
Most of the warnings did not contain a date, target or method of attack, but US, Israeli and Egyptian officials described them as frequent and persistent.
asserted
officials → contain → them
The October 7 Hamas attack killed about 1,200 people, primarily civilians, and resulted in 251 people being taken hostage.
asserted
people → kill → people
Israel subsequently launched its military campaign in Gaza.
asserted
Israel → launch → Gaza
The extent to which the warnings could have changed the outcome remains impossible to determine.
uncertain
warnings → change → outcome
But the newly reported details of Kamel’s visit add to the continuing questions over what Israeli officials knew before October 7 and how those warnings were assessed.
asserted
warnings → report → October
The Aporia
