The conversation regarding higher education has been all doom and gloom from the general public.
asserted
conversation → regard → public
Critics point out that many campuses have devolved into ideological echo chambers, where free expression is stifled and the fear of being “canceled” keeps students quiet.
asserted
fear → point → students
Since the arrival of advanced generative AI, administrators have feared for the future of higher education.
asserted
administrators → fear → education
Essays have become obsolete, as students can now ask a chatbot to write a perfectly edited 12-page paper on the French Revolution in under 10 seconds.
asserted
students → become → seconds
How are professors supposed to measure what a student learned and retained?
asserted
student → suppose → what
At first glance, these seem like two distinct crises.
asserted
these → seem → crises
Universities are looking to solve the crisis of AI, and it is actually forcing them to solve the crisis of free expression.
asserted
it → look → expression
Because written assignments can no longer be trusted, higher education is being forced to return to the oldest and most human method of learning in history, the Socratic method.
asserted
education → write → history
Across the country, professors are discovering the best way to prove a student has absorbed the material is by asking them to explain it verbally.
asserted
student → discover → it
We are seeing a massive resurgence in oral exams, live debates, and classroom dialogue.
asserted
We → see → exams
AI is unable to help you fake your way through an oral defense.
asserted
you → help → defense
When asked to defend their argument in real time, they have to rely on their own intellect and preparation.
asserted
they → ask → intellect
Education that simply requires students to write an essay that only professors will read, it is very easy for a student to simply regurgitate the professor’s ideological beliefs to secure a good grade.
asserted
student → require → grade
It is purely transactional, lacking any form of engagement.
asserted
It → lack → engagement
But an education that requires students to articulate their own thoughts out loud, defend unexpected questions, and debate their peers and professors, the entire learning process shifts.
asserted
process → require → peers
These types of environments force students to take ownership of their ideas.
asserted
types → force → ideas
Now students are obligated to think critically, instead of copying and pasting whatever is politically correct.
asserted
whatever → obligate → ?
The current news cycle shows you a fearful political Left.
asserted
cycle → show → Left
We hear calls for increased regulations and demands for tech CEOs to slow down the pace of AI innovation.
asserted
CEOs → hear → innovation
While framed as caution, this fear stems from the deeper realization that the introduction of AI is stripping the Left of its ability to maintain control over the indoctrination mechanism of the higher education establishment.
asserted
introduction → frame → establishment
This resurgence of oral debate places a massive responsibility squarely on the shoulders of university administrators and faculty.
asserted
resurgence → place → administrators
If higher education is moving toward a more Socratic method of education, then we must guarantee that the classroom is a safe space for all types of thought.
asserted
classroom → move → thought
You cannot force students to engage in debate if they sense their opinion will be “wrong” simply because it is not the popular opinion.
asserted
it → force → debate
If having those opinions results in lower grades or social ostracization, AI was not the biggest problem at that university.
asserted
AI → have → university
Higher education has spent the majority of the 21st century allowing a culture of censorship to fester, allowing the loudest, most radical voices on campus to dictate what can and cannot be said.
asserted
what → spend → campus
But if AI forces us to return to the Socratic method, censorship must end.
asserted
censorship → force → method
Administrators and professors need to create an environment where students feel secure enough to express dissenting opinions verbally without facing repercussions.
asserted
students → need → repercussions
The classroom has to once again become a sanctuary for the free exchange of ideas, where arguments are defeated by better arguments, not censorship.
asserted
arguments → have → arguments
True learning demands friction, and friction requires the freedom to disagree.
asserted
friction → demand → freedom
For all the anxiety surrounding AI, it may turn out to be the catalyst universities needed.
uncertain
universities → surround → AI
AI is stripping away the illusion of passive learning.
asserted
AI → strip → learning
It is forcing students to look up from their screens and defend what they believe.
asserted
they → force → what
If universities rise to the occasion and fiercely protect the freedom of speech necessary for this style of education, AI will not be the death of higher education.
It will be its resurrection.
Dr. Kent Ingle is president of Southeastern University.
asserted
Ingle → rise → University
The Aporia
